Skip to content
๐Ÿถ Dogs

Pet insurance and pre-existing conditions: can a 9-year-old dog with arthritis still get covered?

Asked by BestiePaws team ยท 3 months ago

Say your 9-year-old Lab mix has arthritis, which her vet manages with a prescribed pain plan, and a heart murmur was noted at her last checkup. She has never been insured. A quote for accident-and-illness coverage came back at $110 a month. You’d like to know whether any company will cover her at this age, which conditions are off the table, and whether the premium makes sense for what remains.

See alsoPet insurance vs savings account for my 3-year-old dog: what does the math say?

1 reply

  1. BestiePaws team Team 3 months ago

    Many insurers will quote a 9-year-old dog, though age rules differ by company, and the arthritis and anything else already noted by you or a vet will almost certainly be excluded. What you're really buying is protection against new problems. Whether that's worth $110 a month comes down to a little arithmetic and a careful read of the policy, so let's work through both.

    Pet insurance pre-existing conditions: how insurers define them

    Embrace's published definition is broad: any illness, injury or irregularity observed or diagnosed before coverage began or during the waiting period. Symptoms count even without a formal diagnosis, and it counts even if the dog never saw a vet for it.

    Embrace states that no pet insurance company covers pre-existing conditions. The ASPCA's pet insurance disclosure says the same thing in a line of fine print: pre-existing conditions are not covered, and waiting periods, deductibles and benefit limits may apply.

    What differs is how companies treat conditions that can heal. Embrace splits them in two.

    • Curable conditions. If a condition is temporary and your dog has been symptom-free and treatment-free for 12 consecutive months from the last episode, Embrace says it may remove the exclusion. Its examples of curable conditions include respiratory infections, urinary tract or bladder infections, and vomiting, diarrhea and other digestive disorders.
    • Incurable conditions. Those that can't be cured, recur, or are chronic stay permanently excluded if they were noticed before the end of the waiting period. Embrace lists diabetes, arthritis and allergies as examples, and in its dog section it also lists orthopedic issues, cancer and other chronic illnesses present before coverage.
    Advertisement

    Other insurers use their own wording, and some are stricter than Embrace. Read each one's sample policy, not the marketing page.

    What this means for your dog's two known issues

    The arthritis is excluded, and so are medications and visits directly tied to it. The heart murmur is likely to be treated as pre-existing too, and so would any heart disease linked to it.

    Insurers would say the murmur was noted before coverage. That doesn't mean the whole policy is useless, since Embrace says that even with an incurable pre-existing condition, it still covers other, unrelated health problems.

    Here's the other subtle catch: bilateral conditions. Embrace describes these as things like hip dysplasia or a cruciate ligament tear that can affect either side. If one side was affected before coverage, the other side won't be covered, so if your dog's arthritis involves one hip or knee, ask the insurer how it treats the opposite joint.

    The honest-disclosure rule

    Never leave a known condition off an application, and don't schedule a vet visit to avoid having records. Insurers review medical history, and Embrace says it requires a 12-month medical history with chart notes. If your dog hasn't seen a vet in the last 12 months, it requires a full physical exam within the first 14 days of the policy.

    A vet exam that turns up something new in that window can make that thing pre-existing, so you do want to know about it. Hiding a condition risks a denied claim and a canceled policy. After you buy, Embrace says you can request a medical history review to learn what's been classified as pre-existing, which is worth doing early.

    Embrace lists a 14-day waiting period for illness, accident coverage from the effective date, and orthopedic waiting periods that vary by state. A senior dog with an undiagnosed new problem in that window won't be covered for it, so don't buy the day after you notice a lump. Policies from other companies have different waiting periods.

    Is $110 a month worth it?

    The annual cost is $110 times 12, or $1,320. Say the deductible is $500 and reimbursement is 80 percent. The break-even is where 80 percent of (bill minus $500) equals $1,320.

    Advertisement

    That works out to a covered bill of about $2,150, since 80 percent of $1,650 is $1,320. Below that, you spent more on premiums than you got back in a year. Above it, you came out ahead.

    Now picture a new problem, like a stomach obstruction or a mass that needs removal, with a $6,000 bill. Reimbursement would be 80 percent of $5,500, which is $4,400. You'd pay $1,600, and net of the year's premium you'd be ahead by $3,080.

    If nothing new happens, you're out $1,320. Not buying leaves you carrying the $6,000 yourself, with a dog old enough that new problems aren't unlikely.

    To judge this, ask what you'd do with a $5,000 bill and no insurance. If you'd have the cash, you may be better self-insuring. If not, coverage for the unknown may be worth it, as long as you accept that the arthritis cost remains yours.

    NAPHIA's 2026 report is a reminder that prices are climbing: the average U.S. dog accident-and-illness premium rose 11.5 percent, from $749 in 2024 to $836 in 2025. Embrace says premiums rise with age, so a 9-year-old's quote can sit above that average. NAPHIA's report also lists skin conditions, ear infections, digestive problems, growths and eye disorders among the most common reasons for dog claims, and several of those are exactly what an older dog's new problems might look like.

    Cheaper middle options

    • Accident-only coverage. NAPHIA reports that the average U.S. dog accident-only premium was $190 in 2025. It covers injuries, like a fracture or an ingested object, not illness, so you still carry that side.
    • Savings plus a plan. Put the $110 a month into a dedicated account. After 12 months that's $1,320. It doesn't protect you at month two, but nobody's keeping an exclusion list on it.
    • A clinic plan. Banfield says its wellness plans carry one base price regardless of breed, age or pre-existing conditions, and include unlimited office visits for new and existing concerns. Those plans bundle preventive services and aren't insurance. For a dog who sees the vet often, the visits can be worth something; for treatment of a big problem, they don't help. Ask what's included and how to cancel.

    On the cost of the arthritis itself:

    Ask your vet whether a lower-cost treatment plan exists, but never switch or add medicines on your own. People's anti-inflammatories like ibuprofen and naproxen are dangerous for dogs, and the FDA warns that even leftover pet medication should be checked with your vet before you give it. If treatment costs are a strain, ask the clinic about payment plans and assistance funds.

    Questions to put to any insurer before you sign:

    • How do you define pre-existing, and do symptoms without a diagnosis count?
    • Is there a curable-condition rule, and what's the clock?
    • What is the waiting period for illness and orthopedic problems in my state?
    • How do you handle bilateral conditions?
    • Is there an age limit for enrollment or renewal, and does the annual limit or reimbursement change with age?
    • Will you pay the vet directly?

    If something goes wrong with a claim, your state insurance department takes complaints. This is general information, not insurance or veterinary advice, and the policy language controls.

    Key sources: Embrace Pet Insurance; NAPHIA; Banfield Pet Hospital; FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” you might be talking to a worried owner.