Skip to content
🐢 Dogs

Is a dog DNA test worth it for a rescue mix, or is $120 better spent at the vet?

Asked by BestiePaws team Β· 2 weeks ago

Say you adopted a 2-year-old shelter dog listed only as a medium mixed breed. He’s high energy, has a thick coat and a hint of herding behavior. Breed-and-health kits from the major companies are on sale around $80 to $120, and you can’t tell whether that money would be better spent on a wellness exam, a dental or a vaccine. You’re hoping for a breed mix to guide training and exercise, and maybe a health screen. How much can a consumer DNA test really tell you, and when is it worth it?

1 reply

  1. BestiePaws team Team 1 week ago

    For a rescue mix with a mystery background, a dog DNA test can be a fair way to spend around a hundred dollars, as long as you know what you're buying. It's a decent guess at breed mix, a useful screen for one or two specific gene variants, and a poor crystal ball for your dog's health. If the money is the same money you'd need for a dental cleaning or a vaccine booster, the answer tilts the other way.

    So is a dog DNA test worth it? Here's how to tell, with the prices and the evidence on the table.

    What the kits cost

    Prices move around, and the companies run frequent sales, so check the current page before you buy. At the time of writing, one major company's own site listed its breed-plus-health kit at $119 under an early Black Friday promotion. Wisdom Panel's site listed three tiers with sale prices shown against higher list prices: Breed Discovery at $79.99 (list $99.99), Essential at $83.99 (list $119.99) and Premium at $111.99 (list $159.99). The American Kennel Club has reported kits costing up to $200 for panels that test for more than 160 conditions.

    Say your budget is $100 and you spend it on a kit. Say your clinic charges about that for a wellness exam. Neither is wasted, but if your dog is overdue for a checkup, the exam will tell you far more about his health today than any swab.

    Advertisement

    What breed results can and can't tell you

    Breed ancestry reports are the most popular part of these kits, and they're the part with the weakest independent checking. Researchers at the University of Colorado School of Medicine sent cheek swabs from 12 purebred dogs, registered or eligible for registration, to six direct-to-consumer companies. A registered purebred beagle came back as 50 percent poodle, 50 percent bichon frisΓ© and no beagle at all from one company. The same study found that one company's results seemed to follow the photo submitted with the sample more than the DNA. The researchers' point was that there's no scientific reason a photo should be needed. The study doesn't mean every company is unreliable, but it does mean results from different companies can disagree, and a breed pie chart is an estimate, not a certificate.

    How is that useful? If your dog's results say "mostly terrier and some herding dog," that still helps you plan. A dog with working-breed ancestry may need more mental work and exercise than one that's mostly lap-dog. Treat the report as a conversation starter, not as proof, and don't change how you train because of a percentage.

    What health results can and can't tell you

    This is where owners are most likely to read too much. The AKC interviewed Dr. Elinor Karlsson, a canine geneticist at University of Massachusetts Medical School and the Broad Institute, who said that when a dog carries a variant that's been linked to a disease in a study, owners usually want to know the chance their dog will get sick, "and that's not a question that we can actually answer yet." The research is still young. Correlation isn't causation, and canine genetics has less funding and more variety than human genetics.

    The AKC Canine Health Foundation's CEO added that peer-reviewed, open methods are what make results trustworthy, and that some companies keep their methods private, which makes the results hard to evaluate. Two more problems from that article:

    • A condition may involve several genes while a test checks only one, so a clear result can falsely feel like an all-clear.
    • Veterinarians may not be trained to interpret a long panel, and the article reports at least one case of a dog being put down on the basis of results that may have been misread.
    Advertisement

    So if a report says "carrier" or "at risk," don't panic and don't stop everything. Take the report to your vet and ask what, if anything, it should change.

    The one result that can be useful right away: MDR1

    Washington State University's veterinary diagnostic lab explains that the MDR1 mutation makes some dogs sensitive to certain common drugs. It says roughly three of every four collies in the United States carry the mutant gene, and it has also been found in Shetland sheepdogs, Australian shepherds, old English sheepdogs, English shepherds, German shepherds, long-haired whippets, silken windhounds and a variety of mixed-breed dogs. The lab says the only way to know whether an individual dog has the mutation is to test.

    That matters for a mystery mix. If your rescue looks like he might have herding ancestry, knowing his MDR1 status can help your vet choose medications safely. Wisdom Panel's cheapest listed tier mentions testing for MDR1, and WSU offers its own MDR1 test. Prices for the single test change, so ask the lab or your vet for the current fee and compare it with a kit that includes MDR1 along with breed ID. Don't change any medication yourself based on a result; let your vet decide.

    When a DNA test is worth the money

    • You adopted a mixed-breed dog and want a rough sense of size, coat and energy for planning.
    • Your dog looks like he could have herding ancestry and you want MDR1 status for your vet.
    • You're curious and the price is a sale price you won't miss.
    • You're willing to bring the results to a vet and accept that many "at-risk" flags mean nothing.
    • You're hoping it will diagnose a symptom. A limp, itchy skin or an upset stomach needs an exam, not a kit.
    • You'd use it to decide on surgery, euthanasia or breeding without a vet's guidance.
    • You need proof for a landlord, insurer or airline. Rules about which breeds they accept vary, and a company's report may or may not satisfy them. Ask what documentation they take before you spend anything, and never misstate a dog's breed to anyone.
    • The same money would cover something your dog needs now, like vaccines, a dental or a spay or neuter.

    Wait for a sale, since the two sites above both showed discounted prices alongside the higher list prices. Read what the test covers and how many markers or conditions it includes, and pick a tier that matches the question you actually have. If you only care about breed, the breed-only tier is the cheaper one. If drug sensitivity is the concern, look for MDR1 in the list or order the single test.

    Check how the company handles your dog's data and whether you can delete the sample after testing. If you have an unusual breed mix, consider asking your vet whether they have a preferred company, since some clinics see results from the same kits regularly.

    Ask your vet or a shelter's staff what they see when they look at your dog. Some have seen a lot of mixes and can give you a reasonable guess at body type and what to expect at no charge in some cases. Your vet can also tell you whether a gene test would change anything for this particular dog.

    If you do buy a kit, treat the result as one piece of information among several, along with your dog's age, behavior and checkups.

    This is general information, and it isn't a substitute for your veterinarian's advice about your dog.

    Key sources: University of Colorado School of Medicine; American Kennel Club; Washington State University College of Veterinary Medicine

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind β€” you might be talking to a worried owner.