Skip to content
Bestie Paws Hospital
Bestie Paws Hospital

  • 🏠 Home
  • πŸ“š Blog
  • 🌐 Contact Us
Bestie Paws Hospital

MetLife Pet Insurance

Bestie Paws, July 7, 2026July 7, 2026
πŸΎπŸ›‘οΈ
Reviews Β· Claims Β· Phone Β· Cancel Β· Heartworm Β· Non-Renewal Β· Preventive 575 Β· Heart Murmur Β· UTI

MetLife entered pet insurance in 2020 and has grown fast β€” winning “Pet Insurance of the Year” four consecutive times and earning 5 stars from NerdWallet. But customer reviews tell a more complicated story about claims, premium jumps, and non-renewal notices. This guide gives you both sides, plainly.

πŸ“°
Trending Right Now β€” The Premium Jump Problem

The complaint pattern dominating MetLife pet insurance reviews in mid-2026 is dramatic premium increases as pets age. One verified Trustpilot review documents a policy that started at roughly $60 per month for a puppy in 2023 and reached approximately $189 per month by 2026 β€” more than triple in three years. Separately, BBB complaints describe a pattern where MetLife issues non-renewal notices to policyholders whose pets have made multiple claims, while also flagging waiting-period illnesses as pre-existing to deny future coverage. The NAIC has noted pet insurance as a growing category needing clearer consumer disclosure standards β€” particularly around how premium increases are calculated at renewal and under what circumstances policies can be non-renewed. If you’re researching MetLife pet insurance right now, understanding renewal risk is as important as understanding what the base plan covers.

πŸ”‘ The MetLife Advantage That Most Reviews Miss β€” And the Fine Print That Matters

MetLife’s pet insurance (underwritten by Metropolitan General Insurance Company, not MetLife Inc. itself) has a genuinely strong base plan: it covers UTIs, heart murmurs, hereditary conditions like hip dysplasia, cruciate ligament injuries, dental disease, holistic therapy, grief counseling, and even boarding costs if you’re hospitalized β€” items that many competitors charge extra for or exclude entirely. The accident waiting period is zero days, meaning coverage begins immediately for injuries. These are real advantages. The fine print that matters: you pay your vet first, then submit a claim for reimbursement. MetLife does not pay vets directly. The 15-day illness waiting period means any symptom that appears in the first two weeks β€” even something that seems unrelated β€” can be classified as a pre-existing condition and excluded from all future coverage for that condition. That single clause is behind a significant share of the complaints you’ll find if you dig past the Trustpilot homepage.

πŸ“Š MetLife Pet Insurance β€” Key Numbers at a Glance
Average Monthly Cost Β· Dogs
~$35–$90
Varies by breed, age, zip code, and deductible selection
Average Monthly Cost Β· Cats
~$20–$45
Below industry average for cats in most states
Reimbursement Options
50–90%
50, 70, 80, or 90% β€” applies after annual deductible
Accident Waiting Period
0 days
Accident coverage is immediate β€” industry-leading
Illness Waiting Period
15 days
Any symptom during this window = potential pre-existing exclusion
Healthy Pet Deductible Reward
βˆ’$50/yr
Deductible drops $50 each claim-free year β€” down to $0
πŸ“‹ What MetLife Covers β€” and What It Doesn’t

MetLife’s base plan is one of the most inclusive on the market. These tables show what’s covered and what’s excluded, including several answers to specific questions people search for β€” heartworm, UTIs, heart murmurs.

βœ… What IS Covered
  • Accidents and new illnesses
  • UTIs (urinary tract infections)
  • Heart murmurs (hereditary/congenital)
  • Heartworm treatment (if infected)
  • Cancer treatment
  • Hip dysplasia & cruciate ligament
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions
  • Dental disease (all teeth)
  • Vet exam fees when sick
  • Surgery, hospitalization, emergency
  • X-rays, MRIs, blood work
  • Prescription medications and food
  • Holistic care (acupuncture, chiro)
  • Grief counseling when pet dies
  • Boarding fees (owner hospitalized)
  • Cremation and burial
  • Lost pet advertising (up to $500)
  • Exotic pets (22 states)
βœ— What Is NOT Covered
  • Pre-existing conditions
  • Illness during 15-day waiting period
  • Routine wellness (without add-on)
  • Heartworm prevention (base plan)
  • Vitamins and non-prescription food (base plan)
  • Cosmetic procedures (ear cropping, declawing)
  • Breeding, pregnancy, whelping
  • Elective and experimental procedures
  • Organ transplants
  • Obedience and behavior training (base plan)
  • Racing or commercial guarding injuries
  • Grooming and nail trimming
  • Treatment by unlicensed vets
  • Care outside U.S. (and some Canada)
πŸ” What the “Preventive 575” Plan Actually Covers β€” Explained Simply

The Preventive 575 is MetLife’s higher-tier wellness add-on (the other is called Preventive 365). It’s an optional add-on to the accident and illness base policy β€” not a standalone product. For roughly $20–$40 extra per month, it reimburses up to $575 annually for routine care items including annual wellness exams, vaccinations, flea and tick prevention, heartworm testing and prevention medication, dental cleanings, spay or neuter surgery, microchipping, routine blood and urine tests, and fecal exams. The 575 plan doesn’t kick in for emergencies or chronic conditions β€” it’s designed purely for routine, predictable care that you’d spend money on anyway. Whether it’s “worth it” depends on how much routine care your pet gets annually: if your yearly wellness costs regularly exceed $575 out of pocket, the add-on pays for itself. If your pet is young and healthy with minimal routine expenses, the math may not work in your favor.

πŸ“‹ Key Questions β€” Straight Answers First

The things people search for most about MetLife pet insurance β€” answered directly before the longer context below each one.

  • 1
    How much is MetLife Pet Insurance monthly? Roughly $35–$90 per month for dogs and $20–$45 for cats, depending heavily on your pet’s breed, age, and your zip code. A younger mixed-breed dog in a mid-cost state typically runs $35–$55. A 6-year-old purebred in a high-cost state can exceed $80.
    MetLife’s pricing sits slightly below the industry average for comparable coverage β€” their average for a dog with a $5,000 annual limit runs around $81 per month versus the industry average of roughly $85. That advantage erodes as pets age. Multiple customer reviews document premiums tripling or quadrupling over three to four years as dogs move from puppy to young adult to middle age. When getting a quote, ask MetLife specifically for projected renewal rates at your pet’s age 4, 6, and 8 β€” this information is available on request in most states and gives you a realistic long-term cost picture rather than just the entry-year price.
  • 2
    Does MetLife pet insurance cover UTIs? Yes β€” urinary tract infections are covered as illnesses under the standard accident and illness plan, provided the UTI is not a pre-existing condition and didn’t occur during the 15-day waiting period.
    MetLife explicitly lists infections including UTIs in its coverage documentation. The practical concern: if your pet visited the vet for any urinary symptom β€” frequent urination, straining, blood in urine β€” within the 15-day waiting period after enrollment, that symptom could be classified as pre-existing and all future UTI-related claims denied. The same logic applies if your pet had a UTI diagnosis before you enrolled. This is the clause in pet insurance that catches the most people off guard, because conditions like UTIs can recur regularly in cats and certain dog breeds. If your pet has a history of urinary issues, ask MetLife specifically how prior UTIs will affect future coverage before enrolling.
  • 3
    Will MetLife pet insurance cover a heart murmur? Yes β€” heart murmurs are covered as hereditary and congenital conditions under the standard plan. However, a murmur diagnosed before enrollment or detected during the 15-day waiting period will be excluded as pre-existing.
    MetLife specifically covers hereditary and congenital heart conditions, which includes heart murmurs. This is worth noting because some pet insurers exclude hereditary conditions or require a rider. MetLife’s base plan includes them. A critical clarification: if your vet has noted a murmur in your pet’s medical records at any prior visit β€” even a passing notation of “grade 1 murmur, monitor” β€” that becomes a pre-existing condition under any pet insurer, including MetLife. When you apply, MetLife doesn’t review your pet’s prior records during enrollment. They pull them when you file a claim. Surprises at claim time are the source of many BBB complaints. For breeds genetically prone to cardiac conditions (Cavalier King Charles Spaniels, Dobermans, Boxers), enroll young, before any murmur has been documented anywhere.
  • 4
    Does MetLife pet insurance cover heartworm? Treatment for an active heartworm infection: yes, covered under the base plan. Heartworm prevention medication: only covered with the optional Preventive Care add-on (Preventive 365 or 575).
    This is the most searched heartworm question and the distinction trips people up. If your dog tests positive for heartworm and needs treatment β€” which can cost $600–$3,000 or more depending on severity β€” MetLife’s standard plan covers the treatment, diagnostic testing, and medications. If you want reimbursement for the monthly or semi-annual prevention medication you give a healthy dog to avoid infection in the first place, that’s a different category: routine preventive care, which requires the wellness add-on. Important note for cat owners: there is currently no FDA-approved drug to safely treat heartworm infection in cats, which means prevention is the only option, and that falls under the wellness add-on, not the base plan.
  • 5
    What is the MetLife pet insurance non-renewal situation? MetLife can choose not to renew a policy in some states and circumstances, typically after repeated large claims. This is a real documented concern, not just a rumor β€” BBB complaints describe non-renewal notices. Understanding your state’s pet insurance regulations matters here.
    Pet insurance is regulated at the state level, and the rules around non-renewal differ between states. In most states, insurers can non-renew a policy with sufficient notice β€” typically 30 to 60 days β€” and without requiring a specific reason. Multiple BBB complaints describe MetLife non-renewing policies for dogs with expensive or frequent claims, leaving owners in a difficult position: their pet now has documented conditions that will be pre-existing at any new insurer. If non-renewal happens to you, immediately request the reason in writing, file a complaint with your state insurance commissioner if the notice doesn’t follow required notification periods, and contact MetLife’s appeals process before the renewal deadline passes. The NAIC’s consumer portal at naic.org can connect you to your state’s specific consumer protection office.
  • 6
    How do I file a MetLife pet insurance claim? Through the MetLife Pet app, the online portal, fax, or email. You pay your vet first, then submit a paid itemized invoice and your pet’s medical records. Most claims are processed within 10 business days. Reimbursement comes by check or direct deposit.
    The MetLife Pet app is widely praised for its ease of use β€” it’s one of the consistent positives in customer reviews. Upload your itemized invoice (every line item named separately, not a summary total) and your pet’s complete medical history. If your vet’s records are extensive, request them before your pet gets sick β€” scrambling for 5 years of records while also dealing with an ill pet is a documented point of frustration in multiple reviews. One recurring BBB complaint involves claims submitted via the app that “disappear” before processing β€” if this happens, immediately email the same documents to MetLife and request a confirmation that they’ve been received. Never rely solely on the app upload if the claim involves significant money. Keep copies of everything.
  • 7
    How do I cancel MetLife pet insurance? Call 877-549-1671 or 855-571-3425 during business hours. You can also email [email protected] to initiate a cancellation. Request written confirmation and a cancellation effective date. Get everything in writing before you stop paying.
    Before canceling, pull together your pet’s complete medical records from the entire period you were covered by MetLife. Every condition treated during that coverage becomes a pre-existing exclusion at your next insurer. The strategic question isn’t just “is there a cheaper plan?” β€” it’s “is there a cheaper plan that still covers the conditions my pet developed while at MetLife?” Get an explicit exclusion list from any prospective new insurer before you cancel. If your pet has had no significant health events during your MetLife coverage period, switching carries minimal risk. If your pet developed a chronic condition, the calculus is significantly more complicated. Also: if you enrolled through your employer, cancellation may follow different procedures than direct consumer policies β€” check with your HR department if applicable.
  • 8
    Is MetLife pet insurance good for multiple pets? Yes β€” MetLife’s Family Plan is one of its genuinely distinctive features. Up to three dogs or cats share one deductible and one annual coverage limit, reducing total out-of-pocket costs for households with multiple pets. There’s no cap on how many Family Plans a household can have.
    Most pet insurers treat each pet as a separate, independent policy with its own deductible. If you have three dogs and each has a $300 annual deductible, you’re paying up to $900 in deductible costs before any reimbursement begins. MetLife’s Family Plan pools all three pets under one shared deductible and one shared annual limit β€” so if one dog’s treatment exceeds the shared deductible, coverage kicks in for the others sooner. The trade-off: the shared annual limit means a year where multiple pets have significant expenses could exhaust the pool faster than individual policies would. For households where pets have historically had low to moderate individual expenses, the Family Plan generally reduces total cost. For households with one very sick pet alongside healthy ones, individual policies may be more protective.
πŸ” Your Situation β€” What MetLife Actually Looks Like for Different Pet Owners
I got MetLife through my employer. Is that the same as buying it directly?
EMPLOYER BENEFIT
The employer version includes one major advantage the direct-purchase version doesn’t: if you had pet insurance through a prior plan and switch to MetLife via your employer, MetLife may cover conditions that would otherwise be classified as pre-existing. This is explicitly listed as an employer-only benefit in MetLife’s policy documents β€” “Pre-existing coverage only available to individuals with active pet insurance coverage that have purchased MetLife Pet Insurance as part of an employer group benefit offering.” For pet owners with an older dog who already has documented health conditions, the employer pathway is meaningfully different from buying directly. If your employer offers MetLife pet insurance as a payroll-deducted benefit, ask specifically whether the pre-existing condition transition benefit applies to your specific plan β€” not all employer implementations include it. Also clarify cancellation procedures with your HR department, since employer-linked policies may have different termination processes than direct consumer accounts.
🏒 Employer plans: may cover prior pre-existing conditions βœ… Check specifically: does YOUR employer plan include this? πŸ“ž HR first: cancellation may differ from direct enrollment πŸ’° Payroll deduction: confirm payments are posting correctly
My claim was denied or the reimbursement amount is wrong. What now?
DENIED CLAIM Β· DISPUTE
Request the denial reason in writing before doing anything else β€” specifically asking which line in your pet’s medical records triggered the pre-existing classification, if that’s the stated reason. This is important because multiple BBB complaints document MetLife using inaccurate or incomplete veterinary notes as the basis for denials. One documented case involved a pet being misidentified by sex and incorrectly noted as having had a C-section when the birth was natural β€” errors that led to a pre-existing classification for a condition that didn’t exist. If the denial is based on a medical record error, your vet can issue a corrected record or written clarification. Submit this with a formal appeal. Keep a log of every contact with MetLife β€” date, time, name of representative, summary of conversation. If MetLife’s internal appeals process fails, file a complaint with your state insurance commissioner at naic.org. Regulators take pet insurance complaints seriously, particularly when they involve documentation errors or disputed pre-existing classifications.
πŸ“ Ask: which specific record entry triggered the denial βœ‰οΈ Vet can issue corrected notes β€” submit with formal appeal πŸ“‹ Log every call: date, rep name, what was said πŸ›οΈ Escalate: state insurance commissioner at naic.org
I just enrolled and my pet got sick during the 15-day waiting period. What happens?
WAITING PERIOD Β· NEW POLICY
Any illness or symptom that appears during the 15-day waiting period will be classified as a pre-existing condition for that condition going forward β€” even if the illness seems minor or unrelated to anything chronic. This is one of the sharpest pain points in customer reviews, because it feels unfair: you enrolled in good faith, your pet got sick two weeks in, and now that entire category of condition is excluded forever. The most documented version of this is a cat vomiting once during the waiting period β€” MetLife assigns a diagnosis to that symptom (often gastroenteritis), and when the cat later develops IBD or lymphoma, the earlier vomiting note is used to exclude coverage. If your pet develops any symptom in the first 15 days: do not wait to see if it resolves, document it clearly with your vet noting it as the first occurrence, and explicitly ask the vet to note in the record whether this is acute or could indicate a chronic condition. Clear, specific documentation from your vet at first presentation can matter significantly in later appeals.
⚠️ Any symptom in first 15 days = potential permanent exclusion πŸ“‹ Vet documentation: ask them to note first occurrence and severity 🐱 Most common trap: single vomiting episode β†’ gastroenteritis label πŸ“ž Contact MetLife immediately if pet is sick in waiting period
I have multiple pets β€” dog, cat, maybe an exotic. What’s the best MetLife setup?
MULTIPLE PETS Β· FAMILY PLAN
For two or three dogs and/or cats, MetLife’s Family Plan with a shared deductible is worth calculating before buying separate individual policies β€” in many households it reduces total annual out-of-pocket costs by $200–$500. The math: on a $300 shared deductible with three dogs, the first dog’s expenses count toward the shared pool. Once $300 is met, all three dogs have coverage applying β€” compared to three separate $300 deductibles where each dog must individually hit $300 before their coverage starts. If you also have an exotic pet (bird, rabbit, ferret, reptile, etc.), note that MetLife covers exotic pets only in 22 states β€” and exotic pets have a separate maximum coverage limit of $10,000 per year rather than the unlimited option available for dogs and cats. Exotic pets cannot be added to a Family Plan; they require a separate policy. Check metlifepetinsurance.com for current exotic pet state availability before assuming coverage is available where you live.
πŸ‘¨β€πŸ‘©β€πŸ‘§ Family Plan: up to 3 dogs/cats, 1 shared deductible πŸ“Š Calculate: shared vs. individual deductibles for your pets 🦜 Exotic pets: separate policy, 22 states only, $10K max πŸ‡ Check availability: metlifepetinsurance.com before enrolling exotic
My premiums have jumped significantly at renewal. Is that normal and what can I do?
PREMIUM INCREASES Β· RENEWAL
Premium increases at renewal are universal in pet insurance β€” every insurer does this as pets age and as veterinary care costs rise β€” but the magnitude documented in MetLife reviews suggests their increases can run steeper than competitors, particularly in the three-to-five-year range. One verified review documented premiums growing from approximately $60 to $189 per month over three years. There are limited options: you can increase your deductible to lower the monthly premium (this can be done at any time, not just at renewal), reduce your reimbursement percentage, or lower your annual coverage limit. You cannot increase coverage between renewals β€” only reduce it. Before accepting the renewal at the new rate, call MetLife at 877-549-1671 and ask specifically whether any discount applies to your situation (employer, multi-pet, military, claim-free discount). Then get quotes from two or three competitors β€” but before switching, confirm what conditions your pet has developed that would be excluded as pre-existing at the new insurer. The locked-in dynamic is real for pets with any health history.
πŸ“ž Call first: 877-549-1671 β€” ask about available discounts ⬆️ Reduce premium: raise deductible (allowed any time) πŸ“‹ Before switching: get exclusion list from new insurer first ⚠️ Your pet’s health history = pre-existing conditions everywhere
Is MetLife pet insurance the best option, or should I compare it to competitors?
COMPARISON Β· WHO OFFERS BEST
MetLife is a genuinely strong choice for zero-day accident coverage, Family Plans for multiple pets, exotic pet coverage, and the deductible-reduction reward for claim-free years. It’s not the right choice for people who need direct vet payment, the absolute lowest monthly cost, or maximum protection against renewal price escalation. The most direct competitors to compare: Trupanion pays vets directly (MetLife does not) and has no annual payout limit, but is typically more expensive upfront and requires a per-incident deductible rather than annual. Pets Best consistently runs lower monthly costs than MetLife and allows accident-only plans (MetLife doesn’t offer accident-only). Figo and Lemonade run leaner and cheaper but with narrower coverage and mixed claims reviews. ASPCA-backed insurance ranks well for comprehensive coverage at a competitive price point. If MetLife came up because your employer offered it or a union recommended it: the employer benefit’s potential pre-existing condition coverage advantage may make it worth prioritizing over independent competitors even if the monthly cost isn’t the lowest available.
βœ… MetLife best for: zero-day accidents, Family Plans, exotics πŸ” Trupanion: pays vet directly, per-incident deductible πŸ’° Cheaper base: Pets Best or Figo for budget-first buyers 🏒 Employer plan: check for pre-existing condition transition benefit
πŸ”‘ MetLife Pet Insurance β€” Contacts and Key Links
πŸ“ž Customer service: 877-549-1671 πŸ“ž Alternative line: 855-571-3425 βœ‰οΈ Feedback / complaints: [email protected] 🌐 Get a quote: metlifepetinsurance.com πŸ“± App: MetLife Pet Insurance (iOS + Android) πŸ“‹ Coverage details: metlifepetinsurance.com/coverage-exclusions πŸ›‘οΈ Preventive plans: metlifepetinsurance.com/preventive-care πŸ›οΈ NAIC consumer portal: naic.org/consumer ⭐ BBB profile: search “MetLife Pet Insurance” at bbb.org πŸ“ž State insurance commissioner: naic.org/state-map
βœ… 5 Things to Verify Before You Commit to MetLife
  • 1 Ask for projected renewal premiums at your pet’s age 4, 6, and 8 β€” not just the entry-year rate. MetLife is required to provide this on request in most states. The entry premium is rarely what you’ll pay long-term, and the gap between year-one and year-five pricing is the most consistent source of customer regret in reviews.
  • 2 Collect your pet’s complete veterinary records before the 15-day waiting period ends. Read them yourself. Note anything that could be interpreted as a symptom β€” even a passing mention of “occasional vomiting” or “soft stools” β€” because these become the basis for pre-existing condition denials if related conditions develop later. Knowledge of what’s in the records puts you in a better position to respond if a claim is denied.
  • 3 Set up direct deposit in the MetLife Pet app before you need it. Multiple customer reviews and BBB complaints cite checks being mailed to incorrect addresses, causing weeks-long reimbursement delays during already stressful situations. Confirm your direct deposit banking information in the app immediately after enrollment.
  • 4 If considering the Preventive 575 or 365 add-on, calculate what you actually spend on routine care annually first. Add up what you spend on wellness exams, vaccines, flea/tick/heartworm prevention, and any annual lab work. If that number regularly exceeds $575, the add-on pays for itself. If it doesn’t, you may be paying extra for reimbursements you’ll never fully use.
  • 5 Keep your own duplicate paper or digital file for every claim you submit. BBB complaints document a recurring pattern of claims submitted through the MetLife app disappearing from the system without processing. Email a copy of every submission to [email protected] and request confirmation of receipt. Never rely solely on the app upload for any claim involving a significant dollar amount.

This guide reflects publicly available information including MetLife Pet Insurance’s own published policy documents and website, BBB business profile and complaint records, Trustpilot verified reviews, and analyses by NerdWallet, U.S. News, Yahoo Finance, and The Vet Desk. Coverage details, premium estimates, and plan features are subject to change and vary by state, pet species, breed, age, and selected policy options. MetLife Pet Insurance is issued by Metropolitan General Insurance Company (not MetLife Inc.) and administered by MetLife Pet Insurance Solutions LLC. In some states, MetLife Pet operates under alternate names as noted in its policies. This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute insurance advice. Always read your complete policy documents and consult a licensed insurance professional before purchasing. For state-specific consumer protection resources, visit naic.org.

Recommended Reads

  1. Banfield Pet Hospital β€” Hours, Costs, Wellness Plans
  2. 10 Best Pet Insurance for Dogs
  3. 10 Pet Insurance Companies Offering Senior Citizen Discounts
  4. Fetch Pet Insurance β€” Honest Review, Real Complaints
Dog

Post navigation

Previous post

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories

Recent Posts

  • MetLife Pet Insurance
  • Fetch Pet Insurance β€” Honest Review, Real Complaints
  • Β 8 Best Memory Foam Pet Beds
  • Embrace Pet Insurance Reviews
  • Nationwide Pet Insurance Reviews

Recent Comments

  1. Bestie Paws on 12 Non-Prescription Low Phosphorus Wet Cat Foods

    πŸ’¬ Expert Reply You've identified one of the genuinely difficult corners of CKD cat nutrition β€” and you're not alone.…

  2. Harlotte on 12 Non-Prescription Low Phosphorus Wet Cat Foods

    Helpful, but there's not much of a choice for kitties with kidney issues AND allergies to poultry..

  3. Sandy Ramlet on Stages of Healing for Dog Hot Spots

    This is a comprehensive, complete guide to dog hot spots. It is exactly what I was looking for as our…

  4. Bestie Paws on 12 Best Remedies for Dogs with Acid Reflux β€” Natural & Vet-Approved

    What you're describing β€” a dog who tolerates homemade food well but reacts to nearly every medication form β€” is…

  5. Laura Di Mauro on 12 Best Remedies for Dogs with Acid Reflux β€” Natural & Vet-Approved

    How do I find a vet who also has expertise on hollistic approach? I have a dog who's had GI…

Help for Seniors Near Me
https://www.budgetseniors.com/

The content, tools, and chat features on Bestie Paws are forΒ informational and educational purposes only. They are not a substitute for professional veterinary or medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.

  • ⚠️ Privacy Policy
  • βš–οΈ Terms of Service
©2026 Bestie Paws Hospital | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes