How do I house train an adult dog I just adopted without paying a trainer?
Say you adopted a 3-year-old mixed-breed from a shelter two weeks ago. She’s friendly and eats well, but you keep finding puddles on the kitchen floor, and twice she squatted right after coming back inside. A trainer was quoted at several hundred dollars for a package, and that’s more than the budget allows this month. You work a normal day shift and have a small yard. Can you house train an adult dog yourself with a crate, a schedule and some treats, and how do you know when the problem needs a vet or a professional instead?
1 reply
-
๐พ BestiePaws team Team 4 months ago Puddles two weeks in are normal, and you can house train an adult dog yourself for the price of a crate, a bag of small treats and an enzyme cleaner. The method is boring on purpose: a fixed schedule, a leash, a reward the second she finishes outside, and no unsupervised freedom until she's earned it. The one thing to rule out first is a medical cause, which is covered below.
A newly adopted adult isn't being stubborn. The AKC points out that some adults were never taught, never lived indoors, or spent long stretches somewhere they could only go on concrete, on paper in a pen or on bedding in a crate. A dog like that may not connect grass or dirt with "the bathroom" at all.
American Humane says it plainly: going outside isn't instinctive. Dogs avoid soiling where they sleep, but the rest of your house is fair game until someone teaches otherwise. Your new dog doesn't know where the door is or what your routine is. That part is yours to teach, and adults usually learn it faster than puppies because they can hold it longer.
How to house train an adult dog: the routine
Start with meals. Both the AKC and American Humane say to feed on a schedule instead of leaving a bowl down all day, because food in on a schedule means predictable bathroom breaks. The AKC suggests picking up the dish 10 to 15 minutes after you set it down; American Humane says 20 minutes. Either way, whatever she hasn't eaten goes away until the next meal.
AdvertisementThen build the day around trips outside, on a leash, with you. The AKC lists the key moments: first thing in the morning, after breakfast, after dinner, a few times through the day and right before bed. Add one after any nap or hard play session.
Say you work a day shift and leave at 8:00. A workable plan might look like this:
- 6:30 a.m.: out on leash, stay until she goes (or 10 minutes)
- 7:00 a.m.: breakfast, then out again
- Before you leave: out one more time, then into the crate or a gated, easy-to-clean area
- Midday: a neighbor, a friend or a walker if at all possible; if not, ask your vet what's realistic for her age and health
- Right after you get home: straight outside
- Dinner, then out again, then a last trip before bed
That's a sketch, not a prescription. Adjust it to your dog and your hours.
Go out with her. The AKC notes that trainers often hear about dogs having accidents just after coming in, and the usual reason is that the person didn't stay out long enough. Dogs need a minute to sniff and settle.
American Humane's version is worth copying: walk calmly back and forth on a short leash, don't talk or play until she goes, say a cue word as she starts, then praise warmly, hand over several treats fast and let her have some fun. Use a treat she only gets for going outside, small pieces about the size of a pinky fingernail, three to five per success. The exclusivity is what makes it feel like a jackpot.
If she doesn't go, the AKC advice is to bring her inside and put her in the crate for about 10 minutes, then try again. American Humane's similar tip is to wait about 10 minutes, come in, keep her on the leash and go back out 10 to 15 minutes later. Don't give her free run of the house after a trip where nothing happened. That's when the puddle appears.
The crate, and how to size it
A crate or a small gated room works because dogs don't like to soil where they sleep. Any time you can't watch her, she's in the crate, in a gated space, or tied to you by a leash.
AdvertisementSize matters. American Humane says the crate should let her stand, turn around and lie down, nothing more. If it's bigger, she can pick one end as a bathroom. CareCredit's starter-supplies list puts a crate at roughly $25 to $250 depending on size and brand, so a used one or a borrowed one from a friend or a local buy-nothing group is a fine start.
A crate is a tool, not a parking spot. American Humane warns against relying on it as a substitute for training, and says dogs still need daily exercise and company.
When she has an accident anyway
Don't punish. Both the AKC and American Humane say that frightening a dog teaches her to hide when she needs to go, which makes everything harder. If you catch her mid-squat, interrupt calmly, with a clap or a quiet "ah ah," get her outside as fast as you can (carry her if she's small enough), and reward if she finishes out there.
Then clean the spot properly. American Humane's protocol: wet a dried spot with lukewarm water, press paper towels into it until nothing more transfers, apply an enzymatic cleaner as directed and repeat three times. Standard household cleaners don't remove the odor, and dogs return to spots that still smell like a bathroom.
One more trick from the same source: move a soiled paper towel or a bit of waste to the outdoor spot you want her to use. Scent tells dogs where to go.
The AKC lists pacing, whining, circling, sniffing with purpose or leaving the room as "take me out right now" signs. Not every dog barks at the door. If you learn her signals and respond quickly, she'll often start asking on her own because getting up and opening the door works.
Some things slow progress. One is a surface she's used to: if she only ever went on concrete, try a quiet park or a gravel patch. The AKC adds that most dogs go where another dog has already gone.
Another is loose supervision. American Humane's troubleshooting section says repeated accidents usually mean you aren't watching closely enough. Keep her in your sight, on a tether to you, or gated in your room.
A third is too much freedom too soon. Extend it gradually. The AKC suggests a little freedom, 10 to 15 minutes, after she's eliminated outside, then more over a few weeks. If accidents return, go back a step.When to call a vet, and when to call for help
Both are on American Humane's list. If accidents begin suddenly after she'd been doing well, or if she's still struggling after consistent work, book a vet visit to rule out a medical cause such as a urinary problem. A health issue can look exactly like a training issue. Intact males may also be marking rather than having accidents, and the same source says neutering can help.
Other flags: a dog who was kept in a cage long-term where she couldn't avoid eliminating, which American Humane says is harder and merits professional guidance, or a dog who panics, digs or destroys bedding in the crate, which can point to separation anxiety rather than a bathroom problem. In those cases, ask your vet for a referral to a credentialed trainer or a veterinary behaviorist. Don't keep pushing the crate on a dog who's frantic.
What a trainer would cost, for comparison
Chewy's new-dog cost breakdown prices training at $180 to $840 in total, which is $30 to $140 a session over an average of six sessions (it lists group classes at the low end and private sessions near $140). It helps to set that against the do-it-yourself bill: a crate you might already own, treats, an enzyme cleaner, and your time. Prices vary by region and trainer, so ask for a written fee before booking anything.
A trainer is worth the money when the problem isn't really housetraining. If you have a lot of other behaviors on your list, or you just want someone to watch you do the routine once, a single session may be plenty.
Keep a simple log for two weeks: times you went out, whether she went, and any accident with the time and what she'd just done. Patterns show up fast. If the accidents bunch up after meals or naps, the fix is another trip outside a little earlier.
This is general information, not a substitute for your own vet's advice. If your dog is straining, passing blood, drinking far more than normal or in obvious pain, call the vet that day. Don't wait to see whether training solves it.
Key sources: AKC; American Humane Society; CareCredit