🐶 The Farmer’s Dog vs. Sundays vs. Ollie: Which Fresh Dog Food is Right for Your Pup?

Choosing the best food for your dog is a critical decision that can impact their health, happiness, and longevity. With so many options available, pet parents often find themselves comparing popular fresh food brands like The Farmer’s Dog, Sundays, and Ollie. Each offers unique benefits, but how do you know which one is right for your furry friend? This guide breaks down the key differences between these brands, including ingredients, pricing, customization options, and subscription flexibility—so you can make an informed choice that fits your dog’s needs.

---

Key Takeaways: Quick Answers About The Farmer’s Dog, Sundays, and Ollie

• Which brand is most customizable? The Farmer’s Dog offers personalized meal plans based on your dog’s breed, size, and health.
• Which is the easiest to store? Sundays delivers air-dried food that doesn’t require refrigeration.
• Which is the most affordable? Ollie generally offers a lower cost per meal for fresh, human-grade dog food.
• Which has the best ingredients? All three brands use high-quality, human-grade ingredients without artificial fillers or preservatives, but The Farmer’s Dog and Ollie focus more on fresh, cooked meals, while Sundays offers a unique air-dried option.

---

What Makes The Farmer’s Dog Stand Out? Personalized Fresh Meals 🍽️

The Farmer’s Dog offers fresh, vet-designed meals delivered to your door based on your dog’s breed, age, weight, activity level, and dietary preferences. Each meal is made from human-grade ingredients and is tailored specifically for your dog, ensuring they get the nutrition they need without any fillers or artificial preservatives.

1. Customization: This brand excels in its level of personalization. When you sign up, you fill out a detailed profile about your dog, which includes questions about their health, lifestyle, and dietary restrictions. The Farmer’s Dog then crafts a meal plan that’s portioned just for them, delivered on a regular schedule.
2. Fresh Ingredients: The Farmer’s Dog uses whole, fresh ingredients like chicken, beef, turkey, sweet potatoes, and spinach, which are gently cooked at low temperatures to preserve nutrients. This cooking method helps retain the natural vitamins and minerals in the food, making it a great option for dogs with sensitive stomachs or food allergies.
3. Convenience: Meals arrive pre-portioned and frozen, ready to thaw and serve. You simply store them in your fridge or freezer until it’s time to feed your dog. This ensures the food is as fresh as possible.

Pros	Cons	💡 Tip
Highly customizable based on your dog’s needs.	Requires freezer space for storage.	Plan ahead for freezer space, especially with larger dogs.
Fresh, human-grade ingredients.	Pricier than kibble alternatives.	Save by subscribing to regular deliveries for a discount.
Vet-designed, balanced meals.	May require gradual introduction for picky eaters.	Introduce the food slowly to avoid digestive issues.

💡 Pro Tip: If you’re transitioning from kibble to fresh food, introduce The Farmer’s Dog slowly by mixing it with your dog’s current food to prevent stomach upset.

---

What Sets Sundays Apart? Air-Dried Convenience with Fresh Ingredients 🥩

Unlike other fresh food brands, Sundays delivers air-dried dog food that’s made with human-grade ingredients. This method preserves the nutrients while creating a dry, shelf-stable product that doesn’t require refrigeration, making it a convenient option for busy pet parents.

1. Air-Dried Nutrition: Sundays uses a gentle air-drying process to create a food that retains the nutritional benefits of fresh ingredients without needing refrigeration. This makes it easy to store and serve, and it’s a good option for pet parents who want the benefits of fresh food without the hassle of freezing or thawing.
2. No Artificial Ingredients: Sundays prides itself on using 100% human-grade ingredients with no artificial fillers, preservatives, or flavors. Their recipes feature real meats like beef and chicken, along with nutrient-dense ingredients like blueberries, pumpkin, and carrots.
3. Easy to Serve: Because it’s air-dried, Sundays doesn’t require refrigeration or special handling. You can pour it straight into the bowl—just like kibble—but with the added nutritional benefits of fresh food. This makes it an excellent option for travel or for households without the freezer space needed for frozen meals.

Pros	Cons	💡 Tip
Doesn’t require refrigeration—easy to store.	Less customizable than other brands.	Great option for busy pet parents or those who travel frequently.
Air-dried to retain nutrients.	May not appeal to picky eaters due to texture.	Store in a cool, dry place to maintain freshness.
100% human-grade ingredients.	Limited protein options compared to competitors.	Consider mixing with wet food for variety.

💡 Pro Tip: Sundays is perfect if you want the benefits of fresh, high-quality ingredients without the storage requirements of frozen food. It’s also a great option for dogs who prefer a crunchier texture.

---

Why Choose Ollie? Budget-Friendly Fresh Food 🥘

Ollie is known for delivering fresh, human-grade meals at a more affordable price than some of its competitors. Like The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie offers meals that are made from whole, minimally processed ingredients and tailored to your dog’s unique needs.

1. Cost-Effective Fresh Food: Ollie stands out as a budget-friendly option for pet parents who want to feed their dog fresh, healthy meals without breaking the bank. Their prices are generally lower than The Farmer’s Dog, making it a great choice for those who are price-conscious but still want high-quality, fresh food.
2. Balanced, Fresh Ingredients: Each meal is designed by veterinary nutritionists to ensure your dog gets a complete and balanced diet. Ollie uses premium ingredients like chicken, lamb, beef, carrots, and kale, which are gently cooked to retain their nutritional value.
3. Convenient Subscription: Like other fresh food services, Ollie offers a subscription model with flexible delivery options. You can pause, skip, or change your order at any time, making it easy to fit into your schedule.

Pros	Cons	💡 Tip
More affordable than other fresh food brands.	Requires freezer space for storage.	Ideal for pet parents looking for fresh food at a lower price point.
Flexible subscription options.	Fewer customization options than The Farmer’s Dog.	Adjust portion sizes based on your dog’s changing needs.
Human-grade, minimally processed ingredients.	Only available via subscription, no one-time purchases.	Combine with kibble if you want to stretch out the meals and reduce costs.

💡 Pro Tip: If you’re looking to save even more, consider feeding Ollie as a mix-in with dry kibble. This allows you to incorporate fresh food while keeping your costs lower.

---

Which Brand Is the Most Affordable? Breaking Down Costs 💸

Price is an important consideration for many pet parents, and each of these brands offers different pricing structures based on your dog’s size, dietary needs, and the delivery frequency. Here’s a basic breakdown of what you can expect to pay:

Brand	Average Cost (Small Dog)	Average Cost (Large Dog)	Delivery Frequency	💡 Tip
The Farmer’s Dog	$2 to $5 per day	$8 to $10 per day	Every 2 to 4 weeks	Get a discount for subscribing to recurring deliveries.
Sundays	$2 to $4 per day	$6 to $8 per day	Every 4 to 8 weeks (shelf-stable)	Less frequent deliveries make this great for busy schedules.
Ollie	$1 to $4 per day	$6 to $8 per day	Every 2 to 4 weeks	Check for promotions or discounts on your first order.

💡 Pro Tip: If you’re on a budget, Ollie offers a great balance between cost and quality, while The Farmer’s Dog provides more customization for those with specific dietary needs.

---

Which Fresh Dog Food Brand Should You Choose? Personalization, Storage, and Convenience 🐕

When it comes to choosing between The Farmer’s Dog, Sundays, and Ollie, it’s important to consider your dog’s specific needs, your lifestyle, and your budget. Here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

1. The Farmer’s Dog: Best for pet parents who want highly customized, fresh meals tailored to their dog’s unique dietary needs. This brand is ideal for dogs with allergies, sensitivities, or specific nutritional requirements. However, it does require freezer space and is a bit pricier.
2. Sundays: Perfect for those who want the convenience of a shelf-stable product with the nutritional benefits of fresh ingredients. Sundays doesn’t require refrigeration, making it an excellent choice for pet parents who are on-the-go or lack freezer space.
3. Ollie: Offers a balance between quality and affordability. It’s a great choice for pet parents looking to provide their dog with fresh, human-grade meals without overspending. While it requires some freezer space, its pricing is competitive, and the quality is comparable to other fresh food brands.

---

Final Thoughts: Tailoring the Choice to Your Dog’s Needs

Each of these brands—The Farmer’s Dog, Sundays, and Ollie—brings something unique to the table. Whether you prioritize freshness, storage convenience, cost, or customization, there’s a solution that fits both your dog’s dietary needs and your lifestyle.

---

Quick Recap: The Farmer’s Dog vs. Sundays vs. Ollie

• The Farmer’s Dog: Best for highly customized, fresh meals tailored to specific dietary needs. Requires freezer space.
• Sundays: Convenient, shelf-stable, air-dried food that’s easy to store. Great for busy pet parents.
• Ollie: Affordable fresh food option that offers a balance of cost and quality, with flexible subscription options.

Choosing the right food will keep your dog healthy and happy for years to come. 🐾

---

Comment 1: “Which brand is better for dogs with allergies? My dog has food sensitivities, and I need to be careful with ingredients.”

Answer: For dogs with food allergies or sensitivities, The Farmer’s Dog and Ollie are generally better options compared to Sundays, primarily because of their high level of customization and the ability to tailor meals to your dog’s specific dietary needs.

1. The Farmer’s Dog: This brand is particularly good for dogs with food allergies because of the detailed customization process they offer. When you sign up, you provide information about your dog’s allergies, and their nutritionists will craft a meal plan that excludes allergens. For example, if your dog is allergic to chicken, they’ll create a meal plan using other protein sources like turkey, beef, or pork. Additionally, they use simple, whole ingredients with no fillers, which minimizes the risk of exposing your dog to potential allergens.
2. Ollie: While Ollie doesn’t offer the same level of customization as The Farmer’s Dog, they still focus on using limited ingredients and whole foods, which can help reduce the likelihood of an allergic reaction. They offer specific recipes like lamb, which is often a good choice for dogs with sensitivities to more common proteins like chicken or beef. Their meals are formulated by veterinary nutritionists, ensuring they meet the needs of dogs with various health conditions, including allergies.
3. Sundays: Sundays is a bit less customizable, though their air-dried recipes are also made from human-grade ingredients. While they do not offer the same detailed allergy accommodations as The Farmer’s Dog, they use minimal, high-quality ingredients without fillers or artificial preservatives. However, if your dog has specific protein allergies or requires a more tailored diet, The Farmer’s Dog would likely be the safer bet.

Brand	Best for Allergies?	Why It Works	💡 Tip
The Farmer’s Dog	Yes, highly customizable.	Personalized meal plans based on your dog’s specific allergies.	Fill out their detailed allergy form to tailor meals.
Ollie	Good for limited ingredients.	Uses fewer fillers and whole, minimally processed proteins.	Opt for their lamb recipe if chicken or beef is a concern.
Sundays	Moderate for general sensitivities.	Simple, high-quality ingredients but less customizable.	Consult their ingredient list to avoid known allergens.

💡 Pro Tip: If your dog has specific protein allergies, both The Farmer’s Dog and Ollie offer protein options that cater to sensitive dogs. Always introduce new foods gradually to ensure your dog doesn’t have a reaction to the new ingredients.

---

Comment 2: “How does Sundays compare to kibble in terms of nutrition? I like the convenience of dry food, but I want something healthier.”

Answer: Sundays offers a healthier alternative to traditional kibble while maintaining the convenience of a dry food. The main difference lies in the quality of ingredients and the air-drying process, which preserves the nutrients typically lost during the high-heat extrusion used to make kibble.

1. Nutrient Retention: Traditional kibble is made through an extrusion process that involves high heat, which can destroy important nutrients. Sundays, on the other hand, uses a gentle air-drying method that retains more of the food’s natural vitamins and minerals. This means your dog gets the whole food benefits of fresh ingredients with the convenience of dry food.
2. Human-Grade Ingredients: One of the biggest advantages of Sundays over kibble is that they use 100% human-grade ingredients, including real meat, fruits, and vegetables. Many commercial kibbles rely on by-products and fillers, which provide less nutritional value. Sundays, with its limited ingredient list, ensures that your dog is eating food that is closer to what you would feed them if you were cooking at home.
3. Shelf-Stable: Like kibble, Sundays doesn’t require refrigeration, making it ideal for pet parents who need the convenience of a dry food but don’t want to compromise on nutrition. Sundays offers a crunchier texture, much like kibble, but with significantly higher-quality ingredients and no artificial preservatives, fillers, or grains.

Comparison	Sundays	Traditional Kibble	💡 Tip
Nutrient Retention	Air-dried to preserve nutrients.	High-heat processing destroys some nutrients.	Sundays offers better nutritional integrity than kibble.
Ingredients	Human-grade meats and vegetables.	Often contains fillers and by-products.	Check ingredient labels on kibble for hidden fillers.
Shelf Stability	Air-dried, shelf-stable like kibble.	Long shelf-life but often includes preservatives.	Sundays offers the convenience of kibble without compromising quality.

💡 Pro Tip: If you like the convenience of kibble but want a healthier option, Sundays is an excellent choice. It’s easy to store and serve, with significantly higher nutritional value than most kibble brands.

---

Comment 3: “Which of these brands is better for a picky eater? My dog is very selective about their food.”

Answer: For picky eaters, Ollie tends to be the most popular choice, but The Farmer’s Dog can also work well, depending on your dog’s preferences. Here’s why:

1. Ollie: Many dogs find Ollie’s meals extremely palatable due to the freshness and variety of the ingredients. The meals are lightly cooked, which enhances the aroma and taste without sacrificing nutritional value. Ollie also offers several protein options, including chicken, beef, lamb, and turkey, allowing you to switch recipes if your dog becomes bored with one. The freshness of the ingredients combined with natural textures and flavors makes it a great option for dogs who turn their noses up at standard kibble or even other fresh food brands.
2. The Farmer’s Dog: With The Farmer’s Dog, you get the added benefit of customization. If your dog is picky, you can tailor the meals based on their preferences and even adjust portion sizes to find the right balance of taste and nutrition. The fresh ingredients and whole foods are similar to Ollie, so many picky eaters will enjoy the flavor. Plus, their minimal processing ensures the meals retain their natural flavors and textures, which can appeal to selective dogs.
3. Sundays: Sundays offers a crunchier texture, similar to kibble, which some picky eaters may prefer. However, if your dog is more accustomed to moist or soft food, they may take some time to adjust to the air-dried format. Sundays does offer high-quality, human-grade ingredients, but the texture may not be as immediately appealing to dogs used to softer food.

Brand	Best for Picky Eaters?	Why It Works	💡 Tip
Ollie	Yes, highly palatable.	Fresh, lightly cooked meals with multiple protein options.	Rotate protein sources to keep your dog interested.
The Farmer’s Dog	Yes, with customization.	Fresh, customizable meals tailored to your dog’s preferences.	Tailor portion sizes and switch up the proteins for variety.
Sundays	Good for crunch-loving dogs.	Air-dried, shelf-stable with a crunchy texture.	Try mixing it with wet food for added appeal if your dog prefers softer textures.

💡 Pro Tip: For picky eaters, consider starting with Ollie’s fresh, cooked meals and rotating the protein options to keep things interesting. If your dog prefers crunchy food, Sundays can be a great alternative, but you might need to mix it with wet food initially.

---

Comment 4: “How do these brands handle portion control and meal delivery? I want to make sure my dog is getting the right amount.”

Answer: All three brands—The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie, and Sundays—take portion control seriously and offer easy, pre-portioned meals based on your dog’s specific needs. Here’s how they differ:

1. The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog offers precisely portioned meals based on your dog’s weight, breed, activity level, and age. When you sign up, you provide detailed information about your dog, and the meals are then tailored specifically to their caloric needs. Each package comes pre-portioned for easy feeding, so you don’t have to measure anything—just thaw and serve.
2. Ollie: Similar to The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie also provides pre-portioned meals customized to your dog’s size and dietary requirements. Their packaging includes clear feeding instructions based on the meal plan you’ve selected, and you can adjust the portions as your dog’s weight or activity level changes. This ensures that your dog is always getting the right amount of food without over- or under-feeding.
3. Sundays: Sundays offers slightly more flexibility since it’s a dry, air-dried food, but they also provide feeding guidelines based on your dog’s size and weight. Since it’s a shelf-stable product, you can easily scoop out the right amount according to their recommendations. While not individually portioned like The Farmer’s Dog or Ollie, it’s still easy to manage portion control with the detailed instructions provided.

Brand	Portion Control	Delivery	💡 Tip
The Farmer’s Dog	Pre-portioned, tailored meals.	Delivered frozen with easy thaw-and-serve instructions.	Adjust meal portions as your dog’s activity level changes.
Ollie	Pre-portioned based on dog’s needs.	Delivered fresh, with flexible subscription options.	Monitor weight and adjust portion sizes as necessary.
Sundays	Flexible portioning, easy to measure.	Shelf-stable, delivered regularly based on plan.	Use a kitchen scale to ensure precise portion control.

💡 Pro Tip: If your dog’s weight or activity level changes, it’s important to adjust their portion sizes accordingly. Both The Farmer’s Dog and Ollie make it easy to update your dog’s profile and modify their meal plan as needed.

---

Comment 5: “Is there a significant difference in delivery and storage between these brands? I don’t have much freezer space.”

Answer: Storage and delivery are important factors to consider, especially if you’re tight on space. Here’s how the three brands compare:

1. The Farmer’s Dog: Meals are delivered frozen and need to be stored in the freezer until ready to serve. You’ll want to thaw the meals in your fridge the night before feeding. If freezer space is an issue, The Farmer’s Dog might be challenging for larger dogs, as they require more food and freezer space.
2. Ollie: Ollie’s meals are also delivered fresh and frozen. Like The Farmer’s Dog, they require freezer storage, but you can choose the frequency of deliveries to help manage your freezer space. Ollie’s flexible subscription allows you to customize delivery times, so you don’t get overwhelmed with too much food at once.
3. Sundays: Sundays wins in the storage department because it’s air-dried and shelf-stable. It doesn’t need refrigeration or freezing, making it the most convenient option if you’re low on freezer space. You can store the bag in your pantry, and it will stay fresh for months, unlike frozen options.

Brand	Storage Needs	Delivery Frequency	💡 Tip
The Farmer’s Dog	Requires freezer storage.	Every 2 to 4 weeks, depending on subscription.	Plan ahead for freezer space, especially for larger dogs.
Ollie	Requires freezer storage.	Flexible delivery based on your preferences.	Choose a more frequent delivery to manage freezer space.
Sundays	Shelf-stable, no freezer needed.	Delivered every 4 to 8 weeks depending on usage.	Perfect for households with limited freezer space.

💡 Pro Tip: If you don’t have a lot of freezer space, Sundays is your best option for hassle-free storage. For fresh meals, consider more frequent deliveries from Ollie or The Farmer’s Dog to avoid taking up too much freezer space at once.