Should I worry about grain free dog food and DCM, and what can I feed cheaply?
Say you’ve fed your 7-year-old Golden Retriever a grain-free kibble with peas and lentils for years, and a news story about heart disease has you worried. She seems healthy. A vet visit with a heart check isn’t free, and a new food could cost more or less than the old one. What did the FDA’s investigation into grain free dog food and DCM actually find, what is still unknown, who should call the vet now, and how do you pick an affordable food without panic-switching?
1 reply
-
๐พ BestiePaws team Team 2 months ago If your dog has been eating grain-free food for years and a headline scared you, here's where things stand. The FDA has not told owners to stop feeding these foods, it hasn't requested a recall, and it says it has no definitive information that these diets are inherently unsafe. What it does say is to talk to your vet before changing your dog's food. That advice matters most if your dog is a breed known for heart disease, or if you've seen any signs of heart trouble.
What the FDA actually found
Dilated cardiomyopathy, or DCM, is a disease of the heart muscle that enlarges the heart. As the heart gets bigger it has a harder time pumping, valves can leak, and fluid can build up in the chest and abdomen, which is congestive heart failure. DCM has long been tied to genetics in certain large and giant breeds. The FDA's own page names the Doberman Pinscher, Great Dane and Irish Wolfhound, and notes it is also seen in Cocker Spaniels associated with taurine deficiency.
In July 2018 the FDA announced it was looking into reports of DCM in dogs eating certain foods, many labeled grain-free, that had a high proportion of peas, lentils, other legume seeds (pulses) or potatoes among the main ingredients. Many of the cases were breeds not known to carry the genetic risk.
AdvertisementHere are the numbers the agency has published:
- From January 1, 2014 to April 30, 2019, the FDA received 524 reports of DCM, 515 involving dogs.
- In that 2019 update, more than 90 percent of the reported foods were grain-free, and 93 percent contained peas or lentils.
- A later table in the FDA's Q&A counts 1,382 reports of DCM in dogs from January 2014 through November 1, 2022. The FDA notes it doesn't investigate every report and that reports are voluntary.
- The FDA's December 23, 2022 note said it doesn't plan more public updates until there is meaningful new scientific information.
The same pages add important cautions. Reporting numbers alone don't prove a cause. The FDA saw a reporting bias, for instance with Golden Retrievers, because breed groups and social media encouraged owners to report. The agency isn't aware of any statistics on the normal background rate of non-hereditary DCM in dogs, and the American Veterinary Medical Association estimates 77 million pet dogs in the US, so most dogs eating these foods haven't been reported to have DCM.
What it still doesn't know
The FDA's Q&A says non-hereditary DCM appears to be a complex condition that may involve genetics, other medical conditions and diet. Aspects of diet it names include the nutritional makeup of ingredients, how well dogs digest them, sourcing, processing, formulation and feeding practices.
Two details surprise people. First, the FDA says it has received reports involving both grain-free and grain-containing diets, so grain-free isn't the only pattern. Most diets in the reports have non-soy legumes like peas and lentils high on the ingredient list. Second, the FDA says legumes have been used in pet foods for many years with no evidence they're inherently dangerous. It does say pulse ingredients are used in many grain-free diets in greater proportion than in most grain-containing ones.
On taurine, FDA says nutrition research generally doesn't consider taurine an essential amino acid for dogs, since dogs can make it from other amino acids, and that its testing found similar protein, fat and taurine levels in grain-free and grain-containing products on a dry-matter basis. It says it's still looking at how taurine is absorbed and processed.
AdvertisementFinally, the FDA says it has no definitive information that these diets are inherently unsafe and need to be removed from the market, and it has stopped updating a list of brands because companies have changed formulas.
There's good news if it's caught early
The FDA's Q&A says veterinary cardiologists report some good results in non-hereditary DCM with appropriate veterinary treatment and diet change when it is caught early. That's unlike genetic DCM. So if you're worried, a checkup is better than waiting.
Emergency signs
Trouble breathing, a collapse, a swollen belly with labored breathing or a very weak dog need an emergency vet now. Heart failure can mean fluid in the chest, and that's an emergency.
What to do on a budget
- Call your regular vet and ask a plain question: "My dog eats a grain-free food with peas or lentils. Do you want to see my dog or switch the food?" Your vet knows your dog's breed and history, and the FDA says your vet is in the best position to advise you.
- Ask what a heart check costs, in writing. A listen to the heart is part of a routine exam. If your vet suggests more, such as a cardiac ultrasound, ask for the price and whether it's needed now. The FDA notes that diagnostic testing and treatment of DCM can be complex and costly. Prices vary a lot by clinic, so ask for a written figure rather than relying on an average.
- Ask about a lower-cost visit. Veterinary colleges may offer lower-cost clinics, and Humane World for Animals' resource page points owners to them. Ask your vet about a payment plan, and read the terms of any credit.
- Don't panic-switch overnight. A sudden change can upset a dog's stomach. If your vet agrees a switch makes sense, do it gradually.
What to feed on a budget
You don't need to buy an expensive diet to avoid this issue, but nobody can name the right food for your dog without knowing your dog. The FDA says every dog has its own needs and to consult your vet before changing. What's safe to say is that according to AAFCO, a good low-cost food carries a nutritional adequacy statement that it's complete and balanced for your dog's life stage, and that the FDA's reports have centered on diets with peas, lentils or other legumes high on the ingredient list, grain-free or not. Many grain-containing foods meet the same standard, and many of them cost less.
Say a 100-cup grain-free bag costs $62 and your dog eats 2.5 cups daily. That bag lasts 40 days, about $1.55 a day, or about $566 a year ($1.55 times 365). A grain-containing food with a proper statement at $38 for 120 cups, with 3 cups a day, would last 40 days at $0.95, or about $347 a year. The gap is about $219 a year. These are example prices, so use your own. But the point is that if your vet is comfortable with a switch, the cost can drop, and nothing in the FDA's pages gives a reason to pay more for the grain-free bag.
If your dog has a medical condition or has been diagnosed with DCM, don't pick a food yourself. Your vet may involve a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, as the FDA suggests. Treatments such as heart medication and diet changes are decided by the vet.
Don't fall for these
- Supplements or "heart-health" products marketed to treat DCM. Don't give any supplement or human medicine unless your vet says so.
- Sites that say the FDA is "hiding" something. Its pages are public, including its statement that it has no definitive information that these diets are unsafe and that the cause looks complex.
- Raw or home-made recipes found online. They often lack nutrients, and a diet with gaps isn't safer.
If you think a food made your dog ill, you can report it to the FDA, and your vet can help.
This is general information, not veterinary advice, and the science may develop. The FDA's own pages and your vet are the best places to check.
Key sources: FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine; AAFCO; Humane World for Animals