Freshpet vs Farmer’s Dog: What is The #1 Recommended Dog Food?

Freshpet and Farmer’s Dog are two companies you might want to consider if your dog or cat could benefit from a fresh food diet. Both companies offer deliveries of fresh, human-grade meals prepared with high-quality ingredients.

Farmer's Dog vs Freshpet dog food

Farmer’s Dog and Freshpet

Freshpet and Farmer’s Dog both offer delivery of their fresh pet food products, but their sales methods differ. Freshpet is sold in stores nationwide. You can purchase Freshpet dog food at Target, Walmart, Petco, Kroger, and other grocery and pet store chains. Farmer’s Dog offers home delivery only through their online store.

Freshpet offers food with fresh meats and veggies, which are made without preservatives or additives. Meanwhile, The Farmer’s Dog partners with local farmers to source their ingredients and provides nutritionist-formulated recipes made in a human-grade kitchen.

Both companies also offer a range of meals to choose from, but Freshpet offers more variety in dog meals than The Farmer’s Dog does.

The Farmer’s Dog is a subscription-based meal service that sends pre-portioned meals in frozen pouches. Farmer’s Dog offers personalized meal plans for dogs that take into account your pet’s age, weight, activity level, and more. Freshpet doesn’t do this, but it does offer its recipes in a variety of sizes and formulas to accommodate different sized pets and dietary needs.

Freshpet is a pet food brand that offers refrigerated meals and treats for cats and dogs. The Freshpet dog food line includes dog food rolls, dog food pouches, and dog food bites. They also sell Freshpet cat food, which comes in varieties such as cat food rolls, cat treats, and cat food pouches.

After testing both brands, I am confident that each brand has a place in the market for busy pet owners looking for convenience, quality, and affordable fresh pet food options.

Freshpet reviews

Freshpet claims to be in a class all its own. Freshpet’s foods are made with fresh ingredients, not powdered or freeze-dried, which allows them to retain the maximum amount of vitamins and minerals from the original ingredients. The company uses USDA-certified meats in their food and never adds any preservatives or fillers to the food. Freshpet guarantees that the ingredients listed on their packaging are the only ingredients used in their food.

Dog owners rave about how much their dogs love Freshpet. They say their pets can’t wait to eat their meal and they immediately gobble it down. As a result, many dogs have improved their health, with owners reporting that their dogs have gained weight, more energy, and shinier fur. Some even say the food has improved their dogs’ digestion, with less gas and softer stools.

The downside of Freshpet is that it’s pricey, roughly double the price of high-quality dry dog food, and some owners say they can go through it quickly with larger breeds. Also, some dog owners worry about spoilage if they don’t use it fast enough (though the company says its products stay good for 7 days after opening).

Freshpet meals are made with real ingredients like meat, vegetables and fruit. The brand is known for its variety of recipes, ranging from lamb to chicken to turkey.

The company offers several lines of meals:

  • Deli Fresh®
  • Fresh Treats.
  • Freshpet® Select.
  • Homestyle Creations™
  • Nature’s Fresh®
  • Spring & Sprout™
  • Vital®

Many reviewers are pleased with the results they see in their dogs.

“Freshpet is a superior product to conventional dog food; it’s much healthier and more digestible than any kibble or canned product I’ve ever tried. It seems to give my dog more energy and vitality. I would never go back to boxed dog food.”

“My dog has been on this for 2 weeks and his coat has never looked better! My dog loves this food. He goes crazy when he hears me getting it ready for him!”

“My dogs love this food. It is great for them because it has so many real ingredients. I mix it with dry food and they lick their bowls clean.”

“I bought this dog food because of the all-natural ingredients. My dogs love it, and I feel great about feeding them something that is healthy for them.”

“I like that this dog food doesn’t contain corn or soy. It’s made from quality ingredients and my dogs love it.”

“My puppy loves this dog food! He was raised on another brand but then we switched him to Freshpet and he has loved every formula. Highly recommend!”

“FreshPet is a great product for your dog or cat. My dog loves it and I can easily see the benefits from it. She used to not eat her whole food bowl and now she eats everything and comes back for more. She used to take a long time to eat her food before but now she runs over to her bowl and finishes eating in less than a minute.”

“Bought this for my 2-year-old husky, who has never had anything but kibble before. She absolutely loves it, I was in the other room and heard her chomping on something so I thought she got into something she wasn’t supposed to but when I came back into the kitchen there was no mess, just my dog enjoying the food.”

“This is hands down the best food I have ever given my dog. She loves it and she has never had any issues with digestive problems or stomach aches. I highly recommend this product to anyone who cares about their dogs.”

Farmer’s Dog reviews

The Farmer’s Dog has a similar philosophy about pet food as Freshpet. They believe that pets should eat whole foods as humans do, and they provide carefully sourced meats and vegetables in their meals.

The Farmer’s Dog doesn’t use any preservatives or additives in their food and they don’t use any by-products or fillers either. The Farmer’s Dog uses human-grade ingredients in their recipes, so you can be sure that your dog is getting a nutritious meal every time they have one of these meals.

Farmer’s Dog offers a subscription option where you prepay for a certain amount of meals upfront and they will deliver them monthly.


  • Fresh from the kitchen. Fresh, never frozen ingredients — cooked at low temps to preserve nutrients.
  • Personalized nutrition. Each meal is customized for your dog’s age, breed, size, and activity level (and any allergies).
  • Easy to digest. Cooked at low temperatures and gently dehydrated for food that’s easily digestible for dogs of all ages and sizes (and gentle on sensitive tummies).
  • No fillers or by-products. Just 100% whole ingredients like free-range chicken, sweet potatoes, and pumpkin.

Reviews for Farmer’s Dog are generally positive with some customers concerned about the price.

“Love the Farmer’s Dog! I have two dogs – one with skin allergies – and this is the only food that has cleared up her issues.”

“Love Farmer’s Dog! The food is fresh, healthy and my pups love it!”

“I cannot say enough good things about the Farmer’s Dog! My dog is a picky eater and was on a kibble diet for years. When I switched her over to The Farmer’s Dog, she absolutely loved her meals, and never turned down one of her meals. I love how I can customize her meals based on her activity levels/weight goals! This has been a game-changer for my dog (and me) because she now eats all of her meals every day instead of picking out the “good” pieces of kibble from her bowl. Highly recommend!”

“My puppy is thriving on this diet and I couldn’t be happier with the results. I’ve tried other dog food companies and wasn’t satisfied. Farmer’s Dog has the best packaging, shipping, and product of any dog food out there.”

Do vets recommend Farmer’s Dog?

Their team of veterinarians, canine nutritionists, and software engineers created the perfect personalized dog food for your dog. Just tell them your dog’s age, weight, and any allergies, and they’ll build a plan that delivers the right amount of food straight to your door.

Do vets recommend Freshpet?

Yes. Freshpet is recommended by veterinarians because it is made with high-quality, natural ingredients that help pets live happier and healthier lives. Many veterinarians believe a fresh diet helps promote a pet’s overall well-being, which can lead to healthier teeth, skin and coat, increased energy, and smaller stools.

While Freshpet foods are designed to be complete and balanced meals, if your veterinarian recommends a special diet or if you are looking to supplement your pet’s diet, always follow the advice of your veterinarian before changing any aspect of their diet.

What dog food is comparable to Freshpet?

If you’re looking for a Freshpet alternative, there are a few companies that offer similar convenience and fresh ingredients.

  • The Farmer’s Dog
  • Ollie
  • Nom Nom
  • PetPlate
  • Spot and Tango
  • We Feed Raw

Conclusion of The Farmer’s Dog vs Fresh Pet

If you’re shopping for a high-end dog food without the hassle of making it yourself, Freshpet and The Farmer’s Dog are both good options. Both companies provide their own line of freshly cooked meals, delivered right to your door.

Freshpet may be a good choice because it is an easy option for pet owners who want fresh food but don’t have time to make it themselves. They use real meat in their recipes, which can be hard to find in traditional kibble formulas. This brand also offers a wide variety of foods and treats that are made with vegetables and fruit for added nutrition.

Freshpet is a more traditional retailer with a wide range of products available in grocery stores throughout the country. Their fresh food is made with quality ingredients, but it uses refrigeration instead of freezing or vacuum sealing to prolong shelf life.

The Farmer’s Dog is another great option if you’re looking for a high quality food that’s made with real meat and vegetables. Their recipes include chicken, turkey, beef, lamb or pork as the first ingredient along with fruits like apples and berries for extra vitamins A & C.

The Farmer’s Dog offers a premium service where all meals are specially prepared for each individual dog based on their age, weight, activity level, and other factors. They use flash-freezing to lock in nutrients and deliver the food to customers’ doors frozen in vacuum-sealed bags.

If you’re looking for a premium pet food, both companies offer excellent products. But if you want truly gourmet dog food with all the perks, we recommend The Farmer’s Dog over Freshpet.

However, neither one of these companies is perfect. There are many factors that determine the best dog food for your particular pet and we encourage our readers to do their own research.

Loading RSS Feed

Hannah Elizabeth is an English animal behavior author, having written for several online publications. With a degree in Animal Behaviour and over a decade of practical animal husbandry experience, Hannah's articles cover everything from pet care to wildlife conservation. When she isn't creating content for blog posts, Hannah enjoys long walks with her Rottweiler cross Senna, reading fantasy novels and breeding aquarium shrimp.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to Top