Just Food For Dogs vs. Freshpet vs. Ollie: Expert Insights to Help You Choose the Best Fresh Food for Your Dog 🍖🍽️🐕
The shift towards fresh, whole-food diets for dogs is gaining popularity, but with so many options available, it can be difficult to decide which is the best fit for your furry friend. Three top contenders in the market—Just Food For Dogs, Freshpet, and Ollie—each offer unique benefits.
Key Takeaways: Quick Answers to Your Questions
- Which brand offers the most customizable meal plans? Ollie, with tailored plans based on your dog’s needs.
- Which has the widest variety of ingredients? Just Food For Dogs, with multiple recipes and ingredients for specific health needs.
- Which is easiest to find in stores? Freshpet is available at most major retailers.
- Which offers the most human-grade ingredients? All three, but Just Food For Dogs emphasizes USDA-certified ingredients.
- Which is the best for dogs with allergies? Ollie offers grain-free options tailored for sensitivities.
- Which is the most convenient? Freshpet, as it’s available in refrigerated sections of many stores.
- Which offers fresh meals delivered to your door? Both Ollie and Just Food For Dogs offer subscription delivery services.
- Which is the most cost-effective? Freshpet tends to be more budget-friendly for larger dogs.
- Which is the best for senior dogs or dogs with special dietary needs? Just Food For Dogs, thanks to its veterinary-formulated recipes.
- Which provides the best nutritional transparency? Just Food For Dogs, with full transparency on ingredients and nutrition.
1. Which Brand Offers the Most Customizable Meal Plans? 🥩🍗
When it comes to personalization, Ollie stands out. This brand uses an in-depth questionnaire about your dog’s age, breed, activity level, weight, and health issues to create a tailored meal plan. Every aspect, from portion sizes to the nutrient profile, is based on your dog’s unique needs. Just Food For Dogs also offers customization, especially with their DIY meal kits and prescription diet plans for specific health concerns, but it’s not as detailed as Ollie’s personalized approach. Freshpet, on the other hand, offers pre-packaged options with less flexibility.
| Brand | Customization Level | Ideal For | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | Very High | Dogs with unique needs | Tailor meals based on health and weight goals |
| Just Food For Dogs | High | Dogs with specific health issues | Opt for DIY kits for full control |
| Freshpet | Low | Dogs needing convenience | Pre-packaged, less customizable |
💡 Pro Tip: For dogs with complex health needs, Ollie’s deep customization ensures you’re getting a meal plan specifically designed for your dog.
2. Which Has the Widest Variety of Ingredients? 🥦🥕
Just Food For Dogs takes the lead in ingredient variety, offering an impressive selection of recipes, from turkey and macaroni to fish and sweet potatoes. They focus heavily on USDA-certified, human-grade ingredients and often use whole foods like spinach, carrots, and quinoa. Their menu is designed with input from veterinary nutritionists, catering to dogs with unique dietary needs.
Ollie offers four main protein choices—beef, turkey, lamb, and chicken—with the option to choose grain-free or include grains. They also emphasize whole-food ingredients and avoid artificial preservatives. Freshpet, while still using real meats and vegetables, tends to offer fewer options and focuses more on pre-cooked, refrigerated meals available in grocery stores.
| Brand | Variety of Ingredients | Special Features | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Just Food For Dogs | Very High | Prescription diets, USDA ingredients | Choose specific recipes for dogs with medical needs |
| Ollie | High | Grain-free and grain-inclusive options | Rotate proteins to avoid allergies |
| Freshpet | Moderate | Pre-cooked, refrigerated meals | Easily found at grocery stores |
💡 Pro Tip: For dogs with allergies or sensitivities, Just Food For Dogs offers prescription recipes, while Ollie allows you to select grain-free options.
3. Which Is Easiest to Find in Stores? 🛒🧊
If convenience is key, Freshpet is your go-to option. Unlike Just Food For Dogs and Ollie, which focus on direct-to-consumer subscription models, Freshpet products are available at most major grocery stores, pet stores, and even big-box retailers. Their meals are stored in the refrigerated section, making them easy to grab during your regular shopping trip.
Both Ollie and Just Food For Dogs primarily operate on a subscription model, delivering fresh meals directly to your door. However, Just Food For Dogs also has kitchens and pantries in select retail locations where you can pick up food in person.
| Brand | Availability | Purchase Method | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freshpet | Widely available | In-store (grocery & pet stores) | Convenient for weekly grocery runs |
| Just Food For Dogs | Moderate | Subscription, retail kitchens | Pick up or have meals delivered |
| Ollie | Limited | Subscription only | Delivered fresh to your door |
💡 Pro Tip: For busy pet parents who want instant access, Freshpet’s wide availability makes it the easiest to find while running errands.
4. Which Offers Fresh Meals Delivered to Your Door? 🚚📦
Both Ollie and Just Food For Dogs offer fresh, human-grade meals delivered right to your door. This makes it incredibly convenient for pet parents who prefer not to shop in-store or who want a regular supply of fresh food without having to think about it.
Ollie delivers fresh, pre-portioned meals based on your dog’s individual needs, with clear storage and feeding instructions. Similarly, Just Food For Dogs provides custom meal plans or DIY kits for those who want to prepare meals themselves at home. Freshpet, while not a subscription service, focuses on providing meals at retail stores rather than delivery.
| Brand | Delivery Service | Subscription Option | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | Yes | Subscription | Set your delivery frequency to suit your dog’s needs |
| Just Food For Dogs | Yes | Subscription | Great for dogs with specific dietary requirements |
| Freshpet | No | No | Purchase in-store |
💡 Pro Tip: If you want a steady supply of fresh meals without the hassle of shopping, Ollie’s subscription service ensures that you never run out of nutritious food for your dog.
5. Which Is Best for Dogs with Allergies? 🐾🌾
When it comes to dogs with allergies, Ollie and Just Food For Dogs both offer excellent options. Ollie allows for grain-free choices, which is particularly beneficial for dogs with grain sensitivities. Their limited-ingredient meals reduce the risk of triggering food allergies and are formulated to support a sensitive digestive system.
Just Food For Dogs offers even more targeted solutions with prescription diet options crafted by veterinary nutritionists. They provide recipes designed to manage specific health issues, including food allergies and intolerances, making them a top choice for dogs with complex dietary needs. Freshpet does offer high-quality fresh food, but it has fewer options when it comes to addressing severe allergies.
| Brand | Allergy-Friendliness | Special Features | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | High | Grain-free options | Tailor meals to avoid allergens like grains or poultry |
| Just Food For Dogs | Very High | Prescription allergy diets | Consult their vet team for personalized allergy solutions |
| Freshpet | Moderate | Limited options for allergies | Use their ingredient list to choose recipes carefully |
💡 Pro Tip: If your dog suffers from severe allergies, Just Food For Dogs offers prescription recipes specifically designed to eliminate common allergens.
6. Which Is the Most Cost-Effective? 💰📊
Freshpet tends to be the most budget-friendly option, especially for larger dogs or multi-pet households. Since their products are available in larger quantities at grocery stores, they are more accessible and can be more cost-effective than subscription services.
However, both Ollie and Just Food For Dogs provide higher levels of customization, which may justify their higher prices, especially if your dog has specific dietary needs. Ollie offers slightly more flexibility with portion sizes, which can help manage costs, while Just Food For Dogs offers DIY meal kits that may save money if you’re willing to prepare meals at home.
| Brand | Price Range | Cost-Effectiveness | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freshpet | $ | Best for budget-conscious pet parents | Buy larger packs to save more |
| Ollie | $$ | Personalized but pricier | Adjust delivery frequency to manage costs |
| Just Food For Dogs | $$$ | Worth it for health-specific needs | DIY kits can reduce overall cost |
💡 Pro Tip: If cost is a concern, Freshpet provides quality fresh food at a more affordable price, while Ollie allows you to adjust portion sizes to save on costs.
7. Which Brand Is Best for Senior Dogs or Dogs with Special Dietary Needs? 🦴👴
Just Food For Dogs is the top choice for senior dogs or those with specific health concerns. Their range of prescription diets, which include options for liver disease, kidney support, and weight management, are all formulated by veterinarians to meet the unique nutritional needs of older or health-challenged dogs. They also offer a senior-specific recipe designed to address the reduced metabolism and joint health issues common in aging dogs.
Ollie provides well-balanced meals for dogs of all ages, with the ability to customize portions and ingredients based on your senior dog’s specific needs. Freshpet offers nutritious, fresh food but lacks the veterinary-formulated options that Just Food For Dogs offers.
| Brand | Best for Senior Dogs | Special Features | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Just Food For Dogs | Very High | Senior-specific and prescription diets | Consult their vet team for senior-specific recommendations |
| Ollie | High | Tailored meal plans for older dogs | Customize to reduce calories or support joint health |
| Freshpet | Moderate | General fresh recipes | Look for high-protein, low-calorie options for senior dogs |
💡 Pro Tip: For dogs with chronic conditions or aging concerns, Just Food For Dogs’ prescription diets provide the most targeted support.
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Best Fresh Food for Your Dog 🐶❤️
When deciding between Just Food For Dogs, Freshpet, and Ollie, it’s essential to consider your dog’s specific needs. Ollie offers unmatched customization, Just Food For Dogs excels in nutritional variety and veterinary-backed recipes, while Freshpet stands out for its convenience and affordability. Whichever brand you choose, each provides high-quality, fresh meals that support your dog’s health and happiness!
Comment 1: My dog has food allergies. Which brand is the best for avoiding allergens like grains or poultry?
For dogs with food allergies, Ollie and Just Food For Dogs both offer excellent options tailored to dogs with sensitivities. Ollie provides a highly customizable meal plan, including grain-free recipes and alternative protein sources such as lamb or turkey, which can help avoid common allergens like grains or poultry. Their meals are formulated with limited ingredients, which reduces the risk of triggering an allergic reaction.
Just Food For Dogs goes a step further by offering prescription diets specifically designed for dogs with allergies. These diets are developed by veterinary nutritionists and can be customized based on your dog’s individual allergies, ensuring that you eliminate specific triggers from their meals. With options that include novel proteins and carefully selected whole-food ingredients, Just Food For Dogs is an ideal choice if your dog has complex dietary needs.
Freshpet, while using high-quality ingredients, offers fewer specialized options for dogs with severe allergies. Although they do have some grain-free products, they don’t have the same level of personalization or vet-designed plans as the other two brands.
💡 Pro Tip: For dogs with multiple or severe allergies, consider Just Food For Dogs’ prescription recipes, which can be tailored with specific allergens in mind.
Comment 2: I travel a lot with my dog. Which brand offers the most travel-friendly meals?
For dog owners who travel frequently, Freshpet offers a convenient solution, especially since their products are available in refrigerated sections of grocery stores across the country. This makes it easy to find Freshpet meals wherever you go, eliminating the need to rely solely on subscription services. The pre-cooked meals are simple to pack and refrigerate, so you don’t have to worry about complex storage or preparation while on the road.
While Ollie and Just Food For Dogs both offer fresh meal delivery services, which are great for home use, they may be less travel-friendly due to the need for consistent refrigeration and freezing. However, Just Food For Dogs does offer pantry fresh options, which are shelf-stable and don’t require refrigeration until opened, making them a good option for longer trips where you may not have access to a refrigerator.
Ollie’s subscription model is designed for home delivery, but if you’re a frequent traveler, you might need to plan ahead by freezing meals and packing them in a cooler, which can be a bit more cumbersome.
💡 Pro Tip: If you’re traveling and want easy access to fresh meals, Freshpet is the most convenient option thanks to its wide availability in stores.
Comment 3: How does the quality of the meat compare between these brands?
All three brands—Ollie, Just Food For Dogs, and Freshpet—use high-quality, human-grade meats, but there are some differences in how they source and prepare the proteins.
Ollie emphasizes using high-quality meats that are sourced responsibly and are free from hormones, fillers, and artificial preservatives. Their protein options include grass-fed beef, cage-free chicken, and free-range lamb, ensuring your dog gets nutrient-dense meals. Each meal is cooked at low temperatures to preserve the integrity of the ingredients while killing off harmful bacteria.
Just Food For Dogs also stands out by using USDA-certified meats, meaning the proteins meet the same standards as those sold for human consumption. Their meals are often designed by veterinarians, ensuring the right balance of nutrients while using whole-food, high-quality meats like wild-caught cod, free-range turkey, and venison. They also prioritize sourcing locally where possible, ensuring freshness and sustainability.
Freshpet, while still using real, fresh meats, tends to focus more on convenience, offering pre-cooked proteins like chicken, beef, and turkey. Their meats are fresh and free of by-products, but the selection is more limited compared to the other two brands, and it may not be as specifically tailored toward premium protein sourcing.
💡 Pro Tip: For the highest quality of meat and variety in protein sources, Just Food For Dogs offers more diverse and premium options, particularly with their prescription and whole-food recipes.
Comment 4: How do I store the food for each brand? Do they require special storage?
The storage requirements differ slightly between these three brands, but all offer straightforward instructions to ensure the food stays fresh and safe for your dog.
Ollie meals are shipped fresh and should be stored in the refrigerator upon arrival. Meals typically come in individual, pre-portioned containers, which makes it easy to serve. If you can’t use them right away, Ollie meals can be stored in the freezer for up to six months, and they include detailed thawing instructions for optimal freshness.
Just Food For Dogs also recommends refrigerating or freezing their fresh meals upon arrival. Their meals can be stored in the freezer for extended periods and are easy to defrost as needed. They also offer pantry-fresh options, which are shelf-stable until opened, making them more convenient for short trips or backup meals. These can be stored at room temperature and are ideal for travel or for those who want a non-refrigerated option.
Freshpet, since it’s sold in refrigerated sections of stores, requires refrigeration at all times. Their meals should be consumed within 7 days of opening, and unlike the other brands, Freshpet does not offer freezer-friendly meals, which may be a downside if you want to buy in bulk.
| Brand | Storage Method | Shelf Life | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | Refrigerate or freeze | Up to 6 months (frozen) | Freeze extra meals and thaw as needed |
| Just Food For Dogs | Refrigerate or pantry (shelf-stable) | 6 months (frozen) | Opt for pantry-fresh for travel or emergency meals |
| Freshpet | Refrigerate only | 7 days after opening | Store in the fridge and serve within a week |
💡 Pro Tip: For long-term storage and easy meal prep, Ollie’s frozen meals are the most convenient, while Just Food For Dogs’ pantry-fresh meals offer flexibility for on-the-go use.
Comment 5: Which brand offers the best value for money for large dog breeds?
For large dog breeds, where the cost per serving can add up quickly, Freshpet typically offers the most cost-effective solution. Since Freshpet is available in larger quantities and can be purchased at local grocery or pet stores, it tends to be a more affordable option per pound compared to subscription-based services. This makes it ideal for owners of larger breeds who need to feed their dogs substantial portions without breaking the bank.
Ollie provides high-quality, customizable meals, but the cost can be higher, especially for large dogs who require bigger portions. The benefit, however, is that each meal is tailored to your dog’s specific needs, ensuring you’re not overfeeding or underfeeding, which could ultimately save on long-term health costs.
Just Food For Dogs, while premium, is on the pricier side due to its veterinary-formulated meals and use of USDA-certified ingredients. For large dogs, the cost per serving can be significant, but if your dog has specific health conditions, this investment could be worthwhile for long-term well-being.
| Brand | Cost per Serving | Best for Large Dogs | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freshpet | Low | Budget-conscious owners | Buy in bulk to reduce costs |
| Ollie | Medium | Customizable but pricier | Adjust meal plans to suit portion needs |
| Just Food For Dogs | High | Special dietary needs | DIY kits can reduce costs for larger portions |
💡 Pro Tip: For large breeds on a budget, Freshpet provides the most cost-effective solution, while Ollie allows you to fine-tune portion sizes to avoid overfeeding.
Comment 6: Which brand is the most sustainable or environmentally friendly?
When considering sustainability, both Ollie and Just Food For Dogs have taken steps to reduce their environmental impact, though in different ways.
Ollie emphasizes responsible sourcing, using ethically raised meats like grass-fed beef and free-range chicken. Their packaging is also designed with sustainability in mind, using recyclable materials and working to minimize waste. Additionally, they focus on reducing food waste by pre-portioning meals according to your dog’s needs, ensuring nothing is wasted.
Just Food For Dogs is known for using locally sourced, USDA-certified ingredients, which reduces the carbon footprint associated with transportation. They also focus on whole-food recipes that are minimally processed, which aligns with sustainability goals. Their DIY kits further reduce packaging waste, as they allow you to prepare large quantities of food at home with minimal materials.
Freshpet focuses primarily on fresh ingredients, but their wide distribution model and reliance on refrigerated storage in retail stores means a larger carbon footprint compared to subscription-based services that ship directly to consumers.
| Brand | Sustainability Focus | Special Features | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | Ethically sourced, recyclable packaging | Reduces food waste with pre-portioned meals | Recycle packaging materials after use |
| Just Food For Dogs | Locally sourced, USDA ingredients | DIY kits reduce packaging waste | Opt for DIY kits to minimize environmental impact |
| Freshpet | Fresh ingredients but larger footprint | Refrigerated products in stores | Choose Freshpet for convenience, but recycle packaging |
💡 Pro Tip: For the most sustainable option, Ollie and Just Food For Dogs focus on ethical sourcing and reducing food waste, with recyclable packaging and minimal processing.
Comment 7: How does the taste and texture of the food compare between brands? Does one stand out in terms of palatability for picky eaters?
When it comes to taste and texture, all three brands—Ollie, Just Food For Dogs, and Freshpet—use fresh, whole ingredients, making their meals highly palatable for most dogs. However, for picky eaters, Ollie and Just Food For Dogs seem to have an edge due to their customization options and emphasis on high-quality meats and vegetables.
Ollie’s fresh meals are made with gently cooked proteins, providing a soft, appealing texture that many dogs find irresistible. The variety of proteins (like lamb, beef, and turkey) and customizable options make it a great choice for picky eaters who may prefer one flavor over another. The soft, moist texture and the inclusion of flavorful ingredients like pumpkin or spinach enhance the palatability.
Just Food For Dogs also offers highly palatable meals with their wide selection of recipes, including unique flavors like venison and squash. The whole-food texture—with visible chunks of meat, vegetables, and grains—appeals to dogs who enjoy a more natural, less processed food experience.
Freshpet, while fresh, uses pre-cooked, refrigerated meals that tend to have a more uniform texture, similar to traditional dog food rolls or patties. While many dogs enjoy the taste, particularly of their beef or chicken recipes, it may not be as exciting for the pickiest eaters compared to the variety and texture of the other brands.
| Brand | Taste and Texture | Best for Picky Eaters | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | Soft, moist, flavorful | High variety for picky eaters | Rotate proteins to keep meals interesting |
| Just Food For Dogs | Whole-food texture, visible ingredients | Ideal for dogs who like variety | Opt for unique proteins like venison or cod |
| Freshpet | Uniform texture, pre-cooked | Moderate appeal | Great for dogs who like traditional dog food texture |
💡 Pro Tip: For picky eaters, Ollie’s customizable meals offer the most variety in both flavor and texture, making it the best option for keeping your dog interested in their food.
Comment 8: My dog has a sensitive stomach. Which brand offers the best options for dogs prone to digestive issues?
For dogs with sensitive stomachs, both Ollie and Just Food For Dogs provide top-tier options that prioritize gentle, whole-food ingredients to minimize digestive discomfort.
Ollie is a standout for its customizable meal plans, allowing you to tailor meals based on your dog’s specific digestive sensitivities. They offer recipes with limited ingredients and avoid common irritants like grains or fillers. Their gentle cooking process retains nutrient density while ensuring the meals are easy to digest. The grain-free options, particularly their turkey and pumpkin recipe, can be especially beneficial for dogs who struggle with grains or heavy proteins.
Just Food For Dogs, on the other hand, goes further by offering prescription diets that are designed specifically for dogs with gastrointestinal issues. These meals are formulated by veterinarians and use highly digestible proteins like cod and lamb, paired with bland ingredients such as sweet potatoes or rice. They even offer options like Gastrointestinal Support Low Fat, which is tailored for dogs prone to pancreatitis or severe digestive problems. The transparency of ingredients and focus on digestive health make this a top choice for dogs with chronic GI concerns.
Freshpet, while using whole ingredients, doesn’t have as many specialized options for digestive issues. Their meals are fresh and can be easier on the stomach compared to traditional kibble, but they may not offer the same level of personalization or veterinary formulation for dogs with serious sensitivities.
| Brand | Digestive Support | Special Features | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | High | Customizable, limited ingredients | Opt for grain-free recipes if grains upset your dog’s stomach |
| Just Food For Dogs | Very High | Prescription diets for GI support | Choose their Gastrointestinal Support formula for chronic issues |
| Freshpet | Moderate | Fresh, whole foods, but limited GI options | Look for their simpler recipes with fewer ingredients |
💡 Pro Tip: For dogs with ongoing digestive problems, Just Food For Dogs’ veterinary-prescribed diets offer tailored solutions, while Ollie provides flexibility with grain-free and gentle protein options.
Comment 9: Is there a significant difference in nutritional content between these brands?
The nutritional content of each brand is top-notch, but there are some differences in formulation and focus that may make one a better choice for your dog, depending on their unique needs.
Ollie prioritizes balanced, nutrient-dense meals designed specifically for your dog’s weight, activity level, and health. Their meals are carefully formulated to meet AAFCO standards (Association of American Feed Control Officials), ensuring they provide complete and balanced nutrition. The emphasis on whole proteins like beef, turkey, or lamb, combined with nutrient-rich vegetables like carrots and spinach, means that your dog is receiving a diet that supports long-term health. They also avoid unnecessary fillers, preservatives, and artificial ingredients, ensuring the highest-quality nutrition.
Just Food For Dogs is renowned for its veterinary-designed meals, especially for dogs with health conditions requiring specific nutritional support. Their formulations not only meet but often exceed AAFCO standards, particularly with their prescription diets that focus on things like weight management, kidney care, and digestive health. The use of USDA-certified ingredients means your dog gets a high-quality, fresh food experience without any synthetic additives. Additionally, Just Food For Dogs includes supplements like fish oil and antioxidants to boost overall health, particularly for senior dogs or those with special needs.
Freshpet, while using fresh ingredients, is more of a convenience-focused brand. Their nutritional content is solid, meeting basic standards, but may not offer the same level of customization or health-specific focus. While their meals provide whole proteins and vegetables, they tend to have a more standardized formulation that’s not tailored to specific health conditions or individual needs like Ollie or Just Food For Dogs.
| Brand | Nutritional Focus | Special Features | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | Balanced, nutrient-dense, tailored | Custom formulations based on dog’s needs | Ensure meal portions are adjusted based on your dog’s activity level |
| Just Food For Dogs | Highly targeted, veterinary-designed | Prescription diets with health-specific nutrients | Choose based on your dog’s health concerns (e.g., kidney care, weight loss) |
| Freshpet | Basic but solid fresh nutrition | Standard fresh formulations | Great for everyday nutrition but lacks customization |
💡 Pro Tip: For dogs with special nutritional needs, Just Food For Dogs offers the most comprehensive, health-specific formulations, while Ollie is ideal for owners who want a balanced diet tailored to their dog’s lifestyle.
Comment 10: My dog is a picky eater. Which brand offers the best variety of flavors to keep my dog interested?
For picky eaters, variety is key, and both Ollie and Just Food For Dogs excel in offering a wide range of flavors and textures to keep dogs engaged at mealtime.
Ollie offers multiple protein options, including beef, chicken, turkey, and lamb, allowing you to rotate flavors and keep your dog from getting bored with their meals. The meals are moist and flavorful, thanks to the inclusion of ingredients like blueberries, sweet potatoes, and spinach, which can make meals more enticing for finicky dogs. Ollie’s use of natural, fresh ingredients ensures the food is not only tasty but also nutrient-rich, helping even the pickiest dogs get the nutrition they need.
Just Food For Dogs takes it a step further with a wide variety of proteins and recipes, including unique options like cod, venison, and turkey. These whole-food meals are crafted to appeal to dogs who may tire of standard chicken or beef recipes. Their prescription diets also add variety, particularly if your dog needs a change for medical reasons. The visible chunks of meat and vegetables in Just Food For Dogs meals may also be more appealing for dogs who like their food to resemble what their humans eat.
Freshpet also provides a good range of protein options, from chicken to beef to turkey, but their pre-cooked meals might not be as appealing to a truly picky eater compared to the freshly prepared options from Ollie and Just Food For Dogs.
| Brand | Variety of Flavors | Best for Picky Eaters | 💡 Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ollie | Multiple protein options (beef, lamb, turkey) | Excellent variety and fresh ingredients | Rotate flavors to keep meals exciting |
| Just Food For Dogs | Very wide variety (including venison, cod, lamb) | Best for dogs who tire of standard meals | Use their variety to prevent mealtime boredom |
| Freshpet | Standard (beef, chicken, turkey) | Moderate variety but less customization | Choose different protein types for variety |
💡 Pro Tip: For the pickiest dogs, Just Food For Dogs offers the broadest range of unique flavors, but Ollie also provides plenty of options to keep things fresh and interesting.