Freshpet vs. Just Food for Dogs vs. Raw Diet: Which is Right for Your Pet?

As pet parents, choosing the right diet for our furry companions can feel overwhelming, especially when there’s a flood of options like Freshpet, Just Food for Dogs, and the ever-popular Raw Diet. But don’t worry—I’ve got the insights you need to make an informed choice for your dog’s health and happiness. 🐶

Key Takeaways (Short Answers) 🔑

• Which is most convenient? Freshpet
• Which is the most customizable? Just Food for Dogs
• Which is the most natural? Raw Diet
• Which is safest for sensitive stomachs? Just Food for Dogs
• Which is best for picky eaters? Freshpet
• Which is the most cost-effective? Raw Diet (if you prepare it yourself)

---

🥗 What Are These Diets Made Of? Freshpet vs. Just Food for Dogs vs. Raw Diet

Freshpet uses real, fresh ingredients, typically sourced from quality suppliers, including a blend of high-quality proteins (chicken, turkey, beef) and vegetables. Everything is gently steamed, helping to lock in nutrients without the need for preservatives. The food is then packaged and sold in the refrigerator section of stores. 🥩🥕

Like Freshpet, Just Food for Dogs prioritizes whole, human-grade ingredients, but the meals are designed by veterinarians and nutritionists. This brand focuses on customized formulations for different dogs’ needs, offering pre-made fresh meals and custom recipes for dogs with specific health concerns. 🧑‍⚕️🐕

A Raw Diet consists of uncooked meat, bones, organs, and sometimes veggies. The idea is to feed dogs as their ancestors ate—primarily animal-based proteins and fats. Some raw diets may include ground bones and supplements to ensure a balanced nutritional intake. It’s often homemade, which gives you full control over ingredients, but it comes with risks. 🍗🦴

---

📦 How Convenient Is Each Option for Busy Pet Parents?

Option	Convenience
Freshpet	Extremely convenient—just pick it up from the store, store in the fridge, and scoop out portions. Similar to handling human food.
Just Food for Dogs	Slightly more effort than Freshpet—offers both pre-made meals and DIY kits for pet parents who want to cook for their dog.
Raw Diet	Least convenient—requires time and effort to source fresh, quality ingredients and prepare balanced meals. May need freezing and daily prep work.

If you’re a pet parent constantly on the go, Freshpet shines for its grab-and-serve style. Just Food for Dogs gives flexibility if you prefer a more hands-on approach. But if you’re up for a kitchen challenge, the Raw Diet can be rewarding yet time-consuming.

---

🐕 Which Option Is Healthiest for Your Dog?

Freshpet is a great option for overall health, especially for picky eaters or dogs with average energy levels. Its fresh ingredients provide balanced nutrition, and the gentle cooking process retains many natural nutrients. However, it may not offer the level of customization some pets need.

For dogs with health conditions or dietary restrictions, Just Food for Dogs is a standout choice. Their meals can be tailored for dogs with allergies, digestive issues, or specific health concerns like kidney or liver disease. They work closely with veterinarians, making it a trusted option for pets with medical needs.

Proponents of the raw diet often believe it’s the most natural and biologically appropriate option. Raw food is packed with proteins and fats that can benefit skin, coat, and energy levels. However, balancing nutrients in a raw diet is crucial, and there’s a higher risk of bacterial contamination (salmonella, E. coli). It’s best to consult with a vet or canine nutritionist to ensure your dog is getting everything they need.

---

💲 Which Diet Is Most Budget-Friendly?

Option	Cost
Freshpet	Moderate—cheaper than Just Food for Dogs, but more expensive than traditional kibble. Prices vary based on size and feeding amounts, but expect higher grocery bills.
Just Food for Dogs	More expensive—pre-made meals and custom formulations come at a premium, but you get what you pay for in terms of tailored nutrition.
Raw Diet	Can be affordable if done DIY—sourcing your own ingredients can save money, but commercial raw diets can get pricey. Costs vary significantly depending on sourcing.

If you’re on a strict budget, making a Raw Diet at home could save you money, but the costs can escalate with commercial options. Freshpet sits comfortably in the middle, while Just Food for Dogs offers premium pricing for premium health benefits.

---

🤢 Which Is Safest for Sensitive Stomachs?

Freshpet’s ingredients are fresh and free from fillers or artificial preservatives, which can benefit dogs with sensitive tummies. However, the consistency of pre-packaged meals may not work for every dog.

Just Food for Dogs takes the crown here. Their ability to customize meals to your dog’s specific needs—whether they have food allergies or sensitivities—makes it a top-tier choice for digestive issues. Vet-backed formulations add peace of mind.

While a Raw Diet can work wonders for some dogs, it’s a bit riskier for others, especially those prone to gastrointestinal issues. The variability in preparation, along with potential bacteria, could exacerbate sensitive stomachs if not handled with care.

---

🐾 Final Verdict: Which Should You Choose?

The right choice depends on your dog’s unique needs and your lifestyle. Freshpet is excellent for convenience and overall health, Just Food for Dogs is the best for those with specific dietary needs or health conditions, and a Raw Diet offers the most natural option but requires careful planning and vet oversight.

---

Key Takeaways

1. Which is most convenient? Freshpet is the easiest to use—just grab and serve! 🏆
2. Which is the most customizable? Just Food for Dogs allows for tailor-made meals based on health needs. 👩‍⚕️
3. Which is the most natural? A Raw Diet mimics a dog’s ancestral eating habits, though it requires more work. 🌿
4. Which is safest for sensitive stomachs? Just Food for Dogs, thanks to vet-designed, custom formulations. 🐾
5. Which is best for picky eaters? Freshpet’s fresh, high-quality ingredients win over even the fussiest eaters. 😋
6. Which is the most cost-effective? A DIY Raw Diet can save you money, but it’s not as convenient. 💰

---

Comment 1: “Isn’t raw food dangerous because of bacteria?”

Answer: Yes, that’s a valid concern! The Raw Diet does carry a higher risk of bacterial contamination compared to cooked food. Pathogens like salmonella or E. coli can be present in raw meats, and while dogs’ stomachs are generally more acidic than humans, they’re not immune to these dangers. The key to minimizing risk lies in handling practices. Always source meat from reliable suppliers, store it at the correct temperature, and follow strict hygiene protocols during preparation. Many owners freeze raw meals to kill certain bacteria, but it’s important to note that freezing doesn’t eliminate all risks. Using a balanced recipe (with appropriate supplements) and regular vet checks is essential when feeding raw to ensure your dog is getting everything they need while minimizing health risks.

Comment 2: “Which diet is best for dogs with allergies?”

Answer: When it comes to allergies, Just Food for Dogs is typically the best option. They offer custom recipes tailored to address food sensitivities, working with veterinarians and nutritionists to create meals free from common allergens like grains, chicken, or dairy. Their formulas are designed to help pinpoint exactly which ingredient might be causing your dog’s reaction. While Freshpet is also made from natural ingredients and could work for some dogs, it doesn’t provide the same level of customization. A Raw Diet can also be suitable for dogs with allergies if carefully planned, but it’s trickier to ensure the diet is nutritionally complete and allergen-free without professional guidance. Consult your vet before switching to a raw diet to rule out potential allergens.

Comment 3: “Is Freshpet better for picky eaters than the other diets?”

Answer: Freshpet’s success with picky eaters is well-known, and for good reason. The fresh, lightly cooked ingredients make the food more palatable, as it closely resembles human food in both texture and aroma. Dogs are naturally drawn to the fresh meats and vegetables used in these formulations. The gentle cooking process helps retain more of the natural flavors, making it an attractive option for dogs who may turn their noses up at kibble or other commercial diets. Compared to Just Food for Dogs, which also uses fresh ingredients, Freshpet tends to be more widely accepted by picky eaters because of its easy-to-digest texture and consistent flavor profile. A Raw Diet, while often appealing to some dogs, can be hit or miss—some picky eaters are put off by the raw texture or specific smells, especially if they’re accustomed to cooked food.

Comment 4: “How do I transition my dog from kibble to Freshpet or Just Food for Dogs?”

Answer: Transitioning from kibble to fresh food like Freshpet or Just Food for Dogs should be done gradually to avoid upsetting your dog’s stomach. Start by mixing a small amount (about 25%) of the new food with 75% of their current kibble. Over the next 7-10 days, gradually increase the proportion of fresh food while decreasing the kibble. This slow transition helps your dog’s digestive system adjust to the new ingredients and higher moisture content of fresh food, preventing diarrhea or upset stomachs. It’s also a good way to spot any potential sensitivities to ingredients in the new food. With Just Food for Dogs, the transition period can be particularly helpful if you’re switching to a customized formula that addresses specific health concerns. Make sure you monitor your dog’s stool consistency and energy levels throughout the process to ensure they’re adjusting well.

Comment 5: “Is a raw diet more natural for dogs?”

Answer: In terms of what’s biologically appropriate, yes, a Raw Diet is often considered more natural because it mimics what dogs’ ancestors would have eaten in the wild. It’s based on the principle that dogs thrive on animal-based proteins and raw meaty bones, which provide essential nutrients like calcium and phosphorus. Advocates of raw feeding argue that this diet supports better skin health, shinier coats, and improved energy levels due to the lack of processed ingredients and fillers found in many commercial pet foods. However, while it is more natural in theory, a raw diet requires careful planning to ensure your dog gets a balanced intake of vitamins and minerals. Without this balance, a dog can suffer from nutrient deficiencies. So, while it may be natural, it’s not always easy, and it’s crucial to consult a vet or canine nutritionist to create a safe, balanced raw meal plan.

Comment 6: “Does Just Food for Dogs really work for dogs with specific health issues?”

Answer: Absolutely! Just Food for Dogs is one of the few pet food companies that specializes in creating custom meals for dogs with specific health issues, ranging from kidney disease and liver problems to food allergies and weight management. Their vet-formulated diets are scientifically crafted to support a dog’s particular medical condition, making them an excellent choice for pets that need more than just a standard balanced meal. They even offer a DIY kit, where you can make these meals at home using a recipe provided by their team of nutritionists. This level of customization ensures your dog is getting exactly the right nutrients for their health needs, something you won’t find with most commercial brands or even raw diets. It’s essentially like having a prescription diet, but made from fresh, whole foods.

Comment 7: “Can I mix Freshpet or Just Food for Dogs with kibble?”

Answer: Yes, you can mix Freshpet or Just Food for Dogs with kibble, and it’s a common approach for dog owners looking to improve their dog’s diet without completely switching from dry food. Mixing fresh food with kibble allows you to add the nutritional benefits of fresh ingredients while still maintaining some of the convenience and affordability of kibble. If you go this route, make sure to balance the portions carefully to avoid overfeeding. Freshpet’s meals are designed to be complete, meaning they can be fed as a sole diet, so when mixed with kibble, be mindful not to overdo it. It’s also important to monitor how your dog adjusts to the new mix—sometimes the change in texture and ingredients can cause minor digestive changes, but as long as you transition slowly, most dogs adapt well.

Comment 8: “How do I ensure a Raw Diet is nutritionally balanced?”

Answer: Ensuring a Raw Diet is nutritionally balanced can be challenging because it’s more than just offering your dog raw meat. To achieve a balanced diet, you must provide a variety of animal-based proteins (such as chicken, beef, or lamb), organ meats (like liver and kidney), and edible bones for essential minerals like calcium. But that’s not all—dogs also need omega fatty acids from sources like fish or fish oil, and a certain percentage of vegetables (if included in your raw philosophy) for vitamins and fiber. A common mistake is neglecting supplements; many homemade raw diets require additional nutrients like vitamin D, zinc, and iodine, which aren’t always present in the meats you buy. It’s crucial to follow a vet-approved recipe or work with a canine nutritionist to ensure that your dog’s meals are balanced and safe for long-term feeding. Regular bloodwork and vet visits are key to ensuring your dog remains healthy on this diet.

Comment 9: “Does Freshpet require any special storage or handling?”

Answer: Yes, Freshpet does require specific storage conditions since it’s made with fresh ingredients and lacks preservatives that many commercial dog foods contain. It needs to be kept refrigerated at all times, much like human food, and should be served within 7 days of opening the package to ensure it remains fresh and safe for your dog. When serving, you can scoop out your dog’s portion directly from the fridge. It’s also important to use clean utensils and wash your hands after handling it, especially since you’re dealing with fresh meat. Freshpet packages come with clear storage instructions, and it’s essential to follow them to prevent spoilage or contamination. If your dog doesn’t finish a serving, you can store the remainder back in the fridge, but avoid leaving it out for too long. Unlike dry kibble, this food is perishable, so maintaining its freshness is key to your dog’s safety and enjoyment. 🧊

Comment 10: “Can a dog on a raw diet get all the vitamins and minerals it needs without supplements?”

Answer: It’s technically possible, but extremely difficult to ensure a dog on a Raw Diet gets all the necessary vitamins and minerals without supplements. A well-balanced raw diet requires a precise ratio of meat, organ meats, and bones, each offering a unique nutrient profile. For instance, organ meats like liver are a rich source of vitamin A, while bones supply calcium and phosphorus. However, certain vitamins, such as vitamin E and D, are often lacking in raw diets and can lead to deficiencies over time. Omega-3 fatty acids, crucial for a dog’s skin and coat health, are commonly added through fish oil or feeding oily fish like sardines. While a dog may get many nutrients from raw food alone, most raw feeders still add supplements like zinc, iodine, and manganese to ensure a completely balanced diet. To avoid potential health issues, it’s highly recommended to work with a veterinarian or a pet nutritionist who can guide you on the right proportions and whether supplements are necessary based on your dog’s specific needs.

Comment 11: “What are the long-term benefits of switching to Freshpet from kibble?”

Answer: Switching from kibble to Freshpet can yield several long-term benefits for your dog’s health, largely due to the higher-quality, fresh ingredients. One of the most noticeable improvements tends to be in the digestive health of the dog. Freshpet contains fewer fillers and artificial ingredients, which can help improve your dog’s digestion and lead to firmer, healthier stools. Another major benefit is the impact on skin and coat health; dogs often develop shinier, softer coats due to the inclusion of fresh proteins and essential fats in Freshpet. You might also see a boost in energy levels since fresh food provides more bioavailable nutrients, meaning the body can more easily absorb and utilize them compared to kibble. Additionally, Freshpet has a higher moisture content, which can support better hydration and kidney function over time. For dogs prone to allergies or food sensitivities, the simpler, more natural ingredient list of Freshpet can help reduce symptoms like itchiness, inflammation, or ear infections, which are sometimes exacerbated by the preservatives and fillers in kibble.

Comment 12: “Can Just Food for Dogs really be customized for every dog’s specific health needs?”

Answer: Yes, Just Food for Dogs can be tailored to suit a wide range of specific health needs thanks to their customized formulations and vet-designed recipes. This level of customization is particularly beneficial for dogs with chronic health conditions like kidney disease, diabetes, or pancreatitis, as the ingredients and nutritional composition can be adjusted to meet their exact requirements. For instance, a dog with kidney disease might need a lower-protein, lower-phosphorus diet, and Just Food for Dogs can create a custom recipe that aligns with these needs while still providing a balanced and nutritious meal. They also offer DIY kits with precise instructions, allowing you to prepare meals at home using their recipes, which can be specifically modified based on your vet’s recommendations. This approach gives pet owners a level of confidence that’s hard to match with other commercial diets, as every ingredient is carefully measured and formulated to address your dog’s individual health concerns. Whether it’s weight management, food sensitivities, or even post-surgery recovery, Just Food for Dogs has options that ensure your pet is receiving the appropriate nutrition. 🧑‍⚕️🍲

Comment 13: “What should I consider before starting my dog on a Raw Diet?”

Answer: Before starting your dog on a Raw Diet, there are several critical factors to consider. First and foremost, you’ll need to ensure you have the time and resources to properly source, handle, and prepare the raw ingredients. This isn’t as simple as buying kibble; you’ll need to ensure you’re using high-quality, fresh meats, organ meats, and bones that are safe for consumption. Additionally, there’s a risk of bacterial contamination (like salmonella or E. coli), so you must follow stringent food safety protocols, such as cleaning surfaces and utensils after every meal prep. It’s also essential to recognize that a raw diet isn’t just throwing meat in a bowl; it requires a balanced mix of proteins, fats, vitamins, and minerals to meet your dog’s nutritional needs. You may need to invest in supplements to ensure your dog gets everything they need, such as calcium or essential fatty acids. Consulting with a veterinarian or canine nutritionist before starting a raw diet is critical, as they can help you create a plan that ensures your dog receives a complete and balanced diet. And lastly, consider your dog’s current health status; raw diets aren’t always the best option for dogs with weakened immune systems or certain chronic conditions.