Dr. Marty’s Dog Food vs. The Farmer’s Dog

When it comes to choosing the perfect meal for our canine companions, the options can be overwhelming. In the realm of premium dog foods, Dr. Marty’s Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog stand out as popular choices. But how do they stack up against each other?

Key Takeaways:

  • Dr. Marty’s offers a raw, freeze-dried diet with a variety of ingredients.
  • The Farmer’s Dog provides personalized, fresh-cooked meals tailored to your dog’s needs.
  • Both brands prioritize high-quality, nutritious ingredients.
  • Consider your budget and your dog’s specific needs when making a decision.
  • Consulting with a veterinarian can provide additional guidance tailored to your dog’s health.

Quality of Ingredients

Dr. Marty’s Dog Food: Dr. Marty’s takes pride in its use of all-natural, freeze-dried raw ingredients, ensuring that the nutrients remain intact. The recipes are crafted with a variety of protein sources, fruits, and vegetables, aiming to provide a balanced diet for dogs of all ages and sizes.

The Farmer’s Dog: On the other hand, The Farmer’s Dog emphasizes its commitment to using fresh, human-grade ingredients. Their meals are prepared in USDA kitchens, a testament to their high quality and safety standards. Like Dr. Marty’s, their recipes include a blend of proteins, vegetables, and wholesome grains.

Nutritional Value

Dr. Marty’s Dog Food: With its raw, freeze-dried format, Dr. Marty’s claims to offer a diet that closely mimics what dogs would eat in the wild. This method of preparation is believed to preserve the natural enzymes and nutrients in the food, promoting better digestion and overall health.

The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog sets itself apart with personalized meal plans tailored to an individual dog’s needs, taking into account factors such as age, breed, and health status. Their fresh-cooked meals are designed to provide complete and balanced nutrition, adhering to the guidelines set by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO).


Dr. Marty’s Dog Food: Dr. Marty’s offers convenience with its freeze-dried formula, allowing for a longer shelf life without the need for refrigeration. The food is easy to prepare—just add water, and it’s ready to serve.

The Farmer’s Dog: While The Farmer’s Dog requires refrigeration due to its fresh ingredients, they score high on convenience by delivering pre-portioned meals directly to your doorstep. This not only saves time but also ensures you’re feeding the correct amount.

Price and Value

Dr. Marty’s Dog Food: Dr. Marty’s Dog Food tends to be on the pricier side, reflecting its premium ingredients and freeze-dried preparation method. However, many pet owners find the health benefits and quality of ingredients justify the cost.

The Farmer’s Dog: Similarly, The Farmer’s Dog is a premium option with a price tag to match. The personalized service and high-quality ingredients offer great value, and many customers appreciate the convenience of home delivery.

Customer Feedback and Veterinary Support

Dr. Marty’s Dog Food: Customer reviews for Dr. Marty’s are mixed, with many praising the quality of ingredients and noticeable health benefits for their pets. However, some express concern over the cost and the palatability for pickier eaters.

The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog generally receives positive feedback, with customers noting improvements in their dogs’ health, energy levels, and coat condition. Veterinarians also tend to support the brand due to its adherence to nutritional guidelines and use of high-quality ingredients.


Choosing between Dr. Marty’s Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog ultimately depends on your priorities and your dog’s specific needs. Both offer premium ingredients and aim to provide a balanced and nutritious diet. Dr. Marty’s may be the better option for those seeking a raw, freeze-dried diet, while The Farmer’s Dog stands out with its personalized meal plans and fresh ingredients. Whichever you choose, you can rest assured that you are investing in a high-quality meal for your furry friend.

Comparison Table

Criteria Dr. Marty’s Dog Food The Farmer’s Dog
Quality of Ingredients
Nutritional Value
Price $$$ $$$
Customer Feedback Mixed Positive
Veterinary Support Varied Strong


1. How do Dr. Marty’s Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog source their ingredients?

Dr. Marty’s prides itself on selecting top-quality, natural ingredients, ensuring they are free from artificial preservatives and additives. The ingredients are primarily sourced within the United States, with a stringent quality control process to guarantee their purity and safety.

On the other side, The Farmer’s Dog emphasizes transparency and integrity in sourcing, utilizing human-grade ingredients. These ingredients come from reputable food suppliers, local farms, and other trusted sources, ensuring that every component in the recipes meets the highest standards of quality and safety.

2. Can I switch my dog’s current food to Dr. Marty’s or The Farmer’s Dog easily?

Transitioning your dog to a new food requires a gradual process to prevent digestive issues. For Dr. Marty’s, it’s recommended to slowly integrate the new food into your dog’s diet over a period of 7-10 days, increasing the amount of Dr. Marty’s while decreasing the old food progressively.

Similarly, when transitioning to The Farmer’s Dog, a gradual integration is key. The brand provides specific guidelines based on your dog’s profile, ensuring a smooth and safe transition to their fresh-cooked meals.

3. Are these dog food brands suitable for puppies?

Yes, both Dr. Marty’s and The Farmer’s Dog offer formulations suitable for puppies. Dr. Marty’s provides a nutrient-rich formula that supports the rapid growth and development of puppies.

The Farmer’s Dog also offers puppy-specific recipes, taking into account the unique nutritional needs of younger dogs. Their team of veterinary nutritionists ensures that the meals support healthy growth and development.

4. How do Dr. Marty’s and The Farmer’s Dog handle food allergies or sensitivities?

Dr. Marty’s offers a limited ingredient formula, which can be beneficial for dogs with food sensitivities or allergies. The simplicity of the ingredients list helps in identifying and avoiding potential allergens.

The Farmer’s Dog, with its personalized meal plans, takes a detailed approach to dogs with food allergies or sensitivities. During the onboarding process, pet owners have the opportunity to highlight any known allergies or sensitivities, allowing The Farmer’s Dog to tailor the meals to avoid triggering ingredients.

5. What is the shelf life of Dr. Marty’s Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog food?

Dr. Marty’s freeze-dried formula boasts a long shelf life, typically around 12-18 months when stored in a cool, dry place. The packaging is designed to preserve freshness and nutrient integrity over time.

The Farmer’s Dog, with its fresh-cooked meals, has a shorter shelf life and requires refrigeration. The meals can be stored in the fridge for up to 4 days, and they can also be frozen for extended storage, lasting up to 4 months in the freezer.

6. How do these brands compare in terms of environmental impact?

Dr. Marty’s, with its freeze-dried format, requires less packaging and has a lower shipping weight compared to fresh or frozen options, potentially resulting in a smaller carbon footprint.

The Farmer’s Dog takes sustainability seriously, using eco-friendly packaging and emphasizing responsible sourcing practices. Their efforts to minimize waste and support sustainable agriculture reflect a commitment to environmental stewardship.

7. Are Dr. Marty’s and The Farmer’s Dog available internationally?

Currently, Dr. Marty’s primarily operates within the United States, though there might be options to ship to Canada. It’s recommended to check directly with the company for the most accurate and up-to-date information.

The Farmer’s Dog also focuses on the U.S. market, and at this time, they do not offer international shipping. Their model is designed to ensure the freshness of their meals, which could be compromised with extended shipping times required for international delivery.

8. What customer support options are available for Dr. Marty’s and The Farmer’s Dog?

Dr. Marty’s provides customer support via phone and email, with a team ready to assist with any inquiries, order modifications, or issues that may arise. They emphasize customer satisfaction, offering a money-back guarantee on their products.

The Farmer’s Dog also offers robust customer support, including a dedicated team of pet care specialists available via phone or email. Their personalized approach extends to their customer service, ensuring that each pet owner receives the attention and information they need.

9. How do Dr. Marty’s and The Farmer’s Dog cater to specific breed needs?

Dr. Marty’s approach relies on providing a broad-spectrum formula aimed at catering to dogs of all breeds and sizes. They believe in the power of their natural ingredients to offer comprehensive nutritional benefits, supporting overall health and wellbeing.

Conversely, The Farmer’s Dog takes a personalized approach, tailoring meals to each dog’s individual profile, which includes breed, age, size, activity level, and health conditions. This ensures that the nutritional needs unique to each breed are taken into consideration and addressed adequately.

10. How do the cost comparisons between Dr. Marty’s and The Farmer’s Dog pan out?

Dr. Marty’s, with its freeze-dried format, tends to be on the pricier side due to the high-quality ingredients and production process. However, the long shelf life and concentrated nutrition can sometimes balance out the cost over time.

The Farmer’s Dog, providing fresh, personalized meals, also comes with a premium price tag. The cost is influenced by the dog’s size, age, and nutritional needs. While it might be more expensive than commercial kibble, many pet owners find the investment worthwhile for the health benefits and quality of the food.

11. What is the procedure if my dog doesn’t like the food from Dr. Marty’s or The Farmer’s Dog?

Dr. Marty’s stands behind their product with a 90-day money-back guarantee, ensuring that if your dog doesn’t take to the food, you can return it for a full refund, less shipping and handling.

The Farmer’s Dog also prioritizes customer satisfaction, offering a money-back guarantee on your first order if your dog refuses to eat the food or doesn’t react well to it. Their customer support is on standby to assist with any issues and provide guidance on how to make the transition to their food smoother.

12. How do both brands handle the freshness and safety of their products?

Dr. Marty’s utilizes freeze-drying technology to preserve the freshness and nutritional integrity of their ingredients, ensuring a long shelf life without the need for artificial preservatives.

The Farmer’s Dog takes a different route, preparing meals in USDA kitchens, quickly freezing them to lock in freshness, and delivering them straight to your door. The freshness is maintained through refrigeration, and meals come with clear expiration dates to ensure safety.

13. Are there any bulk purchase options or subscription plans available?

Dr. Marty’s offers bulk purchase options, providing discounts for larger orders. This is beneficial for households with multiple dogs or those looking to stock up and save in the long run.

The Farmer’s Dog operates primarily on a subscription basis, delivering freshly made meals on a regular schedule tailored to your dog’s needs. The subscription model ensures that you never run out of food, providing convenience and consistency.

14. How do both brands contribute to the community or engage in charitable activities?

While specific charitable activities or community engagement initiatives of Dr. Marty’s might not be widely publicized, many brands in the pet food industry take part in philanthropy and support animal welfare.

The Farmer’s Dog has a notable history of donations, providing meals to shelter dogs and engaging in partnerships that benefit animal welfare organizations. Their commitment to improving the lives of all dogs extends beyond their customer base.

15. Can I find reviews or testimonials from other pet owners who have tried Dr. Marty’s or The Farmer’s Dog?

Yes, both Dr. Marty’s and The Farmer’s Dog have reviews and testimonials available on their official websites, providing insight into other pet owners’ experiences with the brands. Additionally, third-party review sites and pet forums can offer a broader range of perspectives, helping you make an informed decision based on real-world experiences.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top