ASPCA Pet Insurance vs. Trupanion

Two of the most renowned providers are ASPCA Pet Insurance and Trupanion. Each has its strengths, weaknesses, and unique offerings that distinguish it from the rest. In this article, we will compare ASPCA Pet Insurance and Trupanion to help you make an informed decision about which provider might be the best fit for you and your furry friend.

Contents hide

Understanding Pet Insurance

Pet insurance is designed to help pet owners offset the costs of veterinary care. Policies typically cover illnesses and injuries, but the exact coverage and payout structure depend on the provider and the specific plan you choose.

ASPCA Pet Insurance: Overview

ASPCA Pet Insurance is a well-known provider that offers comprehensive coverage options for both accidents and illnesses. They provide various policy options that allow you to choose the best one based on your pet’s breed, age, and health condition.

Strengths of ASPCA Pet Insurance

  1. Coverage Options: ASPCA offers extensive coverage, including accidents, illnesses, hereditary and congenital conditions, behavioral issues, and alternative therapies. They also provide optional preventative care coverage at additional cost.
  2. Flexibility: ASPCA allows policyholders to customize their reimbursement level, deductible, and annual limit, offering more flexibility to adjust the cost of the policy.
  3. Multiple Pet Discount: ASPCA offers a 10% discount for each subsequent pet you enroll.

Weaknesses of ASPCA Pet Insurance

  1. Age Limitations: ASPCA has certain age restrictions for enrollment. Pets must be at least 8 weeks old, and there’s an upper age limit for illness coverage (14 years for dogs and 15 years for cats).
  2. Preventative Care Cost: The optional wellness coverage can make the overall cost of the policy significantly higher.

Trupanion: Overview

Trupanion is another top-tier pet insurance provider known for its straightforward, comprehensive one-plan policy.

Strengths of Trupanion

  1. Comprehensive Coverage: Trupanion offers a single, comprehensive policy that covers a wide array of conditions, including hereditary and congenital issues, illnesses, accidents, and more.
  2. Direct Payment to Vets: Trupanion stands out due to its ability to pay the vet directly, which can be a relief in high-cost situations where upfront payment may be challenging.
  3. No Payout Limits: Trupanion offers unlimited lifetime benefits with no caps on per-incident, annual, or lifetime payouts.

Weaknesses of Trupanion

  1. Price: Trupanion’s comprehensive coverage tends to be more expensive than many other pet insurance policies.
  2. Deductible Structure: Trupanion uses a per-condition deductible, which means you must pay the deductible for each new condition, which can add up if your pet has multiple unrelated issues in a year.

ASPCA Pet Insurance: Delving Deeper

Policy Customization

ASPCA’s comprehensive coverage extends to diagnostic tests, surgeries, hospitalization, prescription medications, and even behavioral therapies. A standout feature of ASPCA is its highly customizable plans, allowing pet owners to tailor policies according to their budget and their pet’s needs. This level of flexibility is quite beneficial for those who prefer a more personalized approach to pet insurance.

Wellness Add-ons

An optional wellness package known as ‘Preventive Care’ can be added to your base plan, covering routine vet care including vaccines, dental cleanings, and routine screenings. However, it’s worth noting that adding this coverage will increase your monthly premiums.

Waiting Periods

ASPCA has standard waiting periods before the coverage becomes effective: 14 days for illnesses and 2 days for accidents. It’s crucial for pet owners to understand these time frames to avoid any claim denial surprises.

Trupanion: A Closer Look

Straightforward Coverage

Trupanion’s one-plan approach simplifies the decision-making process. Their plan covers 90% of eligible costs related to unexpected illnesses and injuries, ranging from diagnostic tests to surgeries and medications. However, it’s essential to note that the policy does not cover exam fees, wellness and preventative care, or pre-existing conditions.

Lifetime Per Condition Deductible

Unique to Trupanion is its lifetime per-condition deductible, rather than an annual one. This means once you’ve met your deductible for a specific condition, coverage for that condition is deductible-free for the rest of your pet’s life. However, if your pet is prone to diverse health issues, these costs can add up.

Direct Vet Payment

Another feature setting Trupanion apart is their ability to pay the vet directly at the time of check-out. This avoids the usual “pay first, get reimbursed later” model that most pet insurances follow, providing financial relief for pet owners during emergencies.

Exclusions and Limitations

Both ASPCA and Trupanion have exclusions typical of pet insurance providers, such as pre-existing conditions, breeding costs, and cosmetic procedures. It’s also worth mentioning that while ASPCA offers coverage for some behavioral issues, Trupanion does not.

ASPCA has an upper age limit for new enrollments for illness coverage (14 years for dogs, 15 for cats), whereas Trupanion has no upper age limit, making it a potentially better choice for older pets. However, Trupanion’s policy becomes more expensive as your pet ages.

Customer Service and Claim Filing

When it comes to customer service, both companies have strong reputations. ASPCA and Trupanion offer 24/7 customer support and make claim filing relatively simple through online portals or mobile apps. Trupanion’s ability to pay vets directly can simplify the claims process further, particularly in emergency situations.

Premium Costs

The cost of pet insurance varies greatly based on factors such as the pet’s age, breed, location, and the chosen deductible and reimbursement level. In general, Trupanion’s premiums tend to be higher due to their comprehensive, unlimited benefits coverage. ASPCA offers more flexibility in adjusting your premium by offering a range of deductibles, annual limits, and reimbursement levels.

Which is Right for Your Pet?

ASPCA Pet Insurance may be an excellent choice for pet parents looking for customizable policies and optional wellness coverage. On the other hand, Trupanion could be perfect for those seeking simplicity, direct vet payment, and no worry about annual or lifetime payout limits.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What Does ASPCA Pet Insurance Exclude from Coverage?

ASPCA Pet Insurance doesn’t cover pre-existing conditions, which is a common exclusion among pet insurance providers. This means any condition that first occurred before the policy’s effective date or during the waiting period will not be covered.

Other exclusions include cosmetic procedures, breeding costs, and preventive care (unless you opt for the Preventive Care package). Be sure to review the policy document thoroughly to understand all exclusions.

2. How Does the Lifetime Per-Condition Deductible Work with Trupanion?

Trupanion’s lifetime per-condition deductible means that once you’ve met your deductible for a specific condition, you will never have to pay the deductible for that condition again. This feature can be beneficial if your pet has a chronic condition that requires ongoing treatment. However, for each new condition, a separate deductible applies, which can accumulate if your pet faces multiple health issues.

3. Does ASPCA Pet Insurance Offer Direct Vet Payment Like Trupanion?

ASPCA Pet Insurance does not offer direct vet payment, unlike Trupanion. Instead, pet owners will need to pay the vet bill upfront and then submit a claim for reimbursement. This process usually involves completing a claim form, attaching a copy of the vet’s invoice, and sending them to ASPCA for review.

4. Can I Adjust My Trupanion Coverage to Lower My Premiums?

Trupanion offers some level of customization to your policy by allowing you to choose your deductible, which can be set from $0 to $1000. Raising your deductible will lower your monthly premium. However, unlike ASPCA, Trupanion does not allow you to adjust your reimbursement rate or set an annual limit to decrease your premium cost.

5. Are Older Pets Eligible for Coverage Under ASPCA and Trupanion?

While Trupanion does not have an upper age limit for enrolling pets, ASPCA does impose age restrictions. ASPCA’s illness coverage is only available for pets younger than 14 years (for dogs) or 15 years (for cats) at the time of enrollment. It’s crucial to understand these limitations, especially if you have an older pet that you’re considering insuring.

6. Do Both Companies Cover Hereditary and Congenital Conditions?

Yes, both ASPCA Pet Insurance and Trupanion cover hereditary and congenital conditions as long as they aren’t pre-existing. This includes conditions your pet is born with or are prone to because of their breed. However, it’s essential to enroll your pet in insurance before any symptoms of these conditions appear, or they may be considered pre-existing and excluded from coverage.

7. How Long Does It Take to Get Reimbursed After Filing a Claim?

The claim reimbursement time can vary. However, typically, ASPCA aims to process claims within 30 days of receipt, while Trupanion strives for a 60-day timeframe. Both companies offer the option of direct deposit for reimbursements, which can expedite the payment process.

8. Do ASPCA and Trupanion Cover Prescription Medications?

Yes, both ASPCA and Trupanion provide coverage for prescription medications. This is an essential feature since these medications can be quite expensive, especially for chronic conditions. However, over-the-counter medications are typically not covered unless explicitly stated in the policy.

9. Can I Visit Any Vet with ASPCA and Trupanion Insurance?

Absolutely, both ASPCA Pet Insurance and Trupanion allow you to visit any licensed vet, emergency care clinic, or specialty hospital. This freedom can be particularly beneficial in emergency situations when your primary vet may not be available.

10. Will ASPCA and Trupanion Insurance Cover Dental Problems?

ASPCA Pet Insurance covers dental diseases such as periodontal disease and tooth infections as part of their comprehensive coverage. However, it does not cover routine dental care unless the preventive care add-on package is purchased.

On the other hand, Trupanion covers dental illnesses, including tooth extractions and root canals, but does not cover dental cleanings or any condition related to biting or chewing.

11. How Do ASPCA and Trupanion Handle Chronic Conditions?

ASPCA and Trupanion both provide coverage for chronic conditions as long as these conditions aren’t deemed pre-existing. A chronic condition diagnosed after you’ve enrolled and passed the waiting period would be covered. However, if the condition was present before enrolling or during the waiting period, it would not be covered.

12. Are Alternative Therapies Covered by ASPCA and Trupanion?

ASPCA Pet Insurance offers coverage for alternative therapies such as acupuncture, physiotherapy, and chiropractic care when performed by a licensed veterinarian and deemed necessary for treating a covered condition.

Trupanion also covers alternative treatments and therapies, including hydrotherapy, for any new illness or injury after enrollment, making it a good option for those seeking a holistic approach to pet healthcare.

13. Do ASPCA and Trupanion Offer Multi-Pet Discounts?

ASPCA Pet Insurance offers a 10% multi-pet discount for each subsequent pet you enroll, making it a cost-effective option for multi-pet households. Trupanion, however, does not offer a multi-pet discount at the time of writing.

14. What Happens If I Want to Cancel My Pet Insurance Policy?

If you choose to cancel your pet insurance policy with either ASPCA or Trupanion, it’s generally as simple as contacting their customer service. With ASPCA, if you cancel within the first 30 days and have not received payment or are not entitled to receive payment for any claim, you’re entitled to a full refund. Trupanion also has a 30-day money-back guarantee if no claims have been paid.

15. Can I Choose My Own Deductible and Reimbursement Level with ASPCA and Trupanion?

With ASPCA, you have the flexibility to choose your own deductible, ranging from $100 to $500, and your reimbursement level, between 70% to 90%. This flexibility allows you to tailor the policy to suit your financial situation.

Conversely, Trupanion has a fixed reimbursement level of 90% but allows you to choose your own deductible, between $0 to $1,000. Remember, a higher deductible will result in lower premiums, but it means you’ll pay more out-of-pocket when you make a claim.

16. How Does Enrollment Age Impact the Coverage?

The age at which you enroll your pet can impact the coverage they’re eligible for. Trupanion has no upper age limit for coverage, meaning you can enroll your pet at any age, though conditions present before the policy effective date or during the waiting period won’t be covered.

ASPCA offers comprehensive accident and illness coverage for pets as young as 8 weeks. However, there’s an upper age limit for illness coverage—14 years for dogs and 15 years for cats. After this, only accident coverage is available.

17. Are Behavior Issues Covered by ASPCA and Trupanion?

ASPCA covers behavioral issues, offering coverage for conditions like anxiety and compulsive behavior, provided they aren’t linked to preventable conditions or pre-existing conditions.

Trupanion also covers treatments for behavioral modification, including therapy and medication, as long as the condition is not pre-existing, and the behavior is not associated with a lack of training or preventable conditions.

18. Do ASPCA and Trupanion Insurance Cover Specialist Referrals?

Yes, both ASPCA and Trupanion cover visits to veterinary specialists. If your pet needs to see a cardiologist, dermatologist, oncologist, or another type of specialist for a covered condition, both insurance companies will cover these visits under their standard plans.

19. Do ASPCA and Trupanion Offer Coverage for Cancer Treatments?

Cancer treatments are covered by both ASPCA and Trupanion, given that the cancer was not present or diagnosed before the policy start date or during the waiting period. This coverage includes chemotherapy, radiation therapy, surgery, hospitalization, and medications.

20. What Is the Claims Process Like for ASPCA and Trupanion?

Both ASPCA and Trupanion allow policyholders to submit claims online or via email or fax. After paying your vet bill, you’ll need to submit the claim form along with detailed invoices from your vet to the insurance company. Trupanion also offers the unique feature of direct payment to the vet, removing the need for the pet owner to pay large upfront costs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top