Nom Nom vs. The Farmer’s Dog vs. Ollie: Which Fresh Dog Food Is Best for Your Pup? 🐶🥩
As pet owners seek healthier alternatives for their dogs, fresh dog food delivery services have grown in popularity. Among the top contenders, Nom Nom, The Farmer’s Dog, and Ollie stand out for their tailored nutrition, quality ingredients, and convenient delivery. But how do these brands truly compare? We dive deep into their ingredients, customization, pricing, and more, to help you make the best decision for your four-legged friend.
Key Takeaways: Quick Answers About Nom Nom vs. The Farmer’s Dog vs. Ollie
- Which brand offers the best ingredients? 🥦 All three use high-quality, human-grade ingredients, but Ollie includes more unique protein options like lamb.
- Which is more affordable? 💰 The Farmer’s Dog typically offers the best value per meal, depending on your dog’s size.
- Which has the best customization? 🛠️ Nom Nom’s detailed health insights and tailored microbiome support stand out.
- Which is easiest to serve? 🍽️ Ollie’s resealable trays offer added convenience, but all three brands are user-friendly.
- Which offers the best variety? 🍗 Ollie has the edge with its lamb option, while Nom Nom and The Farmer’s Dog focus on core proteins like beef, turkey, and chicken.
🥦 Which Brand Offers the Best Ingredients?
All three brands use human-grade ingredients, meaning the ingredients are fit for human consumption, but there are subtle differences in quality and sourcing:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom focuses on high-quality, restaurant-grade meats, whole vegetables, and simple ingredients. The brand prioritizes minimal processing, which helps retain natural nutrients. Ingredients are listed clearly, including protein sources like chicken, beef, turkey, and pork, paired with vegetables like carrots, squash, and spinach.
- The Farmer’s Dog: This brand uses USDA-approved meat, fresh vegetables, and minimal fillers. It’s committed to sourcing antibiotic-free meats and includes a limited number of ingredients to minimize potential allergens. Core proteins include beef, turkey, chicken, and pork, combined with ingredients like sweet potatoes and lentils.
- Ollie: Ollie uses fresh, high-quality ingredients and offers more unique protein options like lamb, in addition to beef, turkey, and chicken. The brand also incorporates more nutrient-dense ingredients like blueberries and chia seeds, adding extra antioxidants and omega fatty acids.
| Brand | Protein Options | Key Ingredients | 💡 Special Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Chicken, beef, turkey, pork | Whole veggies, brown rice | Minimal processing, clear labeling 🥕 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Beef, turkey, chicken, pork | Sweet potatoes, lentils | USDA meat, limited allergens 🥩 |
| Ollie | Chicken, beef, turkey, lamb | Blueberries, chia seeds | Nutrient-dense, diverse proteins 🫐 |
💰 Which Brand Is More Affordable?
The cost of these brands varies based on your dog’s size, activity level, and dietary needs. Here’s a breakdown of their general pricing structure:
- Nom Nom: Prices start at approximately $3-$4 per day for small dogs but can increase significantly for larger breeds. Nom Nom provides the option to order half-portions, making it more cost-effective for pet owners who wish to mix fresh food with kibble.
- The Farmer’s Dog: Known for its competitive pricing, The Farmer’s Dog offers rates starting around $2-$3 per day for small dogs. It is generally considered the most affordable of the three, especially for larger breeds, as the cost per meal decreases slightly with bigger servings.
- Ollie: Ollie’s pricing tends to be on the higher end, with daily costs starting at $4-$5 for small dogs. However, Ollie does offer a 60% off trial box, making it more budget-friendly initially. Ollie’s higher cost is largely due to its diverse ingredient list and lamb options.
| Brand | Starting Price (per day) | Price for Large Dogs | 💡 Cost-Saving Tips |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | $3-$4 | Higher for large breeds | Try half-portions with kibble mix 🥄 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | $2-$3 | Moderate for large breeds | Order in bulk for savings 💰 |
| Ollie | $4-$5 | Higher due to diverse proteins | Take advantage of the trial discount 🛒 |
🛠️ Which Has the Best Customization?
Customization is crucial when it comes to tailored dog nutrition, and all three brands excel in this area, but each has a unique approach:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom offers detailed customization through its pet health profile, which includes information on your dog’s age, weight, breed, and health concerns. It also provides Microbiome Testing Kits, which analyze your dog’s gut health to offer further dietary recommendations.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog’s customization starts with an in-depth questionnaire that assesses breed, activity level, weight, body type, and health goals. It also allows for more flexible meal adjustments over time, such as increasing or decreasing portion sizes as your dog’s weight changes.
- Ollie: Ollie’s onboarding process is similarly detailed, taking into account your dog’s age, weight, allergies, and sensitivities. Ollie’s system sends automatic portion adjustments based on your dog’s changing needs, which makes it convenient for owners.
| Brand | Customization Features | Health Focus | 💡 Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Microbiome testing, detailed profile | Gut health analysis | Dogs with sensitive digestion 🦠 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Flexible meal adjustments | Adjusts for weight changes | Weight management, active dogs ⚖️ |
| Ollie | Allergy-friendly settings | Auto portion adjustments | Dogs with allergies, busy owners 📆 |
🍽️ Which Is Easiest to Serve?
Ease of serving can make a significant difference in a busy household. Here’s how the three brands compare:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom packages each meal in pre-portioned vacuum-sealed bags, making serving straightforward and mess-free. Simply tear open and pour into your dog’s bowl. The clear packaging also allows you to see the food’s texture and ingredients, which adds peace of mind.
- The Farmer’s Dog: Meals are delivered in eco-friendly, vacuum-sealed bags with daily portions pre-measured. The Farmer’s Dog uses soft food packs that are easy to store in the fridge or freezer, but the bags are bulkier, making it slightly more challenging to handle and pour cleanly.
- Ollie: Ollie’s meals come in resealable plastic trays, making them the most convenient for serving and storage. You can easily scoop out partial servings and reseal the tray to maintain freshness, making Ollie a great choice for dogs who need smaller, more frequent meals.
| Brand | Packaging Type | Serving Ease | 💡 Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Vacuum-sealed bags | Easy to open, pour-ready | Busy households, clear portions ⏳ |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Soft, vacuum-sealed bags | Bulkier, pre-measured | Environmentally conscious owners 🌍 |
| Ollie | Resealable trays | Scoop, serve, reseal | Multi-meal dogs, easy storage 🥄 |
🍗 Which Offers the Best Variety?
Protein variety is important for dogs, especially those with dietary sensitivities or preferences:
- Nom Nom: Offers four primary proteins: chicken, turkey, beef, and pork. The limited variety focuses on the core proteins to ensure minimal allergies, making it suitable for dogs with sensitive stomachs.
- The Farmer’s Dog: Features four proteins: beef, turkey, chicken, and pork, but tends to have a simpler ingredient list compared to Ollie. It’s a good option for dogs with restricted diets or multiple allergies.
- Ollie: Provides a wider range of protein options, including lamb, which adds diversity. The inclusion of lamb is beneficial for dogs that may not tolerate more common proteins like chicken or beef.
| Brand | Protein Variety | Best For | 💡 Top Option |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | 4 core proteins | Sensitive stomachs | Chicken Chow Chow for gentle digestion 🥩 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | 4 core proteins | Dogs with restricted diets | Pork & Sweet Potato for fewer allergens 🍠 |
| Ollie | 4 proteins, incl. lamb | Variety-seeking dogs | Lamb Recipe for more diverse diet 🐑 |
Quick Recap: Fresh Dog Food Comparison
- Best ingredients? 🥦 Ollie with nutrient-dense options like blueberries and chia seeds.
- Most affordable? 💰 The Farmer’s Dog with competitive pricing.
- Top customization? 🛠️ Nom Nom, with microbiome insights and health tracking.
- Easiest to serve? 🍽️ Ollie, thanks to resealable trays.
- Best variety? 🍗 Ollie, with unique proteins like lamb.
Ultimately, the choice depends on your dog’s specific needs, dietary preferences, and your budget. Consulting with your veterinarian can help you decide which of these top brands is the best fit for your furry companion. 🐶🥩
Comment 1: “Which brand is better for dogs with food allergies?”
When it comes to managing food allergies, all three brands—Nom Nom, The Farmer’s Dog, and Ollie—offer specific advantages, but there are some distinctions in their approach:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom’s recipes focus on simpler ingredient lists, which makes it easier to identify potential allergens. Each meal contains one primary protein source, such as chicken or beef, paired with vegetables like squash, spinach, and carrots. This approach helps minimize the risk of cross-reactivity and allows for easier elimination diets to pinpoint the allergen.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog’s recipes are intentionally limited in terms of ingredient diversity, using single-protein formulations that cater to dogs with restricted diets. The use of USDA-certified meats ensures high quality, while the inclusion of simple carbohydrates like sweet potatoes and lentils adds digestibility without common allergens like corn or soy.
- Ollie: Ollie stands out with its inclusion of less common proteins like lamb, which is often used in hypoallergenic diets. For dogs that react to typical proteins like chicken or beef, Ollie’s lamb recipe offers an excellent alternative. Additionally, the use of blueberries and chia seeds adds a natural boost of antioxidants and omega-3 fatty acids, which help support skin health in allergy-prone dogs.
| Brand | Allergy-Friendly Features | Best Formula for Allergies | 💡 When to Choose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Single-protein recipes | Chicken Chow Chow or Beef Mash | Ideal for elimination diets 🥄 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Limited ingredient focus | Pork & Sweet Potato Recipe | Great for dogs with multiple allergies 🌾 |
| Ollie | Lamb option, diverse ingredients | Lamb Recipe with Blueberries | Best for dogs allergic to common proteins 🐑 |
Comment 2: “Which is better for weight management?”
All three brands offer fresh food options that can be adjusted for weight management, but each has specific attributes that cater to this need:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom provides detailed calorie control through its personalized meal plans, which are adjusted based on your dog’s weight, body condition, and activity level. The brand also offers a “half-portion” plan, which allows owners to mix fresh food with kibble, making it easier to reduce calories while maintaining satiety.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog uses its customized meal plans to create portion-controlled diets aimed at achieving and maintaining a healthy weight. Recipes focus on lean proteins like turkey and moderate carbs like broccoli and lentils, ensuring that the meals are both filling and low in unnecessary calories.
- Ollie: Ollie offers a “Weight Loss Meal Plan” that automatically adjusts portion sizes to help dogs shed extra pounds. Ollie’s turkey recipe is especially designed for weight management, as it combines lean protein with low-calorie ingredients like carrots and chia seeds, which offer fiber to enhance fullness.
| Brand | Weight Management Features | Recommended Recipe | 💡 Feeding Strategy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Half-portion plans, calorie control | Turkey Fare | Combine with kibble for reduced calories 🥗 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Lean proteins, customized portions | Turkey Recipe | Adjust portions gradually for weight loss ⚖️ |
| Ollie | Weight loss meal plans | Turkey Recipe with Chia Seeds | Use full portions for quicker results 🏋️ |
Comment 3: “Which brand is more suitable for puppies?”
When it comes to feeding puppies, all three brands offer nutritionally balanced meals that support growth, but some excel in specific areas:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom tailors its recipes for puppies by adjusting caloric density, which supports growth while avoiding overfeeding. Their meals include DHA-rich fish oil, which is critical for brain development. The Turkey Fare recipe is often recommended for puppies due to its easily digestible ingredients and high protein content.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog provides formulas that are suitable for puppies by using calorie-dense ingredients like beef and pork, which cater to the higher energy needs of growing dogs. The brand’s custom portion sizes are adjusted to accommodate rapid growth, making it ideal for puppies in different life stages.
- Ollie: Ollie’s recipes are naturally rich in protein and fats, with the inclusion of ingredients like cod liver oil, which supplies DHA for brain and eye development. Ollie’s beef and turkey recipes are particularly recommended for puppies due to their high protein and fat levels, which align with the needs of growing dogs.
| Brand | Puppy-Specific Features | Top Puppy Recipe | 💡 Feeding Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | DHA inclusion, calorie-adjusted | Turkey Fare | Use smaller, more frequent meals 🍼 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Calorie-dense, customized sizes | Beef Recipe | Adjust portion sizes monthly for growth 📏 |
| Ollie | High protein, cod liver oil | Beef Recipe with Cod Liver Oil | Ensure higher fat intake for growth 🥩 |
Comment 4: “How do these brands compare in terms of sustainability?”
Sustainability is an important factor for many pet owners, and each brand has different strengths in this area:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom focuses on eco-friendly packaging by using recyclable materials and minimal plastic. The company’s focus on locally sourced ingredients also helps reduce carbon emissions, making it a strong choice for environmentally conscious owners.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog uses biodegradable insulation and recyclable packaging, setting a high standard for sustainability. Additionally, its delivery system optimizes routes to minimize the carbon footprint, aligning with its mission to be eco-conscious.
- Ollie: Ollie uses recyclable trays and aims to minimize waste by offering meals in portion-specific containers that reduce food waste. While it’s eco-conscious, it doesn’t currently use as many biodegradable materials as The Farmer’s Dog.
| Brand | Sustainability Efforts | Packaging Type | 💡 Eco-Friendly Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Locally sourced ingredients | Recyclable packaging | Reuse packaging as compost liners 🌿 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Biodegradable insulation | Biodegradable bags | Consider consolidating shipments 📦 |
| Ollie | Portion-specific containers | Recyclable trays | Recycle trays with local facilities ♻️ |
Comment 5: “Which brand is better for picky eaters?”
If you have a picky eater, choosing the right brand can make a significant difference:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom’s use of simple, fresh ingredients and clear food visibility can be appealing to picky dogs. The brand’s meals have a soft texture and high moisture content, making them easy to eat and digest. Additionally, the smell and appearance of the food are often more appetizing to finicky eaters.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog emphasizes aromatic ingredients, which makes it enticing for picky dogs. The use of meats like beef and pork, along with the inclusion of flavors like carrots and sweet potatoes, adds to the appeal. The brand’s meals have a chunkier texture, which some dogs prefer.
- Ollie: Ollie offers a variety of flavors, including the less common lamb option, which can be particularly attractive to picky eaters who may be bored with standard proteins. The resealable trays also help keep the food fresher for longer, preserving the aroma and taste between meals.
| Brand | Appeal for Picky Eaters | Best Flavor Variety | 💡 Feeding Strategy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Soft texture, clear visibility | Chicken Chow Chow | Warm food slightly to enhance aroma 🌡️ |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Chunky texture, aromatic | Pork & Sweet Potato Recipe | Mix in a bit of warm broth for variety 🍲 |
| Ollie | Variety of proteins | Lamb Recipe | Alternate between recipes to avoid boredom 🐑 |
Comment 6: “Which is better for dogs with sensitive stomachs?”
All three brands offer recipes designed for sensitive stomachs, but each brand’s approach varies:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom’s recipes are often recommended for dogs with sensitive digestion due to the use of simple ingredients and the availability of a microbiome testing kit. The Turkey Fare recipe, featuring turkey, brown rice, and carrots, is particularly gentle on the stomach and is often a go-to for digestive issues.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog’s minimal ingredient recipes reduce the risk of gastrointestinal upset. The pork and turkey recipes include ingredients like lentils and sweet potatoes, which offer high fiber content to help stabilize digestion.
- Ollie: Ollie’s sensitive-stomach-friendly options include the lamb and turkey recipes, which are enriched with probiotics and chia seeds to enhance gut health. These recipes aim to support digestion with easily digestible proteins and fiber-rich ingredients.
| Brand | Sensitive Stomach Features | Gentlest Recipe | 💡 Feeding Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Simple ingredients, microbiome testing | Turkey Fare | Introduce gradually over 7-10 days 🦠 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | High fiber, minimal ingredients | Pork Recipe | Feed smaller portions to reduce GI upset 🍽️ |
| Ollie | Probiotics, chia seeds | Lamb Recipe with Chia Seeds | Add warm water to soften food texture 💧 |
Comment 7: “Which brand offers the best customer service?”
Customer service can be a decisive factor, especially when dealing with personalized meal plans:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom provides 24/7 customer support through phone, email, and chat, making it easy to reach out with any questions. The brand also offers easy modification of meal plans and delivery schedules through an online portal.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog is known for its responsive customer service, particularly through email and phone. Customers often report positive interactions, with representatives willing to adjust meal plans and provide guidance on transitioning diets.
- Ollie: Ollie offers live chat support, which provides instant help for quick questions. Their customer service is highly rated for its proactive approach, often following up to ensure that meal plans are meeting expectations and making changes as needed.
| Brand | Customer Service Options | Best Feature | 💡 Customer Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | 24/7 phone, email, chat | Round-the-clock support | Use online chat for faster responses 📨 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Phone, email | Personalized dietary guidance | Reach out for help during transitions 🛎️ |
| Ollie | Live chat, email | Proactive follow-ups | Use chat for immediate adjustments 🖥️ |
Comment 8: “How do these brands compare for senior dogs?”
Senior dogs have unique nutritional needs, including joint support, higher fiber, and easily digestible proteins:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom’s recipes for seniors focus on digestible ingredients and balanced protein-to-fat ratios. The brand’s inclusion of omega-3 fatty acids helps maintain joint health, while fiber-rich ingredients support digestive function. The Beef Mash recipe is particularly recommended for older dogs due to its protein and iron content.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog provides senior-friendly meals with a focus on high-quality proteins and softer textures that are easier for seniors to chew. The recipes contain high fiber from vegetables like carrots and broccoli, which aids digestion and helps regulate weight.
- Ollie: Ollie includes ingredients like cod liver oil in its recipes, which is beneficial for senior dogs’ cognitive health and joint lubrication. The soft texture of Ollie’s meals also makes them easier to chew and digest, which is ideal for older dogs with dental issues.
| Brand | Senior Dog Features | Top Senior Recipe | 💡 Feeding Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Omega-3s, digestible protein | Beef Mash | Add a splash of water for easier chewing 🦴 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | High fiber, soft texture | Turkey Recipe | Adjust portions based on activity level 🏃♂️ |
| Ollie | Cod liver oil, soft texture | Turkey Recipe with Cod Liver Oil | Warm the food slightly to enhance taste 🌡️ |
Comment 9: “Which brand is better for dogs with joint issues?”
All three brands provide options that can support joint health, but they vary in terms of ingredients and formulation:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom incorporates omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil in many of its recipes, which helps reduce inflammation and maintain joint mobility. The brand’s focus on whole ingredients like spinach and squash also ensures a good supply of vitamin C and antioxidants, which are beneficial for cartilage maintenance. The Turkey Fare recipe is particularly recommended, as turkey is a lean protein that’s easy to digest, reducing joint stress in overweight dogs.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog recipes are made with ingredients that naturally support joint health, such as broccoli, sweet potatoes, and lentils, which provide fiber and help maintain a healthy weight—an essential factor for managing joint stress. The high-protein content, particularly in the beef and pork recipes, helps maintain muscle mass, supporting joint stability.
- Ollie: Ollie goes a step further by including cod liver oil in some of its recipes, which adds both omega-3 fatty acids and vitamin D, supporting joint health and bone strength. Ingredients like chia seeds offer an additional source of omega-3s, and the brand’s lamb recipe is particularly rich in zinc, which helps reduce inflammation.
| Brand | Joint Health Features | Best Recipe for Joint Support | 💡 Feeding Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Omega-3s, vitamin C | Turkey Fare | Pair with a glucosamine supplement 🦴 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | High fiber, lean proteins | Beef Recipe | Control portions to maintain a healthy weight ⚖️ |
| Ollie | Cod liver oil, zinc | Lamb Recipe | Mix with warm water to ease digestion 💧 |
Comment 10: “Which brand is best for multi-dog households?”
When feeding multiple dogs with varying dietary needs, versatility and ease of meal management become critical factors:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom offers flexible meal plans that can be adjusted for different breeds, sizes, and ages, making it suitable for multi-dog households. The pre-portioned bags make it easy to measure and serve, ensuring that each dog receives the correct portion. Additionally, the brand’s focus on individualized meal plans allows owners to tailor ingredients based on specific needs, such as allergies or weight management.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog also works well for homes with multiple dogs, thanks to its customizable meal plans. Each plan is designed based on a dog’s unique profile, making it easy to order different recipes for each dog while managing varying caloric needs. The meals come in bulk packaging with simple storage instructions, making it convenient to portion for multiple dogs.
- Ollie: Ollie’s resealable trays make it a top choice for multi-dog households, as owners can scoop out the desired amount for each dog and keep the rest fresh. The brand offers multiple protein options, making it easier to provide variety without managing separate brands.
| Brand | Multi-Dog Features | Top Benefit | 💡 Feeding Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Pre-portioned bags | Easy portion control | Label each dog’s meal for accuracy 🏷️ |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Customizable plans | Flexible meal management | Use separate containers for different dogs 🐕 |
| Ollie | Resealable trays | Easy scooping and storage | Alternate flavors to keep dogs interested 🍗 |
Comment 11: “How do these brands compare in terms of food safety?”
Food safety is crucial, especially when dealing with fresh ingredients. Each brand maintains stringent safety protocols:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom uses a low-temperature cooking process to maintain the nutritional integrity of its ingredients while ensuring that harmful bacteria are eliminated. Meals are tested rigorously for pathogens, and the brand employs FDA-approved kitchens that meet human-grade standards. The packaging is designed to keep food fresh during transit, with insulated liners and ice packs.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog takes a minimal processing approach, cooking its ingredients gently to retain nutrients while maintaining safety. The brand operates in USDA-certified kitchens, following protocols similar to those used in human food production. The packaging uses biodegradable insulation that ensures temperature control throughout delivery.
- Ollie: Ollie emphasizes ingredient traceability, sourcing meats and vegetables from reputable suppliers and using HPP (High-Pressure Processing) for certain recipes to enhance food safety without compromising nutritional value. Meals are packed in resealable trays that are easy to store and ensure freshness.
| Brand | Safety Protocols | Best Safety Feature | 💡 Food Storage Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Low-temp cooking, FDA kitchens | Insulated delivery packaging | Keep meals in the fridge, use within 7 days ❄️ |
| The Farmer’s Dog | USDA kitchens, minimal processing | Biodegradable insulation | Freeze unused portions for extended freshness 🧊 |
| Ollie | HPP treatment, traceable sourcing | Resealable trays | Seal tightly after opening to maintain freshness 🚫 |
Comment 12: “Which brand offers the best portion flexibility?”
Adjusting portion sizes is important for dogs with changing nutritional needs, whether due to weight management, health conditions, or lifestyle changes:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom offers high flexibility with its pre-portioned pouches, which make it easy to adjust portion sizes by serving full or half portions. The brand’s meal plans can also be adjusted mid-subscription to increase or decrease portions based on a dog’s changing weight or activity levels.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog sends bulk packages that allow owners to portion meals according to daily needs. This makes it simple to increase or decrease portions as needed, though it does require measuring out the food manually. It’s especially useful for owners who like to mix fresh food with kibble to manage portions and cost.
- Ollie: Ollie’s resealable trays are designed for portion flexibility. The trays make it easy to scoop out variable amounts, whether you’re serving a full meal, a partial portion, or a topper for kibble. Adjusting portion sizes is simple, making Ollie convenient for dogs with fluctuating caloric needs.
| Brand | Portion Flexibility | Top Flexibility Feature | 💡 Portion Adjustment Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Pre-portioned pouches | Easy to serve half or full portions | Adjust weekly based on weight changes ⚖️ |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Bulk packaging | Manual portion control | Use a kitchen scale for accuracy 📏 |
| Ollie | Resealable trays | Scoopable portions | Store opened trays in the fridge, use within 5 days ❄️ |
Comment 13: “Which brand offers the best trial offer?”
If you want to test out fresh food without committing to a full subscription, here’s how the trial offers compare:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom’s trial offer is a 50% discount on your first box, allowing pet owners to try the recipes at a lower cost. The trial includes a mix of the chosen recipes, so owners can see how their dogs respond to different flavors.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog offers a 20% discount on the first box, which includes a two-week supply of food based on your dog’s customized meal plan. It’s a great way to see how well your dog adapts to the new diet over a longer period.
- Ollie: Ollie offers one of the best trial deals with a 60% discount on the first box. This initial box includes a full selection of recipes, making it easy to identify which flavors your dog prefers and how they tolerate the new diet.
| Brand | Trial Offer | Discount | 💡 Trial Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | 50% off first box | Good intro to recipe variety | Gradually introduce over 7 days to prevent GI upset 🥣 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | 20% off first box | Two-week supply for better adjustment | Monitor stool consistency during trial 🩺 |
| Ollie | 60% off first box | Best initial discount | Try different recipes during the trial to check preferences 🐾 |
Comment 14: “Which brand is best for digestive health?”
Digestive health is a top concern for many pet owners, and all three brands provide gut-friendly ingredients:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom’s recipes are packed with digestible carbohydrates like brown rice, potatoes, and squash. The brand also offers a Microbiome Testing Kit that can be used alongside the food, helping to identify gut health imbalances and adjust meal plans accordingly. Probiotics are also included to support digestive health.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog uses ingredients like lentils, carrots, and broccoli, which provide natural fiber and promote regular bowel movements. Recipes are minimally processed, making them easier on sensitive stomachs.
- Ollie: Ollie’s use of probiotic-rich ingredients like pumpkin and chia seeds helps maintain a healthy gut microbiome. The brand’s high-protein lamb recipe is also well-suited for dogs with sensitive digestion, as it uses easily digestible protein sources.
| Brand | Digestive Health Features | Best Recipe for Digestion | 💡 Feeding Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Probiotics, microbiome testing | Turkey Fare | Add warm water to meals for smoother digestion 💧 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | High fiber, minimally processed | Pork & Sweet Potato | Feed smaller, more frequent meals 🍽️ |
| Ollie | Probiotic ingredients, pumpkin | Lamb Recipe with Chia Seeds | Use as a topper to introduce gradually 🥄 |
Comment 15: “Which brand offers better support for dental health?”
While fresh dog food is naturally softer than kibble, certain ingredients can help support dental health by reducing plaque buildup and maintaining gum health:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom’s recipes include carrots and peas, which have a slightly crunchy texture when cooked lightly, providing a small amount of abrasion to help clean teeth. However, since the food is generally soft, it’s best paired with dental chews or regular brushing.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog includes fibrous vegetables like carrots and broccoli, which can provide some mechanical cleaning during chewing. The brand also promotes the inclusion of chewing supplements alongside its meals for better dental health.
- Ollie: Ollie’s recipes often contain blueberries, which are high in antioxidants and can reduce bacteria in the mouth. While the food is not designed to be abrasive, the high moisture content can help wash away food particles, reducing the risk of plaque formation.
| Brand | Dental Health Ingredients | Best Recipe for Oral Care | 💡 Dental Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | Carrots, peas | Beef Mash | Pair with dental chews for best results 🦷 |
| The Farmer’s Dog | Carrots, broccoli | Beef Recipe | Brush teeth regularly in addition to fresh food 🪥 |
| Ollie | Blueberries, high moisture | Lamb Recipe with Blueberries | Offer water after meals for oral rinsing 💦 |
Comment 16: “How do these brands compare for dogs with high energy levels?”
Active dogs require higher protein and fat to sustain their energy. Here’s how the three brands cater to these needs:
- Nom Nom: Nom Nom’s recipes are high in lean proteins and healthy fats, making them suitable for dogs with high energy needs. The Beef Mash recipe, with ingredients like beef, potatoes, and peas, provides plenty of calories for active dogs without being too rich.
- The Farmer’s Dog: The Farmer’s Dog’s recipes, especially those with beef or pork, are naturally higher in fat and protein, making them well-suited for athletic dogs. The brand’s meal plans can be adjusted to increase portion sizes based on activity levels.
- Ollie: Ollie’s recipes, particularly the lamb and beef options, are rich in protein and contain omega fatty acids to support muscle maintenance and energy production. The lamb recipe is recommended for its dense caloric content, ideal for dogs with demanding exercise routines.
| Brand | High-Energy Support | Best Recipe for Active Dogs | 💡 Feeding Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nom Nom | High protein, lean fat | Beef Mash | Increase meal portions on active days ⚡ |
| The Farmer’s Dog | High fat, adjustable portions | Pork Recipe | Feed twice daily for consistent energy 🏋️ |
| Ollie | Calorie-dense, omega-rich | Lamb Recipe | Serve immediately after exercise for recovery 🐑 |
