PetPlate vs. Ollie

As pet parents increasingly lean towards providing their four-legged companions with healthier, fresher meal options, the pet food market has seen an eruption of fresh food delivery services. Two companies, in particular, PetPlate and Ollie, have stood out. This article offers a detailed comparison of PetPlate vs. Ollie, examining each brand’s quality, ingredients, customization options, and more to help you make an informed decision.

A Bite into PetPlate

Founded by Renaldo Webb in 2016, PetPlate aims to elevate the pet food market’s standards by delivering high-quality, human-grade meals right to your doorstep.

Quality and Ingredients

PetPlate’s offerings are made from USDA-inspected meat and fresh vegetables. The meals are free of by-products, fillers, and artificial ingredients, ensuring that your dog gets a diet that’s both balanced and free from harmful additives.


When you sign up for PetPlate, you’re prompted to fill in details about your dog, such as breed, weight, age, and health condition. Using this information, PetPlate creates a tailored meal plan that caters to your dog’s specific nutritional needs.


PetPlate’s commitment to the environment is evident in their packaging. All their meal containers are made from recyclable, BPA-free plastic.

Ollie: A Nourishing Option

Co-founded by Gabby Slome, Alex Douzet, and Randy Jimenez in 2016, Ollie provides tailored, nutritious meals designed by veterinarians and crafted with love.

Quality and Ingredients

Ollie prides itself on its high-quality, human-grade food sources. The ingredients include real, USDA-certified meats and fresh fruits and vegetables. Ollie meals are free of artificial ingredients, preservatives, and by-products.


Just like PetPlate, Ollie gathers information about your dog’s breed, weight, age, activity level, and health conditions to create a personalized meal plan.


Ollie is conscious about its ecological footprint. Their meal trays are recyclable, and they provide a reusable lid with every order to minimize waste.

PetPlate vs. Ollie: The Faceoff

Both PetPlate and Ollie uphold admirable standards when it comes to ingredient quality, customization, and sustainability. So, how do they stack up against each other?

Menu Variety

While both companies offer a selection of meals, PetPlate has a slight edge with four different recipes: Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and Lamb. In comparison, Ollie offers Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and a unique Lamb recipe.


The cost of both services depends on factors like your dog’s size, breed, age, and health conditions. On average, Ollie is slightly more expensive than PetPlate. However, remember that the cost often reflects the quality of ingredients and customization level.

Shipping and Packaging

Both companies offer free shipping nationwide. Their meals are vacuum-sealed and packed in insulated boxes to ensure freshness upon delivery.


PetPlate and Ollie both deliver pre-portioned meals, making feeding time easy and hassle-free. You simply need to open the container, serve the right portion, and store the rest.

Personalization: Tailoring Meals for Furry Friends

When it comes to personalizing meal plans for your furry friends, both PetPlate and Ollie perform exceptionally well. They use a detailed questionnaire to capture important data about your pet, including breed, age, weight, activity level, and dietary restrictions or allergies.

However, where Ollie pulls ahead is in its wider range of adjustments. Along with offering plans for weight loss or gain, Ollie also provides options for less active dogs and those with food allergies, giving it a slight advantage in meal customization.

Recipe Quality and Nutritional Value

A closer examination of their offerings reveals that both brands use high-quality, human-grade ingredients. Both PetPlate and Ollie rely on real, whole foods, with a substantial portion of the meals composed of USDA-certified meats.

PetPlate uses ingredients like sweet potatoes, broccoli, and apples in their recipes, while Ollie incorporates a variety of vegetables and fruits, including kale, carrots, blueberries, and chia seeds. These nutrient-rich additions contribute essential vitamins and minerals to each meal.

While both companies ensure their meals meet AAFCO standards, Ollie’s recipes are formulated by a team of experienced veterinarians, giving it an edge when it comes to nutrition expertise.

Packaging and Sustainability

Both PetPlate and Ollie are committed to sustainable practices and eco-friendly packaging. PetPlate uses BPA-free, recyclable containers for their meals, while Ollie’s trays are also recyclable.

Ollie stands out by providing a reusable lid with each order, reducing plastic waste further. If environmental consciousness is a priority for you, you might appreciate Ollie’s slight edge in this regard.

Customer Experience and Support

The quality of customer support can significantly affect your overall experience with a pet food delivery service. Both PetPlate and Ollie offer a range of customer support options, including email and phone.

PetPlate’s customer service is renowned for being prompt and helpful, with multiple positive customer reviews highlighting their friendly and efficient support team. Ollie also offers comprehensive customer support, although some users have reported longer response times.

Flexibility and Delivery

With both PetPlate and Ollie, you can decide the frequency of your deliveries, pause, skip, or cancel at any time. This flexibility makes it convenient for pet parents to manage their orders according to their schedules and their pets’ needs.

However, it’s worth mentioning that Ollie offers a unique half-portion plan option, where you can choose to mix the fresh food with your existing kibble, giving a balance of freshness and cost-effectiveness, a feature that PetPlate doesn’t offer.

While both companies offer free shipping, Ollie’s reach is a bit wider, delivering to all 48 contiguous states. PetPlate, on the other hand, serves 48 states but excludes Alaska and Hawaii.

FAQs: Navigating the PetPlate and Ollie Landscape

How does the transition to PetPlate or Ollie work?

When transitioning your dog to either PetPlate or Ollie, it’s essential to introduce the new food gradually to avoid any digestive upset. Both companies provide a transition guide with their first order. Usually, the new food is slowly mixed with the old over a week or so, steadily increasing the proportion of the new food until it completely replaces the old.

Are there vegetarian or vegan options available?

Currently, neither PetPlate nor Ollie offer vegetarian or vegan options. Both companies emphasize the use of high-quality, USDA-certified meats in their recipes. It’s essential to remember that dogs require certain nutrients like taurine and L-carnitine that are primarily found in meat sources.

What if my dog doesn’t like the food?

Both PetPlate and Ollie have policies in place to address this. PetPlate offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, and they’ll work with you to find a meal your dog enjoys. Ollie also promises to refund the cost of your first box if your dog isn’t a fan of their recipes.

Can I warm up the meals?

Yes, you can! While both PetPlate and Ollie meals are perfectly safe to serve right out of the fridge, some dogs might prefer their food slightly warmed. Just be sure to stir the food thoroughly and test the temperature before serving it to your pet.

Can I switch between recipes?

Absolutely. Both PetPlate and Ollie allow you to switch between different recipes. This is especially useful if you have a picky eater or if you just want to give your dog some variety in their diet. With Ollie, you can even split your order between two different recipes.

How long do PetPlate and Ollie meals last?

PetPlate and Ollie meals are fresh and don’t contain preservatives, so they need to be stored in the refrigerator. After opening, PetPlate meals should be consumed within five days, while Ollie suggests using their food within four days.

Can I adjust my delivery frequency?

Yes, both PetPlate and Ollie offer flexible delivery schedules. You can choose how frequently you’d like to receive your shipments. This allows you to adjust your delivery schedule to suit your storage space or your pet’s eating habits.

Are PetPlate and Ollie meals vet-approved?

Absolutely. The recipes from both companies are formulated with the help of veterinarians to ensure they meet the nutritional needs of dogs. Moreover, Ollie’s meals are specifically formulated by a team of veterinary nutritionists, affirming the company’s commitment to providing nutritionally balanced meals.

What is the cost of PetPlate and Ollie meals?

The cost for both PetPlate and Ollie meals can vary based on factors like the size, age, breed, and health of your dog. Both companies provide a quiz on their website that can be filled out to get a customized quote. Generally, the price per day can range anywhere from $3 to $10 or more.

Are the recipes grain-free?

While PetPlate does offer grain-free recipes, Ollie includes healthy grains such as brown rice and chia seeds in their meals. However, both companies ensure that their recipes are free from fillers like corn, wheat, and soy, which are often associated with food allergies in dogs.

Do PetPlate and Ollie use organic ingredients?

Although both companies emphasize the use of high-quality, human-grade ingredients, not all of their ingredients are organic. The primary focus for PetPlate and Ollie is on providing nutrient-rich, wholesome meals using fresh ingredients.

What’s the protein content in PetPlate and Ollie meals?

The protein content in PetPlate and Ollie meals can vary based on the specific recipe. Typically, the crude protein content ranges from around 7% to 11%. The high-quality meats used in their recipes provide ample amounts of protein, essential for maintaining muscle health in dogs.

Are PetPlate and Ollie meals suitable for puppies?

Both PetPlate and Ollie offer meal plans that can cater to the nutritional needs of puppies. They provide nutrient-dense meals, which are essential for the rapid growth phase of puppies.

How are PetPlate and Ollie meals shipped?

Meals from PetPlate and Ollie are shipped in special insulated boxes to ensure they stay fresh during transit. They come in pre-portioned containers, making it easy for pet owners to serve the right amount to their dogs.

Can I pause or cancel my PetPlate or Ollie subscription?

Yes, both PetPlate and Ollie allow you to pause, modify, or cancel your subscription at any time. This flexibility makes these services convenient for pet parents who may need to adjust their schedules or dietary needs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top