Nationwide Pet Insurance vs Lemonade

As a pet parent, nothing is more important than your furry friend’s health. Ensuring your pet has access to the right medical care when they need it can be quite expensive. Hence, pet insurance has become a must-have for many. Among a myriad of options in the market, Nationwide and Lemonade are two popular choices. This comprehensive comparison of Nationwide and Lemonade pet insurance will help you make an informed decision.

What is Lemonade Pet Insurance?

Lemonade Pet Insurance is a fairly recent entrant into the pet insurance industry. Known for their user-friendly app and straightforward coverage options, Lemonade offers a modern approach to pet insurance. They’ve gained popularity due to their competitive pricing and the ability to customize coverage based on the pet owner’s budget and the pet’s health needs.

Key Features of Lemonade

  • Customizable plans: Lemonade provides you with the ability to customize your policy, including the deductible, payout limit, and reimbursement percentage.
  • Affordability: Lemonade typically offers more affordable premiums compared to other providers.
  • Quick Claims Processing: Leveraging AI technology, Lemonade can often process claims quickly, sometimes in just a few minutes.
  • Preventive Care Package: For an additional cost, Lemonade provides coverage for wellness visits, vaccines, and routine care, which isn’t always offered by other providers.
  • No Upper Age Limit: Lemonade doesn’t have an upper age limit for insuring pets, making it an excellent option for older pets.

What is Nationwide Pet Insurance?

Nationwide is a well-known name in the insurance industry, including pet insurance. Nationwide Pet Insurance, formerly known as VPI, provides comprehensive plans covering various illnesses and injuries, wellness care, and even exotic pets.

Key Features of Nationwide

  • Wide Coverage: Nationwide covers a vast range of conditions, including hereditary and congenital diseases.
  • Wellness Plan Options: Nationwide offers comprehensive wellness plans that cover preventive care, including vaccinations, dental cleanings, and routine check-ups.
  • Exotic Pet Insurance: One unique feature of Nationwide is that they also cover birds, reptiles, and other exotic pets, unlike most other insurers.
  • Direct Payment to Vets: Nationwide can pay veterinarians directly, which means less out-of-pocket costs for pet owners.

Lemonade vs Nationwide: Side by Side

While both Lemonade and Nationwide offer comprehensive pet insurance, there are several key differences between them:

  • Price: Lemonade usually offers lower premiums than Nationwide, but rates can vary based on your pet’s breed, age, and location.
  • Coverage: Nationwide offers more comprehensive coverage, including for exotic pets, but Lemonade allows you to customize your policy to match your specific needs.
  • Claims Process: Lemonade’s claims process is known for its speed and simplicity thanks to its use of AI, while Nationwide employs a traditional claims process that may take longer.
  • Preventive Care: Both offer preventive care options, but these come standard in some of Nationwide’s plans, while Lemonade offers this as an add-on to their accident and illness policy.

Lemonade vs Nationwide: Detailed Policy Coverage

Both Nationwide and Lemonade have unique offerings in terms of policy coverage. Let’s delve into the specifics:

Illness and Injury Coverage

Nationwide offers a Whole Pet with Wellness plan that provides nose-to-tail coverage, including accidents, illnesses, and even wellness care. This comprehensive coverage also includes hereditary and congenital conditions, cancer treatments, dental diseases, and behavioral treatments.

On the other hand, Lemonade provides coverage for accidents and illnesses as part of their base policy. It covers diagnostics, procedures, and medication required for the treatment of accidents or illnesses. Additionally, Lemonade offers coverage for microchip implantation – a standout feature that many other insurance providers lack.

Preventive and Wellness Coverage

For preventive and wellness coverage, Lemonade offers a Preventive and Wellness package as an add-on to their standard policy. This package covers annual wellness exams, vaccines, heartworm and parasite screening, and spay/neuter surgery, among other services.

On the flip side, Nationwide includes wellness care as part of their Whole Pet with Wellness plan, covering routine exams, tests, and procedures, including vaccinations, fecal tests, deworming, and dental cleanings. This comprehensive approach to wellness coverage by Nationwide is certainly a standout feature.

Coverage for Breed-Specific and Hereditary Conditions

Lemonade does not explicitly exclude coverage for hereditary and breed-specific conditions, which means such conditions are likely to be covered provided they are not pre-existing.

In contrast, Nationwide specifically covers hereditary and congenital conditions, which is beneficial for pet parents of purebred animals that are predisposed to certain genetic health issues.

Policy Exclusions and Limitations

Every insurance policy has its exclusions, and pet insurance is no exception. Both Lemonade and Nationwide exclude pre-existing conditions from their coverage – a standard exclusion in the pet insurance industry.

Lemonade’s policy excludes some additional aspects, including breeding costs, cosmetic procedures, and behavioral treatments unless you opt for their extended accident and illness package.

Nationwide’s policy also excludes certain specifics like breeding and pregnancy, grooming, boarding, and storage or disposal fees. It’s crucial for pet owners to closely review these exclusions before selecting a policy.

Customer Service and Claims Process

When it comes to the claims process, Lemonade takes advantage of its tech-driven model. Pet parents can file claims directly through the Lemonade app, and their use of AI means claims are often processed and paid out within minutes.

Nationwide, while maintaining a more traditional approach, has a robust online portal where pet parents can submit and track their claims. Nationwide’s turnaround is typically longer than Lemonade’s lightning-quick process, but they have the added advantage of being able to make direct payments to vets, minimizing upfront costs for the pet owner.

Customer service experiences can be subjective. However, both Nationwide and Lemonade have generally positive reviews regarding their customer service. Lemonade’s app-focused approach means that they are often a good fit for tech-savvy pet owners who prefer managing their policies digitally, while Nationwide might be more suited to those who prefer a more traditional approach, including the option for phone support.


When it comes to choosing between Lemonade and Nationwide pet insurance, it’s all about your pet’s specific needs and your budget. Lemonade may be the better option if affordability and quick claims processing are your top priorities. In contrast, Nationwide could be the better fit if you need comprehensive coverage, have an exotic pet, or want preventive care included in your policy. Always remember to read the fine print and understand what each policy covers before making your final decision. With careful consideration, you can ensure your pet is covered and enjoy peace of mind knowing they’ll receive the care they need.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does pet insurance work with a veterinarian?

Pet insurance typically operates on a reimbursement model. You’ll pay your vet for the medical services, then submit a claim to your insurance provider for covered costs. Some providers, like Nationwide, can also make direct payments to vets, reducing your out-of-pocket costs.

Is there a waiting period for Nationwide and Lemonade pet insurance?

Yes, both insurers have waiting periods. For Lemonade, there’s a 2-day waiting period for accidents and a 14-day waiting period for illnesses and orthopedic conditions. Nationwide has a slightly longer waiting period – 14 days for both accidents and illnesses.

Do Nationwide and Lemonade pet insurance cover prescription medications?

Both providers do offer coverage for prescription medications as part of their standard policies. However, it’s crucial to read the policy details as certain limitations or caps might apply.

Are chronic conditions covered?

Lemonade and Nationwide both cover chronic conditions as long as they aren’t pre-existing. So, if your pet develops a chronic condition while covered, the necessary treatments should be covered under the policy.

Are alternative therapies covered by these pet insurances?

Alternative treatments like acupuncture, physiotherapy, and chiropractic care are covered by Nationwide under its Whole Pet with Wellness plan. Lemonade also covers alternative therapies if they are deemed necessary and provided by a licensed vet.

What is the age limit for pets to be insured by Lemonade and Nationwide?

Nationwide does not have an upper age limit for enrolling pets, making it an excellent choice for older pets. Lemonade, on the other hand, only covers pets under the age of 14. However, once your pet is enrolled, Lemonade will continue to cover them regardless of age.

How do deductible, reimbursement level, and annual limit affect the insurance premium?

The deductible, reimbursement level, and annual limit are the key factors that affect your premium. A higher deductible will lower your premium, but you’ll pay more out-of-pocket when you make a claim. A higher reimbursement level increases your premium, but you’ll be reimbursed more for each claim. Lastly, a lower annual limit will reduce your premium, but it also means there’s a cap on the amount the insurer will pay within a year. It’s important to balance these factors according to your pet’s needs and your financial capacity.

Are spaying and neutering procedures covered?

With Lemonade, spay/neuter surgeries are covered if you choose the Preventive and Wellness package. Nationwide covers these procedures under its Whole Pet with Wellness plan. These procedures are generally not covered under basic accident and illness policies.

What happens if I miss a premium payment for my pet insurance?

Both Nationwide and Lemonade would typically provide a grace period if you miss a premium payment. If payment is not made within this period, your policy may be cancelled. It’s crucial to contact your provider as soon as you realize you’ve missed a payment to understand your options and prevent lapses in coverage.

Can I visit any vet with Lemonade and Nationwide pet insurance?

Yes, both Lemonade and Nationwide allow you to visit any licensed vet, emergency clinic, or specialist in the country. There are no network restrictions, giving pet parents the flexibility to choose the best care provider for their pets.

How does Lemonade and Nationwide handle bilateral conditions?

Bilateral conditions are those that can occur on both sides of the pet’s body, like hip dysplasia. Both Nationwide and Lemonade treat bilateral conditions as one condition. If a condition exists on one side of the pet’s body at the time of enrollment, and later develops on the other side, it’s considered pre-existing and won’t be covered.

Are pre-existing conditions ever covered?

Unfortunately, no. Like all pet insurers, neither Nationwide nor Lemonade covers pre-existing conditions. These are defined as conditions that showed signs or symptoms before the policy start date or during the waiting period.

Does pet insurance increase with age?

Yes, pet insurance premiums generally increase as your pet gets older. This is because older pets are more likely to have health issues and require more veterinary care. Both Nationwide and Lemonade take your pet’s age into account when calculating premiums.

Is congenital or hereditary disease coverage included?

Nationwide specifically includes coverage for congenital and hereditary diseases in its plans. Lemonade, on the other hand, does not explicitly exclude these, implying that as long as these conditions aren’t pre-existing, they should be covered.

Do these pet insurances cover cancer treatments?

Yes, both Lemonade and Nationwide provide coverage for cancer treatments, including chemotherapy and radiation, as part of their accident and illness policies. This coverage is subject to each policy’s annual limit, deductible, and co-pay.

Can I adjust my coverage after enrolling?

With both Lemonade and Nationwide, you’re typically able to adjust your coverage even after enrolling. You can change your deductible, reimbursement level, or policy limit, but remember that changes may affect your premium. It’s important to contact your insurer to discuss the implications of any changes you wish to make.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top