Skip to content
๐Ÿถ Dogs

What are safe dog chews for a power chewer so I don’t end up at the ER?

Asked by BestiePaws team ยท 2 months ago

Say your 70-pound Lab treats every toy and chew like a project, and you’d like to keep chews under about $15 a month. The pet store aisle is full of antlers, hooves, hard nylon bones and rawhide twists, plus soft dental chews at higher prices. You’d like to know how to tell a safe chew from a risky one, what supervision really means, and what to do if he swallows something.

1 reply

  1. BestiePaws team Team 2 months ago

    The short version: skip the hard stuff, pick chews your dog can't snap a tooth on or swallow in one gulp, size them to his weight, and stay in the room while he chews. Most expensive chew-related vet visits come from a handful of products and habits, and the cheap fix is usually just a different aisle.

    For a 70 pound Lab who treats everything like a challenge, that means rethinking what counts as "tough." Tough to destroy and safe to chew aren't the same thing. Here's how to sort them.

    A rule of thumb from a veterinary hospital

    Dr. Brian Collins, who leads the Community Service Practice at Cornell University's Hospital for Animals, said he discourages owners from giving bones, antlers or hooves of any kind, or other hard or abrasive objects, because many objects can break or wear down teeth, become choking hazards or injure the digestive tract. His guideline for a suitable chew toy is that it should be bendable and able to be indented with a fingernail. He also recommends supervising dogs with toys, since it's hard to predict how any individual dog will handle an object.

    That fingernail test is free and takes five seconds in the store aisle. A rock-hard nylon bone, an elk antler, a cow hoof and a knuckle bone all fail it. If you can't dent it, your dog's teeth are the softer material in that contest.

    Advertisement

    The FDA's pet-proofing guidance lists bones among items that can get stuck in a dog's esophagus, stomach or intestines.

    Cooked bones from your own kitchen are no better. Chicken and turkey bones splinter, and the FDA notes dogs are good at helping themselves to the carcass in the trash.

    Reading the cost honestly

    Say a bag of "bone" chews costs $12 and a safe alternative costs $8. The $4 savings isn't the point. Say a blockage surgery estimate comes in at $3,000. At $8 a chew, you'd have to buy 375 of them before the safe option cost as much as one surgery. Your clinic's real estimate will differ, so ask for it in writing, but the proportions hold. A few dollars on the right chew is the cheap end of this decision.

    Dental chews: use the seal, size, and supervision

    The Veterinary Oral Health Council gives a seal of acceptance to products that show they reduce plaque or tartar when used as directed. The council doesn't test products itself. Companies submit data, and the council, made up of veterinary dentists and dental scientists, reviews it. The seal can be for plaque, tartar or both. It's a useful tiebreaker if you're choosing between two chews at the same price, and the council keeps a list of accepted dog products on its website that you can check from your phone in the store.

    The council also offers two practical tips for cutting down on blockages from dental chews: give the size that matches the dog's weight, and give the chew only when you're around to watch him eat it. A chew that's too small can be swallowed whole, and a dog who gulps big chunks is the one that ends up in surgery.

    The seal doesn't mean the chew replaces brushing, and it doesn't make it free of calories. Treats are typically not complete and balanced food, so count them in your dog's daily calories. WSAVA's guide says products labeled for intermittent or complementary feeding should be a small share of the diet, 10 percent or less.

    A few free ways to get this wrong:

    • Anything that has splintered, cracked or lost a big piece. Throw it out.
    • Chews that get smaller and smaller until the dog could swallow the last piece. Take the stub away before it's small enough to swallow.
    • Old socks, rope toys that are unraveling and stuffed toys with squeakers. A swallowed bit of fabric can block a dog's gut.
    • Hard plastic bottles, sticks and rocks.
    Advertisement

    The peanut butter question

    Stuffing a safe toy with peanut butter is a cheap way to keep a chewer busy, but check the label. Cornell's Riney Canine Health Center says xylitol, a sugar substitute, turns up in sugar-free gum, candy, toothpaste, peanut butter and baked goods, and that even a small amount can cause a drop in blood sugar, seizures or liver injury in dogs. The amount in products varies, even between flavors of one brand. Right away, if your dog eats something that might contain xylitol, call your vet, the Pet Poison Helpline at 855-764-7661 (it lists a $99 per-incident fee) or the ASPCA's Animal Poison Control Center line, 888-426-4435 (a consultation fee may apply). Both lines run around the clock, and either fee is far smaller than a night in the ER.

    Emergency signs

    Get your dog to a vet now, and call ahead on the way, if you see:

    • Repeated vomiting or retching with nothing coming up
    • A swollen or painful belly
    • Trouble breathing, gagging that doesn't stop, or pawing at the mouth
    • Collapse, extreme weakness or pale gums
    • Straining to pass stool, or no stool and a dog who won't eat

    Signs of a blockage may not appear right away, so a dog who swallowed something can seem fine at first. If you saw the swallowing, call anyway. Don't try to make him vomit unless a vet or poison control says to. With a sharp piece, that can do more damage coming back up.

    No brand names here, because prices and products shift, but these are the categories to look for and a way to check each.

    • Bendable rubber chew toys in your dog's size range. Pass the fingernail test, and match the size to his weight.
    • A dental chew that appears on the VOHC list, in the right size, given while you watch.
    • Frozen safe food in a durable toy, like plain wet dog food. Use a complete food and count the calories.
    • Rotating a few toys. A toy that's new again is more interesting and your dog chews it less ferociously.
    • Free or low-cost gear from a pet pantry. Search Pet Help Finder for food and supplies near you, and call to ask whether any toys or chews are on the shelf.

    If your dog is a power chewer who keeps destroying everything, ask your vet about the reason too. Boredom, teething and anxiety are different problems, and a short, free walk before a chew session can do more than a pricier toy. Your vet knows your dog's mouth and chewing habits best, so run any big change in chews past them.

    Key sources: Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine; FDA; Veterinary Oral Health Council

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” you might be talking to a worried owner.