Skip to content
๐Ÿ  Fish

I can’t keep my fish anymore. Where can I rehome fish instead of letting them go in a pond?

Asked by BestiePaws team ยท 4 months ago

Say you have a 29-gallon tank with several fish, including a goldfish that has outgrown it, and you’re moving into a place that doesn’t allow tanks. A neighbor suggested dumping them in the retention pond behind your building because it’s closer than finding a new home. You want to know why that’s a problem, where you can rehome fish for free, what to do with pond fish or plants, how to be honest about disease, and what to do if a fish is too sick to rehome.

1 reply

  1. BestiePaws team Team 4 months ago

    Please don't put them in the pond, the creek or the storm drain, even if it feels like the kind thing to do. Releasing aquarium or pond fish is rarely kind to the fish and can be harmful to the water they land in. The better news is that you do have options to rehome fish, and most of them are free: a pet store, another hobbyist, a school or nursing home, a local aquarium society, or an organized surrender event. If a fish is too sick to rehome, a vet can help with a humane end.

    Why release is the wrong answer

    The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has a plain message for goldfish owners: they are an invasive species and don't belong in the wild. The agency says one released goldfish can grow to as much as four pounds, and that a pet-store fish that fits in your palm can turn into a football-sized fish in open water. It also says goldfish stir up sediment and uproot plants, spawn several times a season, and carry parasites and diseases that native fish have no immunity to. It adds that most pets released to the wild don't survive, and many suffer before they die.

    Advertisement

    The U.S. Geological Survey's Nonindigenous Aquatic Species program goes further. It says released fish are physiologically stressed, prone to parasites and disease, and may be attacked by native predators. It reports that at least 185 exotic fish species had been caught in open U.S. waters, that 75 were known to have breeding populations, and that over half of these introductions came from the release or escape of aquarium fish. It also notes that releasing exotic fish may be illegal. Rules vary by state, so check with your state's fish and wildlife agency.

    Goldfish are one of the few temperate aquarium species established across the country, which is why they come up so often. Tropical fish like angelfish and cichlids usually can't survive cold winters, but they can take hold in warm states such as Florida and Texas, according to USGS, and that's a problem there.

    Plants and snails count too. Pennsylvania Sea Grant says aquarium plants like hydrilla and Brazilian waterweed have already reached state waters. Its advice is to seal aquatic plants in a plastic bag and put them in the trash, not the compost, since seeds and plant parts can spread. For the same reason, don't dump tank water or plants into a pond, creek or other waterway.

    Rehoming options that cost little or nothing

    The agencies list these, roughly in the order worth trying them:

    • The store where you bought the fish. Penn State's Sea Grant advice starts with asking the retailer for handling advice or a return. Some shops take fish back, and some won't, so call first.
    • Another hobbyist, pond owner or water gardener. Local aquarium societies and online hobby groups are full of people who'd take a healthy fish. The Fish and Wildlife Service suggests reaching out to groups dedicated to aquariums and fish hobbyists, and says many people would be willing to help rehome a pet fish.
    • Schools, nursing homes and community centers. The FWS says these places often have aquariums and may be able to take fish. The USGS page lists offices, museums, public aquariums, zoos, schools, nursing homes and hospitals as places that might accept a fish. Call ahead, because many have rules about what they'll accept.
    • A surrender event or adoption program. Pennsylvania Sea Grant describes aquarium pet surrender events run with humane societies, hobby clubs, aquariums and local businesses, where owners can give up fish without judgment, and a vet or vet tech may check each animal. Events are scattered and not always on the calendar, so search for "aquarium pet surrender" with your state name, and check with your state's Sea Grant program.
    • Don't Let It Loose. The FWS points owners to the Don't Let It Loose campaign for rehoming resources in each state. State wildlife agencies run versions of it, and some list partner pet stores, vet clinics and rescues, while Florida runs an amnesty program for nonnative pets. Search your own state's fish and wildlife site.
    Advertisement

    Pond fish and big fish

    Pond goldfish and koi can be hard to move, since they're large and need transport in oxygenated water. Pennsylvania Sea Grant suggests giving or trading with other pond owners or water gardeners, or donating to an aquarium society, school or aquatic business. A local koi or pond club is a good first call.

    Be realistic about the receiving home. A 12-inch goldfish needs a big tank or pond, and many classrooms can't offer that. Ask the new keeper what they'll do with the fish when it outgrows its space, and don't hand a fish to someone you doubt can care for it.

    Be honest about health

    Tell the new keeper what you know. VCA says that fish that had ich can stay carriers, so it advises caution when rehoming previously infected fish. If your fish had white spots, were treated, or shared water with sick fish, say so. The University of Florida's extension service says survivors can silently spread ich to fish that haven't been exposed. A kind person with a tank full of healthy fish would want to know, and a quarantine tank for 30 days protects both sides.

    When a fish can't be rehomed

    Sometimes a fish is old, very sick or in pain, and rehoming isn't fair to it. The USGS page says that if nothing else works, a veterinarian or fishery biologist can euthanize a fish with an anesthetic, and a pet shop may be able to help. Pennsylvania Sea Grant says to contact a veterinarian or a pet retailer for guidance about humane disposal, and calls disposal of live animals a last resort. Ask a vet what methods they use and what it costs, since fees vary by clinic. Don't improvise at home, and ask the vet about methods.

    If a fish dies on its own, bury it in your own yard or put it in the trash. Don't flush it or toss it in a pond.

    Making the decision when money is tight

    A lot of people end up here because of a move, a job loss, a breakup or a tank that has outgrown the budget. The pressure to fix it fast is real. A few steps help:

    • Pause the spending that's making the fish sicker. A tank with stable, treated water and regular feeding doesn't need to be rehomed tonight.
    • Call two or three possible takers this week rather than one, since many say no or have no room.
    • If the problem is housing, ask a local humane society whether it has a pet-support program or knows an aquarium club. Dial 211 and ask about local pet-assistance resources if you're in a crisis.
    • If you're moving, ask the new home's host whether they can keep a tank in the new place before deciding. Many fish travel fine with preparation, and a pet store can tell you how to bag them safely for a short trip.

    Reporting and preventing the next release

    If you've already let a fish go, or you see goldfish and other pet fish in a pond or stream, the FWS says to report sightings of invasive species to the USGS sighting report or your state's natural resource agency. And if you're thinking about buying more fish, wait. Think through the life span first. PetMD's veterinary care sheet says goldfish can live 30 years or more with proper care, and the species you pick should match what you can keep for its whole life.

    This is general information, not legal or veterinary advice. Rules about releasing and possessing fish differ by state, so check with yours.

    Key sources: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service; U.S. Geological Survey; Pennsylvania Sea Grant

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” you might be talking to a worried owner.