Skip to content
๐Ÿถ Dogs

My landlord says no dogs. What are my emotional support dog rights now that HUD changed its rules?

Asked by BestiePaws team ยท 6 months ago

Say your lease has a no-pets clause, you have a diagnosed anxiety disorder, and your therapist supports having your dog with you. The landlord just said no dogs, and offered a $300 deposit plus $40 a month if you wanted to treat him as a pet. Your dog hasn’t had formal task training. You’ve heard HUD changed its rules this year and you can’t tell what’s still protected, what to put in writing, or where to turn if the landlord won’t budge.

1 reply

  1. BestiePaws team Team 6 months ago

    Yes, you may still have options, but they're narrower than they were a year ago, and what you can do depends on one question: is your dog individually trained to do something specific that relates to your disability, or does he help mainly by being there? That split now drives how HUD treats a landlord's "no dogs" rule, so it's worth sorting out before you send anything.

    Here's what changed, what hasn't, and a practical order of steps. This is general information, not legal advice, and a local fair housing group or legal aid office can tell you how your state treats it.

    What HUD changed, in plain terms

    For years, HUD guidance told landlords to treat an emotional support animal as an assistance animal, meaning no pet fees and no pet rules, if the tenant had a disability-related need. Two notices carried that approach, one from 2013 and one from January 28, 2020. HUD's Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity withdrew both, effective September 17, 2025, and published notice of the withdrawal in the Federal Register on April 6, 2026.

    On May 22, 2026, the Assistant Secretary for Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity issued an enforcement memo that goes further. We read the memo as posted on HUD's own website. It is addressed to HUD's fair housing staff, not to landlords, and it says that, effective immediately, for complaints about animal-related accommodations the office will find reasonable cause and recommend charges only in cases involving animals trained to provide disability-related assistance. It borrows the training requirement from the ADA's service animal definition and says comfort and companionship alone don't count as work or tasks. Requests to waive pet policies for trained animals are described as presumptively reasonable. Requests to waive them for untrained emotional support animals are not. HUD's staff were told to send open emotional support animal cases up for a case-by-case decision.

    Advertisement

    One difference from the ADA: the memo says a housing accommodation could involve an animal other than a dog, as long as it's trained for a disability-related service.

    What didn't change

    The memo changes how HUD will enforce the law. It doesn't amend the Fair Housing Act, and it says nothing in it affects people's right to sue. The Act itself still bars a landlord from refusing a reasonable accommodation in rules or policies when it may be necessary for a person with a disability to have an equal opportunity to use and enjoy a home. State and local fair housing laws can differ and may give you more protection than the federal baseline, so look up yours. The Fair Housing Act lets a person file a civil action in federal or state court within two years of the alleged discriminatory act. The Great Plains ADA Center, a federally funded technical assistance center, also notes that state and local fair housing laws, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and future court decisions can still matter. The Housing Equality Center of Pennsylvania adds that courts will keep applying earlier case law until a final rule exists, and that a HUD complaint is no longer a practical route for an untrained animal.

    HUD's own regulation still has its classic example: a blind applicant in a building with a no-pets policy must be allowed a seeing eye dog. And a separate HUD rule for federally assisted public housing, which was on the books when we checked, says housing providers there can't apply pet policies to animals that are a necessary reasonable accommodation to assist, support or provide service to a person with a disability. The memo says it doesn't address how the department treats complaints under Section 504 or the ADA.

    HUD said it intends to do formal rulemaking to bring its rules closer to the ADA. We checked the Federal Register and found no proposed rule from HUD on this at the time of writing, so watch for one.

    The decision that matters: trained or untrained

    If your dog is trained to do specific tasks, such as alerting to a medical event, interrupting panic symptoms, retrieving medication or providing stability, you're in the strongest position. In the ADA's guidance, a dog trained to notice an approaching anxiety attack and take a set action to head it off or lessen it counts as a psychiatric service dog, while one that only comforts by being near does not. It also says you can train the dog yourself. Professional training isn't required.

    Advertisement

    If your dog helps by being calm and present, you can still ask. A landlord may say yes. HUD just won't push for it the way it used to, and a court may weigh the request differently. In one 2025 federal decision the HUD memo cites, a Louisiana court rejected a tenant's request to waive a general pet fee for her emotional support dog, finding the waiver neither reasonable nor necessary. Other courts have ruled differently, so outcomes vary by state and court.

    Steps to take this week

    • Read your lease and any pet policy. Note the exact wording, the fees and any weight or breed limits.
    • Put your request in writing, dated, and keep a copy. Say that you have a disability and are asking for an exception to the no-pets policy for your dog. If he's trained, list the tasks.
    • Ask your doctor or therapist whether they can speak to your need. Be honest about training. A letter that implies tasks the dog isn't trained to do will hurt you.
    • Call a local fair housing organization or legal aid office and ask how your state treats emotional support animals. Search for your state's fair housing agency or human rights commission. If you're stuck, 211 can point you to local legal help.
    • If you're in subsidized or public housing, ask the housing authority about its assistance animal policy, since separate rules apply.
    • Keep every message. Don't threaten, and don't move the dog in before you have an answer.

    Say the landlord offers to allow the dog as a pet, with a $300 deposit and $40 monthly pet rent. First year: $300 plus 12 times $40, which is $780. That's a real sum, but compare it with moving costs and a possible rent increase elsewhere. Ask whether the deposit is refundable and in what situations. Some states cap pet charges, so check yours before agreeing, and ask the landlord to put any exception in the lease.

    What not to do

    • Don't buy an "ESA registration," ID card or certificate. The Department of Justice says online certificates and registrations convey no rights under the ADA. There's no official registry.
    • Don't pay a website for a letter without a real evaluation from a licensed professional. The HUD memo itself points to advertisements for letters "in 24 hours" and "get approved for free" as signs of an industry that grew up around the old guidance.
    • Don't claim your dog is a trained service animal if he isn't. Misrepresenting a dog as a service animal is a misdemeanor in California under Penal Code 365.7, and the Animal Legal and Historical Center at Michigan State shows a majority of states have laws on fraudulent service animals. Penalties vary.
    • Don't hide the dog. A lease violation can lead to an eviction record, and that costs far more than a deposit.

    The Housing Equality Center cautions that landlords shouldn't assume they face no legal exposure when they deny these requests, since people can still sue or use state agencies. If your landlord already approved your dog in writing, keep that document safe.

    If your dog is trained for tasks, document it. Keep a short list of the tasks, any training records, and the date you started. You don't need a certificate, and no one can require one under the ADA's public-access rules, but notes help if a dispute comes up. For housing, the HUD memo says requests for trained animals are presumptively reasonable.

    If the landlord still refuses, a fair housing group can help you file a complaint with HUD or your state agency, or consider a private claim. Funds and time are limited, so reach out early.

    Key sources: HUD; U.S. Department of Justice ADA Information; Great Plains ADA Center; Housing Equality Center of Pennsylvania

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” you might be talking to a worried owner.