Is this a puppy scam? The breeder wants a $400 shipping fee after my deposit
Say you paid a $250 deposit on a puppy listed at $900, and the seller has now asked for $400 more for a climate-controlled crate and travel insurance, to be paid by gift card or a payment app. The puppy has only ever been seen in photos, and the seller has stopped answering video-call requests. You don’t want to lose the deposit, but you also don’t want to pay again for a dog that may not exist. What should you do about the money already sent, what do you check, and how do you report it?
1 reply
-
๐พ BestiePaws team Team 4 months ago Stop sending money. A seller who takes a deposit and then invents a shipping fee, a "climate-controlled crate" charge or travel insurance is following the standard puppy scam script, and each new payment only sets up the next demand. Before you do anything else, write down every payment you've made, how you made it, and what the seller's account name, phone number and email are. Then read on, because how you paid decides what you can still try.
Why the extra fees are the tell
Michigan's Attorney General describes the pattern plainly: the ad shows puppies that don't exist, and once the purchase price has been paid, the "seller" demands more for shipping, special crates, bogus insurance or health problems. The excuses come in a familiar set. The crate didn't meet airline standards, the puppy needs medical care before it can travel, the weather is too warm or cold and special equipment is needed, or the flight date changed and there's a reservation fee. Michigan's office also notes that the people behind these ads often live outside the United States, which is a big reason victims rarely get money back.
AARP's write-up adds two details worth knowing. First, the scammers copy photos, videos and testimonials from real breeder sites and build convincing pages, including fake transport companies with "tracking" so you can watch your nonexistent puppy's trip. Second, when victims get suspicious the threats start: the puppy will suffer, or you'll be charged with animal abandonment. AARP says that abandonment charge doesn't apply in this situation. It's pressure, nothing more.
AdvertisementRun the numbers before the next payment
Say you paid a $250 deposit on a puppy advertised at $900, and now you're asked for $400 for a crate and insurance. That's $650 out already if you pay. A week later the "flight" is delayed and there's a $300 "quarantine" charge. Now you're at $950, which is more than the puppy's listed price, for an animal nobody has shown you on a live video call.
That arithmetic is the real argument. A real seller's costs are baked into the price; they don't pile up one surprise at a time. If the total you've been asked to pay has already passed the original price, you're being milked.
What to do right now, in order
- Stop replying to demands. You can send one last message saying you want a refund of what you paid, if that helps you feel finished, but don't argue and don't click tracking links the seller sends.
- Collect the evidence. Michigan's list is useful: screenshots of the ad and website, every message, proof of each payment, any contract, the refund policy, and any photos or videos you were sent.
- Call whoever handled the money. If you paid by credit card, tell the card issuer you're disputing the charge as fraud. Michigan's guidance is that a credit card lets you dispute a purchase, which wire transfers, gift cards and payment apps like Venmo, Zelle and Cash App don't, because those can't be refunded and aren't traceable. If you paid through an app or bank transfer, contact that company anyway and report it; the odds are lower, but a quick report costs nothing. If you gave out a card number, ask for a replacement card.
- Report it. File with the FTC through the FTC's ReportFraud site, with BBB Scam Tracker, and with your state attorney general's consumer office. If you lost a larger amount, also file with the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3). Make a police report too; AARP notes the paperwork can matter later.
- Change passwords if you shared any login details, and be wary of "recovery" services that contact you afterward and want a fee. Those are often a second scam.
AdvertisementReporting won't usually get the money back. It does help investigators connect the same phone numbers, photos and payment accounts across many victims, and your report may be the one that links them.
How to tell a real breeder from a stage set
Michigan's checklist is worth following even when a listing looks polished.
- Check the price against what the breed actually sells for. A big discount on a popular breed is a warning, not a bargain.
- Search the seller's email address and phone number along with words like "scam" and "complaint". Scammers reuse contact details across sites.
- Run a reverse image search on the puppy photos, and paste a sentence from the testimonials into a search box. If the same pictures or words show up elsewhere, walk away.
- If the seller says the puppy is registered with a club like the American Kennel Club, contact the club to confirm.
- Ask for a live video call, or a photo or video with your name and the date written on paper next to the puppy. Do this before any deposit. Ask to see where the puppies are kept and to see the mother.
- Be suspicious of anyone who insists on meeting at a "convenient" public place and won't let you see the premises.
AARP also flags sellers who communicate only by email or text, refuse a phone call, or won't take a credit card. Michigan says to pay with a credit card and avoid wire transfers, gift cards and payment apps.
Michigan's guidance points out that sending a young animal a long distance, especially as air cargo in hot months, carries real risk, and recommends picking the puppy up in person (flying home with it in a carrier under your seat is one option). That also removes the whole shipping-fee excuse. If a seller who seems legitimate won't let you pick up in person at all, ask yourself why.
A cheaper and safer route: shelters and rescues
A legitimate puppy from a breeder isn't cheap either. On top of the purchase price, the ASPCA's 2021 cost table puts a dog's first round of vaccines and other initial medical care at about $300, with spay or neuter at around another $300. Many shelters fold that work into the adoption fee, so ask each one what's included: microchip, sterilization and vaccinations are common, though not universal. And with a shelter you can meet the dog in person, ask about its history, and often take it home the same day.
Search for your county or city animal services and the humane societies near you, and check Petfinder or the Shelter Pet Project listings, which AARP also suggests. Adoption fees and what they include vary by shelter, so ask for the fee schedule in writing.
If you still want a particular breed, look for a breed-specific rescue. They exist for most popular breeds and tend to have adult dogs and sometimes puppies, with real people you can talk to and visit.
Sellers who sense they're losing a payment often turn up the heat: "the dog will be euthanized," "your deposit is nonrefundable," "the transport company will keep the puppy." None of that changes your next step. Hold on to your records, don't send more, and file your reports.
If you're embarrassed about being taken in, know that AARP reports an unusually high share of victims of online pet scams are in their late teens or twenties, according to the Better Business Bureau, and AARP also cites a BBB figure that 70 percent of people targeted by pet scams in its reports lost money, with a median loss of $750 in 2020. These ads are designed by people who do this full time, and wanting a puppy is a normal reason to be fooled.
This is general information, not legal advice. If a large amount of money is involved, call your bank right away and consider asking your state attorney general's consumer protection office what else they can do.
Key sources: Michigan Attorney General; AARP; Better Business Bureau; ASPCA