Skip to content
๐Ÿถ Dogs

How do I treat my dog’s separation anxiety without spending thousands on a specialist?

Asked by BestiePaws team ยท 3 months ago

Say your 2-year-old rescue dog howls and scratches at the door within minutes of you leaving, has soiled the apartment twice, and has chewed the door frame. You work outside the home and can’t afford a specialist visit right now. You want to know whether this is really separation anxiety, what you can do at home that is safe and low cost, when medication is worth considering, and which shortcuts could make the problem worse.

1 reply

  1. BestiePaws team Team 3 months ago

    Most of the effective part of dog separation anxiety treatment is slow, boring practice at home, and that part costs almost nothing. Medication is a real option for dogs who are suffering, and it works alongside the practice, not instead of it. The money goes where it matters: a vet visit to rule out medical causes, and professional help when the case is moderate or severe. Here's how to sort out which situation you're in and what to do first.

    Is it separation anxiety, or something else?

    The ASPCA describes the pattern. A dog with separation anxiety may bark or howl, urinate or defecate, chew, dig, pace or try to escape, and these things happen when the dog is alone or separated from its person and typically don't happen when the person is home. Many dogs get worked up as you get ready to leave, then start showing distress, often within minutes of being left. A dog who soils the house or destroys things while you're also in the room is probably dealing with something else, such as house training or boredom.

    Cornell's Dr. Katherine Houpt makes a point worth knowing: she says she almost never diagnoses anxiety by itself, because there's usually something else behind a dog's anxious behavior, and that "anxiety" gets used as a blanket description for anything the owner doesn't like. That's why the first stop is your veterinarian. Tufts' veterinary school advises that dogs with frequent anxious behavior see a veterinarian as soon as possible, so that pain, illness or other medical causes can be checked before anyone assumes a behavior problem.

    Advertisement

    Tufts adds a point that matters for how you respond: when an anxious dog urinates indoors, that's a sign of anxiety, not resentment or anger. Punishing the dog for it adds fear to the situation.

    Why dogs develop it, so you can stop blaming yourself

    The ASPCA says there's no conclusive evidence for exactly why, but it notes that far more dogs adopted from shelters have this problem than dogs kept by one family since puppyhood, and it lists triggers such as a change of guardian or family, being surrendered, and an abrupt schedule change. The FDA's announcement on the first generic clomipramine for dogs cites estimates that separation anxiety is diagnosed in 20 to 40 percent of dogs referred to behavior practices in North America, and that three of the ten most commonly reported problems in a survey of dogs surrendered to a humane society were consistent with separation anxiety. In short, it's common, and it isn't a character flaw in you or the dog.

    The home plan that costs very little

    For mild cases: The ASPCA says counterconditioning may reduce or resolve a mild case. The idea is to build a link between being alone and something wonderful. Each time you leave, give the dog a puzzle toy stuffed with food that takes at least 20 to 30 minutes to finish, and put the toy away when you return so it only appears when the dog is alone. You can serve the dog's daily meals in such toys, which adds no cost beyond the toy. The ASPCA adds a caveat: this works for mild cases only, because highly anxious dogs usually won't eat when their people are gone. If your dog ignores the food, that's information in itself, and it suggests you're past the mild stage.

    For moderate to severe cases: The ASPCA says you need a more complex program of desensitization and counterconditioning: start with many short separations that don't produce anxiety, then lengthen them gradually over many weeks of daily sessions. Cornell's description starts even smaller. Walk out of the room and come right back, then slowly increase the time you're out of sight, and don't expect a quick fix.

    Advertisement

    Here's how that looks in practice. Say your dog stays relaxed when you step out for 10 seconds but starts whining at 40. Practice at 10 and 20 and 30 seconds, return before the whining starts, and do it several times a day, nudging the time up only while the dog stays calm. If the dog gets upset, you went too far, so drop back. The ASPCA stresses that fear has to be avoided or the program backfires and the dog becomes more frightened.

    The ASPCA also describes a step for dogs who panic at your leaving routine, such as putting on shoes or picking up keys. You teach the dog that those cues don't always mean you're leaving by doing them in different orders through the day without going anywhere.

    Cornell adds that a predictable routine helps. Its advice is to build consistency into the dog's life, with simple cause and effect that dogs can learn. Tufts' prevention tips for adult dogs include plenty of exercise and mental stimulation suited to the dog's age, breed and health, so a walk before you leave isn't a bad habit.

    Where the money should go

    The ASPCA's own words: desensitization and counterconditioning are complex and can be tricky, because the plan has to adjust to the dog's reactions, which can be hard to read. It recommends help from a Certified Applied Animal Behaviorist or a board-certified veterinary behaviorist, and, if you can't find one, a Certified Professional Dog Trainer with education and experience treating fear, since that expertise isn't required for the trainer credential. For a sense of price, Tufts lists $605 for a new-client consultation with its veterinary behavior service. Prices vary, so ask for a fee schedule. SPCA Wake offers a free pet helpline that can talk through a behavior problem, which could be a no-cost first step if you're nearby, and similar services exist at some shelters.

    If a full consultation is out of reach right now, a vet visit is the smaller step. A veterinarian can check for medical issues, talk through medication, and refer you to a behaviorist when the time comes.

    Medication: when it helps and what to ask

    Houpt says that if you think the dog is suffering, if you are suffering or if your relationship with the dog is suffering, anti-anxiety medication is a solid option. Cornell lists fluoxetine (sold as Reconcile), clomipramine (Clomicalm), trazodone and dexmedetomidine (Sileo) among the common medications for anxiety in dogs, and says they may be needed only while you work on behavior or may help for life. The FDA's page confirms that clomipramine tablets are approved to be used as part of a comprehensive behavioral management program for separation anxiety in dogs older than six months, and it approved a generic version in October 2019. Ask your vet what the prescription will cost and whether a generic is available.

    Three safety points. First, dosing is a veterinarian's job, and nothing here should be used as dosing guidance. Second, never give a dog a person's antidepressant or any human medicine on your own (the FDA notes the dog product isn't for use in humans, and that anyone who swallows it should get medical care). Third, Cornell says that rather than picking up an over-the-counter supplement or another remedy from the internet, you should schedule a visit with your veterinarian.

    • Leaving a panicking dog in a crate. The ASPCA warns that escape attempts can cause injuries such as broken teeth, cut paws and torn nails. If the dog panics when confined, talk to a professional before crating.
    • Yelling or scolding after you come home to a mess. Tufts says soiling isn't spite.
    • Using harsh trainers. Cornell warns against yelling, leash jerks, pinch collars and shock collars, and against anyone promising a quick fix.
    • Skipping the vet. It's the cheapest way to rule out a medical cause.
    1. Book a veterinary exam and describe exactly what happens and when. If you can, record video of the dog while you're out. Tufts notes that pictures and videos help its behavior doctors.
    2. Start the stuffed-toy routine and the very short departures.
    3. Arrange cover for long absences while the training is underway, such as a friend or neighbor, so the dog isn't repeatedly pushed past its limit.
    4. Ask the vet about medication and a referral if the dog isn't eating when alone, hurts itself, or isn't improving.

    The ASPCA describes this work as taking many weeks of daily sessions, so judge progress by small steps, such as one more calm minute alone.

    Key sources: ASPCA; Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine; FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine; Tufts University Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” you might be talking to a worried owner.